- Foundation
- About 11 min
- 5 practice questions
Making a State law and comparing with the Centre
Follow how a bill becomes a State law and compare the powers of the Council with the Rajya Sabha.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The law-making process in the State follows the same pattern as in Parliament, but the upper House has even less power. This lesson shows what happens to a bill and who has the last word.
Ordinary bills
- Introduced in the Assembly (or, in a State with a Council, in the Council).
- Passed by the Assembly, then sent to the Council.
- The Council may pass it, pass it with amendments, reject it or take no action.
- If the Council rejects it or amends it in a way the Assembly does not accept, or takes no action for three months, the Assembly may pass it again and send it back. The Council can then delay it for a further one month at most (Article 197).
- After that, the bill is deemed passed by both Houses in the form the Assembly passed it, and goes to the Governor for assent.
There is no joint sitting in a State. The Assembly's will prevails over the Council in all cases.
Money Bills
Money Bills are introduced only in the Assembly, on the recommendation of the Governor. The Council can only recommend changes within 14 days, which the Assembly may accept or reject.
Worked examples
Example 1. The Council delays a bill for three months, then the Assembly passes it again and the Council delays one more month. Total maximum delay? 3 + 1 = 4 months.
Example 2. Does a State have a joint sitting to resolve a deadlock? No.
| Point | Rajya Sabha | Legislative Council |
|---|---|---|
| Ordinary bills | Can reject; joint sitting resolves deadlock | Can delay at most 3 months then 1 month |
| Money Bills | 14 days, recommend only | 14 days, recommend only |
| Joint sitting | Yes (Article 108) | No |
| Dissolved? | No | No |
The Legislative Council is weaker than the Rajya Sabha: it can only delay an ordinary bill by up to four months in all.
Key takeaways. Bills pass through the Assembly, and the Council can only delay. The Governor then assents, withholds, returns or reserves the bill.
Check your understanding
-
1. What is the maximum total time a Legislative Council can hold up an ordinary bill passed by the Assembly?
- Four months: three months, then one more month
- 14 days
- Six months
- It can reject the bill for good
Show answer
Answer: A. Under Article 197 the Council can delay a bill for three months; if the Assembly passes it again, the Council can delay it for at most one more month.
-
2. Is there a joint sitting of the two Houses of a State legislature to settle a deadlock?
- Yes, under Article 108
- No; the Assembly's will prevails
- Yes, when the Governor calls one
- Only for Money Bills
Show answer
Answer: B. There is no joint sitting at the State level. Article 108 provides joint sittings only for Parliament.
-
3. What can the Legislative Council do with a Money Bill?
- Reject it outright
- Delay it for three months
- Only recommend changes within 14 days, which the Assembly may accept or reject
- Make amendments that bind the Assembly
Show answer
Answer: C. Money Bills go to the Council only for recommendations, to be returned within 14 days.
-
4. Where and how is a State Money Bill introduced?
- In either House, on the Chief Minister's recommendation
- Only in the Legislative Council
- In the Assembly, on the Speaker's recommendation
- Only in the Legislative Assembly, on the Governor's recommendation
Show answer
Answer: D. Money Bills originate only in the Assembly and need the Governor's recommendation.
-
5. Compared with the Rajya Sabha, the Legislative Council
- has no joint sitting to resolve a deadlock and can only delay ordinary bills
- is stronger, as it can veto ordinary bills
- can be dissolved by the Governor
- can call a joint sitting under Article 108
Show answer
Answer: A. The Rajya Sabha can force a joint sitting on an ordinary bill; the Council can only delay, and the Assembly prevails.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.