• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Shreya Singhal v Union of India: free speech, blocking and intermediaries

State what the Supreme Court decided in Shreya Singhal (2015) on Sections 66A, 69A and 79 of the IT Act, and answer statement questions on online speech and its limits.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Cyber security policy must protect people without silencing them. The leading case on that balance in India is Shreya Singhal v Union of India (2015). Because it dealt with three different sections and reached three different results, it is a perfect source of tricky statement questions.

Background

Section 66A, added in 2008, punished sending through a computer or communication device information that was 'grossly offensive' or had a 'menacing character', or false information sent to cause 'annoyance', 'inconvenience' and similar harms. Arrests over social media posts led to petitions arguing that the section violated the freedom of speech and expression under Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution.

What the Court decided

Three sections, three outcomes
ProvisionResultMain reason
Section 66AStruck down entirelyIts terms were vague and over-broad; it could punish lawful speech and had a chilling effect. It was not saved by the reasonable restrictions allowed under Article 19(2).
Section 69A (blocking)UpheldIt is narrowly drawn, can be used only for grounds linked to Article 19(2), and the procedure requires reasons to be recorded in writing, so an order can be challenged in court.
Section 79 (intermediaries)Upheld but read downAn intermediary must remove content on 'actual knowledge' only when it receives a court order or a government notification - not merely on any private complaint.

The ideas behind the judgment

  • Discussion, advocacy and incitement: the Court distinguished discussing or even advocating a view, which is protected, from incitement, which may be restricted.
  • Vagueness: a criminal law must tell people clearly what is forbidden; words like 'annoying' or 'offensive' mean different things to different people.
  • Chilling effect: a vague law makes people stay silent even about lawful matters for fear of arrest.
  • Reasonable restrictions: speech may be limited only on grounds listed in Article 19(2), such as security of the State, public order, decency or morality and incitement to an offence.

Worked example 1: statement analysis

Statement: 'In Shreya Singhal, the Supreme Court struck down the government's power to block websites.' Working: the blocking power is Section 69A, which the Court upheld. Only Section 66A was struck down. The statement is incorrect.

Worked example 2: applying the Section 79 reading

Suppose a private person emails a platform demanding that it remove a post he dislikes, without any court order or government notification. Working: after Shreya Singhal, 'actual knowledge' under Section 79 means a court order or government notification. The private demand alone does not make the platform liable for keeping the post, though the platform may still act under its own rules. Trap: do not confuse 'read down' (narrowed meaning) with 'struck down' (removed).

Shreya Singhal (2015): 66A struck down; 69A upheld; 79 read down to 'court order or government notification'.

Key takeaways

  • Section 66A was struck down for vagueness and over-breadth under Article 19(1)(a).
  • The blocking power in Section 69A survived because of its safeguards.
  • Section 79's 'actual knowledge' was narrowed to court orders or government notifications.
  • Only incitement, not discussion or advocacy, can be curbed on the ground of public order.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In Shreya Singhal v Union of India (2015), what happened to Section 69A of the IT Act?

    1. It was struck down along with Section 66A
    2. It was upheld as constitutionally valid
    3. It was transferred to the Indian Penal Code
    4. It was replaced by Section 66F
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The Court upheld Section 69A because it is narrowly drawn and has procedural safeguards, including recorded reasons. Only Section 66A was struck down.

  2. 2. Section 66A was struck down mainly because:

    1. Its vague and over-broad terms could punish lawful speech, violating Article 19(1)(a)
    2. It was passed without a vote in Parliament
    3. It applied only to foreign websites
    4. It gave too little punishment for cyber terrorism
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The Court held that terms like 'grossly offensive' and 'annoyance' were vague, chilled lawful speech and could not be saved under Article 19(2).

  3. 3. After Shreya Singhal, an intermediary is said to have 'actual knowledge' requiring it to remove content under Section 79 when it receives:

    1. Any complaint from any user
    2. A message from a news channel
    3. A court order or a notification from the appropriate government
    4. A request from a rival company
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The Court read down Section 79 so that actual knowledge means a court order or government notification, protecting platforms from having to judge every private complaint.

  4. 4. Consider the statements: 1. Section 66A was 'read down' rather than struck down. 2. The Court held that discussion and advocacy are protected, while incitement can be restricted. Which is/are correct?

    1. 1 only
    2. Both 1 and 2
    3. Neither 1 nor 2
    4. 2 only
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Statement 1 is wrong - Section 66A was struck down in full; it was Section 79 that was read down. Statement 2 correctly states the Court's distinction.

  5. 5. Under which Article of the Constitution may reasonable restrictions be placed on the freedom of speech and expression?

    1. Article 21
    2. Article 32
    3. Article 14
    4. Article 19(2)
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Article 19(2) lists the grounds for reasonable restrictions on the freedom guaranteed by Article 19(1)(a). Article 21 is life and personal liberty, 32 the right to constitutional remedies and 14 equality.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery