- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
What communalism means and how it differs from religion
Define communalism in plain words, tell it apart from religious faith, and recognise the three stages of communal thinking described by the historian Bipan Chandra.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
India is home to followers of many religions who have lived side by side for centuries. Most of the time people of different faiths work, trade, study and celebrate together. Communalism is the idea that breaks this living together into hostile camps. Questions on Indian society often begin by asking what communalism is, so this lesson builds the meaning from the ground up.
Religion and communalism are not the same
Religion is a matter of faith, worship, values and a way of life. A person can be deeply religious and still respect every other faith. Communalism is something different: it is a political ideology that uses religious identity to divide society. It claims that people who share a religion form a single 'community' with the same worldly interests, and that this community stands against other religious communities.
| Religion | Communalism |
|---|---|
| A personal and shared faith in God, values and rituals | A political belief built on religious identity |
| Can live peacefully with other faiths | Sees other religious groups as rivals or enemies |
| Concerned with the spiritual and moral life | Concerned with power, jobs, votes and resources |
| Protected as a right by the Constitution | Opposed by the Constitution's secular values |
So a communal person is not simply a religious person. A communal person believes that a religious group's political and economic interests are shared by all its members and opposed to those of other groups.
The three stages of communal thinking
The historian Bipan Chandra, in his writings on modern India, explained that communal ideology develops in three stages, each more dangerous than the last. You can think of them as three steps on a ladder.
- Stage 1 - common interests: the belief that people who follow the same religion also share the same worldly interests: political, economic, social and cultural.
- Stage 2 - liberal communalism: the belief that the worldly interests of one religious community are dissimilar to, and divergent from, those of another community.
- Stage 3 - extreme communalism: the belief that the interests of different religious communities are mutually incompatible and hostile, so that they cannot live together. This stage is based on fear and hatred and easily leads to violence.
Each stage rests on the one before it. Without first believing in 'common interests' of a religious group, a person cannot believe those interests clash with another group's.
Worked example 1: spotting the stage
A pamphlet says: 'People of our faith in this town must always vote as one bloc because our economic needs are the same.' Step 1: ask whether it claims shared worldly interests - yes, economic needs and votes. Step 2: does it say other groups' interests are opposed or hostile? No. Conclusion: this is Stage 1 thinking. It is still communal, because a religion does not decide a farmer's or trader's economic needs - occupation, region and income do.
Worked example 2: religion or communalism?
Two statements. (a) 'I fast during my festival and pray every morning.' (b) 'People of another religion are taking our jobs, so we must keep them out of our area.' Working: statement (a) describes personal faith and practice - it is religion. Statement (b) treats a whole religious group as an economic enemy and calls for exclusion - it is communalism, close to Stage 3. The test is whether religious identity is being turned into a political or economic weapon against others.
Communalism is not religion: it is a political ideology that turns religious identity into a claim that one community's worldly interests are shared within it and opposed to other communities.
Key takeaways: religion is faith; communalism is the political use of religious identity to divide people. Bipan Chandra's three stages are common interests, liberal communalism (divergent interests) and extreme communalism (hostile, incompatible interests). The later stages grow out of the first.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which statement best defines communalism?
- Strong personal faith in one's own religion
- Regular attendance at a place of worship
- A political ideology that uses religious identity to divide society into rival groups
- Respect for the festivals of all religions
Show answer
Answer: C. Communalism is a political ideology built on religious identity that treats religious groups as rivals. Personal faith, worship and respect for festivals are not communalism.
-
2. According to Bipan Chandra, the belief that followers of one religion share the same political, economic, social and cultural interests is:
- The first stage of communalism
- Extreme communalism
- Secularism
- Liberal communalism
Show answer
Answer: A. The first stage is the belief in common worldly interests among followers of a religion. Liberal communalism adds that these interests differ from other groups'; extreme communalism says they are hostile.
-
3. Which stage of communalism is based on fear and hatred and sees the interests of communities as mutually hostile?
- The first stage
- Liberal communalism
- Religious tolerance
- Extreme communalism
Show answer
Answer: D. Extreme communalism, the third stage, treats the interests of different communities as incompatible and hostile, and is marked by fear, hatred and the risk of violence.
-
4. A person who prays daily and respects people of every faith is best described as:
- Communal in the first stage
- Religious but not communal
- An extreme communalist
- A liberal communalist
Show answer
Answer: B. Faith and prayer alone are religion. Communalism begins only when religious identity is used to claim shared worldly interests against other groups.
-
5. Why does each stage of communalism depend on the one before it?
- Because the stages were laid down in the Constitution in that order
- Because each stage was created by a different law
- Because the stages apply to different religions
- Because a clash of group interests can only be imagined after first believing a religious group has common worldly interests
Show answer
Answer: D. Stages 2 and 3 build on the Stage 1 belief in common interests: one must first imagine a shared group interest before seeing it as different from, or hostile to, another group's.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.