• Advanced
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Committees and milestones: from Ripon to the 73rd Amendment

Match each committee to its signature recommendation, order the milestones of local government correctly and avoid the usual mix-ups between similar names.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Advanced questions on the history of local government are rarely 'which year?'. They give four committees and four recommendations to match, or five events to arrange, and the wrong options are built from the confusions students actually make: two Mehtas, two-tier against three-tier, and which committee first asked for constitutional status. This lesson gives each milestone one sharp identifying feature so that matching becomes mechanical.

Before independence

Lord Ripon's resolution of 1882 is treated as the foundation of local self-government in India and is often called its Magna Carta: it favoured elected non-official members and non-official chairpersons for local boards. Under the Government of India Act 1919, local self-government became a 'transferred' subject in the provinces, placed under Indian ministers responsible to the provincial legislature. At independence, the Constitution placed 'local government' in the State List and put village panchayats in Article 40 as a Directive Principle.

The committees and their signature ideas

Four committees to know cold
Committee and yearSignature recommendationCommon trap
Balwant Rai Mehta, 1957Three-tier 'democratic decentralisation': gram panchayat (directly elected), panchayat samiti and zila parishad (indirectly elected); panchayat samiti as the executive body, zila parishad advisory and coordinating, with the Collector as its chairmanConfused with the Ashok Mehta Committee
Ashok Mehta, 1977Two-tier system: zila parishad at the district and mandal panchayat for a group of villages; zila parishad as the executive body; open participation of political partiesThe 'two-tier' answer belongs here, not to 1957
G.V.K. Rao, 1985District as the basic unit of planning; a District Development CommissionerOften swapped with Singhvi
L.M. Singhvi, 1986Constitutional recognition and protection of Panchayati Raj; nyaya panchayats for clusters of villagesThe first strong call for constitutional status

The road to 1992

A Constitution amendment bill on panchayats, the 64th Amendment Bill, was introduced in 1989. It was passed by the Lok Sabha but failed in the Rajya Sabha, partly because it was seen as letting the Union reach into a State subject. A fresh approach followed: the 73rd and 74th Amendment Acts were passed in 1992 and came into force on 24 April 1993 and 1 June 1993 respectively. They did not shift 'local government' out of the State List; instead they bound the States to create and run local bodies on a uniform constitutional frame.

Worked example 1: a four-way match

Match: (P) Balwant Rai Mehta, (Q) Ashok Mehta, (R) G.V.K. Rao, (S) L.M. Singhvi with (1) constitutional recognition, (2) district as basic planning unit with a District Development Commissioner, (3) three-tier system with an advisory zila parishad, (4) two-tier system with mandal panchayats. Step 1: anchor the easiest pair, Ashok Mehta with two tiers: Q-4. Step 2: the older Mehta built three tiers: P-3. Step 3: constitutional recognition is Singhvi's hallmark: S-1. Step 4: R takes the remaining one: R-2. Answer: P-3, Q-4, R-2, S-1.

Worked example 2: chronology with a distractor

Arrange: (a) 64th Amendment Bill fails in the Rajya Sabha, (b) Government of India Act 1919 makes local self-government a transferred subject, (c) Ashok Mehta Committee, (d) Rajasthan inaugurates Panchayati Raj at Nagaur, (e) the 74th Amendment comes into force. Dates: b 1919, d 1959, c 1977, a 1989, e 1993. Order: b, d, c, a, e. The trap is placing the Ashok Mehta Committee before 1959 because its name looks like the 1957 committee's.

Ripon 1882 (foundation) → 1919 Act (transferred subject) → Balwant Rai Mehta 1957 (three tiers) → Rajasthan 1959 → Ashok Mehta 1977 (two tiers) → G.V.K. Rao 1985 (district planning) → L.M. Singhvi 1986 (constitutional status) → 64th Bill 1989 fails → 73rd/74th 1992, in force 1993.

Key takeaways

Give each milestone a single identifying feature and solve matching questions by anchoring the most distinctive pair first. Local government is still a State List subject; the 1992 amendments created a binding constitutional frame within which State laws must work.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which committee recommended a two-tier Panchayati Raj system with mandal panchayats?

    1. Balwant Rai Mehta Committee
    2. L.M. Singhvi Committee
    3. Ashok Mehta Committee
    4. G.V.K. Rao Committee
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The Ashok Mehta Committee (1977) proposed zila parishads and mandal panchayats, a two-tier structure. The Balwant Rai Mehta Committee (1957) proposed three tiers.

  2. 2. Under the Balwant Rai Mehta Committee's scheme, which tier was to be the executive body?

    1. Panchayat samiti
    2. Zila parishad
    3. Gram sabha
    4. Nyaya panchayat
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The 1957 scheme made the panchayat samiti (block level) the executive body, with the zila parishad advisory, coordinating and supervisory.

  3. 3. Which committee is best known for recommending constitutional recognition of Panchayati Raj institutions?

    1. G.V.K. Rao Committee
    2. Balwant Rai Mehta Committee
    3. Ashok Mehta Committee
    4. L.M. Singhvi Committee
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The L.M. Singhvi Committee (1986) recommended that local self-government be constitutionally recognised, protected and preserved.

  4. 4. What happened to the 64th Amendment Bill on panchayats in 1989?

    1. It became law but was struck down by the Supreme Court
    2. It was passed by the Lok Sabha but defeated in the Rajya Sabha
    3. It was never introduced
    4. It was withdrawn after the President returned it
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The 64th Amendment Bill passed the Lok Sabha in 1989 but failed in the Rajya Sabha. The 73rd Amendment followed in 1992.

  5. 5. After the 73rd and 74th Amendments, in which List is 'local government' placed?

    1. Union List
    2. Concurrent List
    3. State List
    4. It was removed from the Seventh Schedule
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Local government remains a State List subject. The amendments created a constitutional framework that State laws must follow; they did not move the subject.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery