- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
State legislation, Governor's discretion and President's Rule
Practise how State bills pass, the limits of the Governor's discretion and the effect of President's Rule under Article 356.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The last area covers how State laws are made and what happens when the State machinery fails.
State bills
- An ordinary bill may begin in either House, if there are two.
- The Legislative Council can delay an ordinary bill by three months on first transmission and one month on the second; the Assembly's will finally prevails.
- The Governor may give assent, withhold it, return the bill for reconsideration, or reserve it for the President.
- There is no provision for a joint sitting at the State level.
President's Rule
Article 356 allows the President to take over a State's government when the constitutional machinery has failed. Proclamation must be approved by both Houses of Parliament within two months. The State legislature is suspended or dissolved and the Governor administers the State on behalf of the President. The Supreme Court in the S. R. Bommai case (1994) held that a proclamation is subject to judicial review.
Worked example 1: Council delay
Question: Which House ultimately prevails if the two disagree on an ordinary bill? Working: The Council can only delay. Answer: The Legislative Assembly.
Worked example 2: Bommai
Question: What did the Supreme Court decide in S. R. Bommai about Article 356? Working: It said the power is open to judicial review. Answer: A proclamation can be reviewed by courts.
Article 356: approved by Parliament within two months; judicial review since Bommai (1994).
Key takeaways: The Assembly prevails over the Council; Article 356 is reviewable.
Check your understanding
-
1. A proclamation of President's Rule under Article 356 must be approved by both Houses of Parliament within
- one month
- six months
- one year
- two months
Show answer
Answer: D. An Article 356 proclamation ceases to operate after two months unless approved by both Houses.
-
2. During President's Rule, the State is administered by
- the Governor, on behalf of the President
- the Chief Justice of the High Court
- the Speaker of the Assembly
- the Chief Minister of a neighbouring State
Show answer
Answer: A. Under Article 356 the President assumes the State's executive functions, and the Governor administers the State on his behalf.
-
3. In a State with two Houses, an ordinary bill may be introduced in
- the Assembly only
- either House
- the Council only
- the Assembly only, on the Governor's recommendation
Show answer
Answer: B. Ordinary bills may begin in either House; only Money Bills are confined to the Assembly.
-
4. In S. R. Bommai (1994), the Supreme Court held that
- Article 356 can never be used
- only the President can review a proclamation
- a proclamation under Article 356 is subject to judicial review
- the Council of Ministers continues after the Lok Sabha is dissolved
Show answer
Answer: C. Bommai made Article 356 proclamations reviewable by the courts.
-
5. When the Assembly and the Council disagree on an ordinary bill
- a joint sitting decides
- the Governor decides between them
- the bill lapses
- the Assembly prevails; the Council can only delay
Show answer
Answer: D. There is no joint sitting in a State; the Council can delay a bill but not stop it.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.