• Advanced
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

The Governor: appointment, tenure, powers and discretion

Master the Articles on the Governor's office, compare the Governor's powers with the President's, and judge which acts are truly discretionary.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

At the advanced level, questions on the Governor rarely ask a single fact. They put three or four statements together, mix the Governor's powers with the President's, or describe a political situation and ask what the Governor may lawfully do. To answer them quickly you need the Article numbers in one picture, a clear idea of where the Governor differs from the President, and a firm grip on the narrow area where the Governor acts on his own judgement.

The office in Articles 153 to 162

Article 153 says there shall be a Governor for each State; a proviso added by the Seventh Amendment (1956) allows the same person to be Governor of two or more States. Article 154 vests the executive power of the State in the Governor, exercised directly or through subordinate officers. Article 155 says the President appoints the Governor by warrant under his hand and seal, so the Governor is neither elected directly nor chosen by the State legislature. Article 156 gives a term of five years, but the Governor holds office during the pleasure of the President, so the five years is an outer limit, not a guarantee. There is no impeachment procedure for a Governor.

Article 157 needs only two qualifications: citizenship of India and completion of 35 years of age. Article 158 adds conditions: the Governor is not a member of either House of Parliament or of a State legislature, holds no other office of profit, and his emoluments cannot be diminished during his term. Article 159 has the oath administered by the Chief Justice of the High Court of the State, or in his absence the senior-most judge available. Article 161 is the pardoning power and Article 163 sets up the Council of Ministers to aid and advise the Governor.

President and Governor compared
PointPresidentGovernor
AppointmentElected by an electoral college (Art 54)Appointed by the President (Art 155)
Minimum age35 years35 years
RemovalImpeachment by Parliament (Art 61)At the pleasure of the President; no impeachment
Oath administered byChief Justice of IndiaChief Justice of the State High Court
Pardon of a death sentenceYes (Art 72)No; may suspend, remit or commute (Art 161)
Court-martial sentencesYesNo

Discretion: constitutional and situational

Article 163(1) says the Council of Ministers aids and advises the Governor except where the Constitution requires him to act in his discretion. Article 163(2) adds that if a question arises whether a matter is one of discretion, the Governor's decision is final. This is a key difference from the President, whose advice from the Council of Ministers is binding under Article 74 and who has no comparable express discretion clause.

  • Constitutional discretion: reserving a bill for the President's consideration (Art 200); recommending President's Rule through a report under Art 356; acting as administrator of an adjoining Union Territory when so appointed (Art 239); certain functions in Sixth Schedule areas.
  • Situational discretion: choosing a Chief Minister when no party has a clear majority; dismissing a ministry that cannot prove its majority; dissolving the Assembly when the ministry has lost its majority.
  • Not discretion: dismissing a Chief Minister who still commands a majority on the floor of the House. The Supreme Court in S.R. Bommai (1994) held that the floor of the House is the place to test a majority.

Worked example 1: the pardoning trap

A person is sentenced to death by a Sessions Court for an offence under a law on which the State has executive power. A mercy petition goes to the Governor. What can the Governor do? Step 1: Article 161 lets the Governor grant pardons, reprieves, respites or remissions, and suspend, remit or commute sentences for offences against State-executive laws. Step 2: the Governor cannot grant a full pardon of a death sentence; that power belongs to the President under Article 72. Step 3: so the Governor may commute the sentence to life imprisonment or suspend it, but a complete pardon must come from the President. If the sentence had been passed by a court-martial, the Governor would have no role at all.

Worked example 2: a hung Assembly

After an election no party has a majority. Party X has the largest number of seats; a post-poll alliance of Y and Z claims a majority with letters of support. Step 1: the choice of Chief Minister here is situational discretion, because the advice of an outgoing ministry cannot bind the Governor. Step 2: the Governor's aim is a stable government that commands the Assembly's confidence. Step 3: whoever is invited, the claim must be tested by a floor test within a short time, following the reasoning in Bommai; a Governor's personal assessment of letters is not a substitute for a vote. The correct exam answer is therefore 'invite the person most likely to command a majority and direct a floor test', not 'the largest party automatically'.

Governor: appointed by the President, holds office at the President's pleasure, needs only citizenship and 35 years. Art 161 commutes but never pardons a death sentence. Art 163(2): the Governor decides what is discretionary. The floor of the House decides who has a majority.

Key takeaways

The Governor is an appointee of the Union with a five-year outer term and no impeachment. Learn Articles 153 to 163 in order and the President-Governor table. Discretion is real but narrow, and the test of a majority is always a vote in the Assembly.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which Article, through a proviso added by the Seventh Amendment, allows one person to be Governor of two or more States?

    1. Article 152
    2. Article 153
    3. Article 155
    4. Article 158
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Article 153 provides a Governor for each State; its proviso, added by the Seventh Amendment in 1956, permits the same person to be Governor of two or more States. Article 155 deals with appointment and Article 158 with conditions of office.

  2. 2. What is the minimum age to be appointed Governor of a State?

    1. 25 years
    2. 30 years
    3. 35 years
    4. 40 years
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Article 157 requires only that the person be a citizen of India and have completed 35 years of age.

  3. 3. Who administers the oath of office to a Governor?

    1. The Chief Justice of the High Court of that State
    2. The President of India
    3. The Chief Justice of India
    4. The Speaker of the Legislative Assembly
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 159: the oath is made before the Chief Justice of the High Court of the State, or in his absence the senior-most judge of that court available.

  4. 4. Under Article 161, which of the following can a Governor NOT do?

    1. Commute a death sentence to life imprisonment
    2. Remit a sentence for an offence under a State law
    3. Grant a full pardon to a person sentenced to death
    4. Suspend a sentence for an offence under a State law
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The Governor can suspend, remit or commute a death sentence, but only the President (Art 72) can grant a full pardon of a death sentence.

  5. 5. If a question arises whether a matter falls within the Governor's discretion, whose decision is final under Article 163(2)?

    1. The President
    2. The High Court of the State
    3. The Chief Minister
    4. The Governor
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Article 163(2) makes the Governor's own decision final on whether a matter is one of discretion, and the validity of his act cannot be questioned on the ground that he ought or ought not to have acted in his discretion.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery