| Question | Realism | Idealism (liberal internationalism) |
|---|---|---|
| What is the world like? | Anarchic - there is no world government above states | Capable of order through law, institutions and cooperation |
| What drives states? | Power and security | Shared interests, rules and values as well as power |
| Best tools | Military strength, balance of power, alliances | International law, the UN, treaties, disarmament |
| View of morality | Secondary to survival | An important guide to policy |
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Sandhi | Making peace by treaty |
| Vigraha | Hostility or war |
| Asana | Staying quiet - waiting without action |
| Yana | Marching or preparing for attack |
| Samshraya | Seeking shelter or alliance with a stronger power |
| Dvaidhibhava | Double policy - peace with one state, hostility with another |
Realism: anarchy, power, security. Idealism: law, institutions, cooperation. Hard, soft and smart power. Kautilya: mandala (neighbour = likely enemy, neighbour's neighbour = likely friend) and six-fold policy.
Key takeaways: national interest - security, prosperity, autonomy - explains continuity. Realism and idealism give opposite readings of the same choices, and Indian policy contains elements of both. Kautilya's mandala and six-fold policy show that realist thinking about statecraft has deep Indian roots.