- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
North-East insurgency and AFSPA for revision: causes, provisions and the debate
Revise the general causes of insurgency in the North-East, the main provisions of the Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act, 1958, and the arguments for and against it.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Questions on the North-East test whether you understand why armed movements arose there, what tools the state uses in response, and the long-running debate over the Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act. This lesson organises each for revision.
General causes
| Cause | How it fuels conflict |
|---|---|
| Ethnic diversity and identity | Many distinct communities fear assimilation and loss of land and culture |
| Historical isolation | Limited integration with the rest of the country and a sense of distance |
| Migration | Inflows seen as threatening land, jobs and political power; inter-ethnic clashes |
| Underdevelopment | Limited industry and jobs, so armed groups find recruits |
| Geography | Hilly forested terrain and a narrow land link through the Siliguri Corridor |
| Porous borders | Shared borders with China, Bhutan, Myanmar and Bangladesh, and Nepal next to Sikkim, allow movement of militants, arms and drugs |
Tools of response
- Sixth Schedule: autonomous district councils for tribal areas in Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura and Mizoram, giving self-government on land, forests and customs.
- Peace accords and ceasefires: political negotiation with groups. The Mizo Accord of 1986 is often cited as a successful settlement; Mizoram became a State soon after.
- Development: connectivity, border trade and investment to create jobs.
- Security operations: central armed police forces and, in disturbed areas, the armed forces under AFSPA.
AFSPA, 1958: main provisions
| Provision | Content in brief |
|---|---|
| Declaration | An area can be declared 'disturbed' by the Governor of the State, the Administrator of a Union Territory, or the Central Government |
| Powers | Officers may, after due warning, use force, even causing death, against persons acting against laws prohibiting assemblies or the carrying of weapons; arrest without warrant on reasonable suspicion; enter and search without warrant; destroy arms dumps and hideouts |
| Handing over | Arrested persons are to be handed over to the nearest police station with the least possible delay |
| Protection | No prosecution or legal proceeding against members of the forces without prior sanction of the Central Government |
A separate law on the same lines was made for Jammu and Kashmir in 1990. The areas notified as disturbed have changed over time, so any question on where the Act currently applies needs the latest official notification.
The debate
| Arguments for the Act | Arguments against the Act |
|---|---|
| Armed groups operate in difficult terrain; forces need legal powers to act quickly | Wide powers with legal protection weaken accountability |
| Protection from prosecution prevents harassment of soldiers through motivated cases | Allegations of excesses take long to be examined |
| It applies only to disturbed areas, not the whole country | Prolonged use can alienate local people and feed the conflict |
The Supreme Court upheld the Act's constitutional validity in the Naga People's Movement of Human Rights case while stressing safeguards such as minimum force and prompt handing over of arrested persons. A review committee headed by Justice B. P. Jeevan Reddy, set up in 2004, recommended repealing the Act and placing suitable provisions in another law.
Worked example 1: who can declare?
Statement: 'Only the State government can declare an area disturbed under AFSPA.' Working: the Act lets the Governor, the Administrator of a Union Territory or the Central Government make the declaration. Verdict: incorrect.
Worked example 2: balanced answer
Asked to 'discuss' AFSPA, write both sides: the need for legal powers in insurgency, and the risk to accountability and trust. Then suggest a middle path: periodic review of disturbed-area declarations, quick and transparent inquiry into complaints, and steady withdrawal as normalcy returns.
AFSPA (1958): disturbed-area declaration by Governor, Administrator or Centre; search, arrest and force after warning; arrested persons to nearest police station; prosecution only with Central Government sanction.
Key takeaways
- Identity, isolation, migration, underdevelopment and porous borders drive North-East insurgency.
- The Sixth Schedule and peace accords are political tools; the Mizo Accord (1986) is the classic example.
- Know AFSPA's four provisions and both sides of the debate.
Check your understanding
-
1. Under AFSPA, who can declare an area 'disturbed'?
- Only the Supreme Court
- Only the State Legislative Assembly
- The Governor of the State, the Administrator of a Union Territory or the Central Government
- Only the Chief of the Army Staff
Show answer
Answer: C. The Act allows the Governor, the Administrator of a Union Territory or the Central Government to declare an area disturbed.
-
2. Under AFSPA, a person arrested by the armed forces must be:
- Handed over to the nearest police station with the least possible delay
- Kept in military custody for at least 30 days
- Sent directly to the Supreme Court
- Released without any record
Show answer
Answer: A. The Act requires arrested persons to be handed over to the officer in charge of the nearest police station with the least possible delay. No fixed military custody period exists.
-
3. The Sixth Schedule provides autonomous district councils for tribal areas in:
- Nagaland, Manipur, Sikkim and Arunachal Pradesh
- Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura and Mizoram
- All eight North-Eastern States
- Only Assam
Show answer
Answer: B. The Sixth Schedule covers tribal areas in Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura and Mizoram. Other States have different special provisions.
-
4. The Mizo Accord, often cited as a successful political settlement, was signed in:
- 1966
- 1976
- 1996
- 1986
Show answer
Answer: D. The Mizo Accord was signed in 1986, ending the insurgency in Mizoram; Mizoram became a State soon after.
-
5. Which is an argument commonly made AGAINST AFSPA?
- It applies across the whole country at all times
- It gives the police control over the army
- Wide powers with protection from prosecution can weaken accountability
- It bans all political negotiation
Show answer
Answer: C. Critics argue that wide powers combined with the need for Central Government sanction to prosecute weaken accountability. The Act applies only to disturbed areas and does not bar negotiation.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.