- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Value of a vote in the Presidential election: a gentle introduction
See why votes in the Presidential election have different values and learn to work out the value of an MLA's vote, an MP's vote and the winning quota.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
In the election of the President, not every vote counts the same. An elected member of a large State's Assembly casts a vote of higher value than the member from a small State, and the members of Parliament together balance the States. This looks complicated, but it follows from two simple aims written in Article 55: uniformity among the States, and parity between the States as a whole and the Union. All numbers in this lesson are illustrative, not official figures.
Two formulas
- Value of one MLA's vote = population of the State divided by (number of elected members of its Assembly x 1000). The population used is from a census fixed by the Constitution for this purpose (the 1971 census), not from the latest census.
- Value of one MP's vote = total value of the votes of all MLAs of all States divided by the number of elected members of both Houses of Parliament.
If a fraction remains, the rules differ: for an MLA's vote a remainder of 500 or more (one-half or more) adds one; for an MP's vote only a fraction of more than one-half is counted as one, and a smaller fraction is dropped. Only elected members vote; nominated members and members of Legislative Councils do not.
Why a formula?
A State with a large population has more people behind each MLA. The formula gives such an MLA a larger vote value, so every State ends up with a total weight that follows its population. The second formula then gives Parliament a total weight equal to the total weight of all the States together. In the end half of the weight is held by the States and half by Parliament.
Worked example 1: two States
State X has a population of 2,00,00,000 and 100 elected MLAs. Value of one MLA's vote = 2,00,00,000 / (100 x 1000) = 2,00,00,000 / 1,00,000 = 200. State Y has a population of 50,00,000 and 50 elected MLAs. Value = 50,00,000 / (50 x 1000) = 50,00,000 / 50,000 = 100. Each MLA of X has a vote worth twice as much as an MLA of Y, because X has more people per MLA. The total for X is 100 x 200 = 20,000 and for Y is 50 x 100 = 5,000, so together the two States give 25,000.
Worked example 2: the MPs and the quota
Suppose these two States are the only States and there are 25 elected MPs. Value of one MP's vote = 25,000 / 25 = 1,000. The total for the MPs is 25 x 1,000 = 25,000, equal to the total for the MLAs. The whole electoral college is worth 25,000 + 25,000 = 50,000. For a contest between two candidates, a candidate needs more than half: 50,000 / 2 = 25,000, so at least 25,001. If there were 24 elected MPs, then 25,000 / 24 = 1,041.67. The fraction .67 is more than one-half, so it is counted as one, and the value of an MP's vote is 1,042.
| Group | Total value in example |
|---|---|
| MLAs of State X | 20,000 |
| MLAs of State Y | 5,000 |
| All MPs | 25,000 |
| Whole college | 50,000 |
MLA's vote = population / (elected MLAs x 1000). MP's vote = total of all MLAs' votes / elected MPs. Half the weight is with the States, half with Parliament.
Key takeaways
Only elected members vote. The value of an MLA's vote rises with the population per MLA. The value of an MP's vote is found by dividing the MLAs' total by the number of elected MPs, so Parliament balances the States. A winner needs more than half of the value of the valid votes polled, not more than half of the number of voters.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which members do NOT vote in the Presidential election?
- Elected members of the Lok Sabha
- Elected MLAs of a State
- Nominated members of Parliament
- Elected members of the Rajya Sabha
Show answer
Answer: C. Nominated members of Parliament and members of the Legislative Councils do not vote.
-
2. A State has a population of 1,00,00,000 and 100 elected MLAs. The value of one MLA's vote is:
- 10
- 1,000
- 100
- 10,000
Show answer
Answer: C. 1,00,00,000 / (100 x 1000) = 1,00,00,000 / 1,00,000 = 100.
-
3. The total value of all MLAs' votes is 40,000 and there are 20 elected MPs. The value of one MP's vote is:
- 800
- 2,000
- 200
- 20,000
Show answer
Answer: B. 40,000 / 20 = 2,000.
-
4. The whole electoral college is worth 60,000 and every member casts a valid vote. For a two-candidate contest, the minimum value needed to win is:
- 30,000
- 30,001
- 60,000
- 29,999
Show answer
Answer: B. More than half of 60,000 means at least 30,001.
-
5. The aim that gives the States and the Union equal total weight in the electoral college is called:
- parity between States and Union
- a rule on equal taxation
- reservation of States' seats
- supremacy of the Union
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 55 asks for parity between the States as a whole and the Union.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.