Realism and idealism compared
QuestionRealismIdealism (liberal internationalism)
What is the world like?Anarchic - there is no world government above statesCapable of order through law, institutions and cooperation
What drives states?Power and securityShared interests, rules and values as well as power
Best toolsMilitary strength, balance of power, alliancesInternational law, the UN, treaties, disarmament
View of moralitySecondary to survivalAn important guide to policy
Kautilya's six-fold policy
TermMeaning
SandhiMaking peace by treaty
VigrahaHostility or war
AsanaStaying quiet - waiting without action
YanaMarching or preparing for attack
SamshrayaSeeking shelter or alliance with a stronger power
DvaidhibhavaDouble policy - peace with one state, hostility with another

Realism: anarchy, power, security. Idealism: law, institutions, cooperation. Hard, soft and smart power. Kautilya: mandala (neighbour = likely enemy, neighbour's neighbour = likely friend) and six-fold policy.

Key takeaways: national interest - security, prosperity, autonomy - explains continuity. Realism and idealism give opposite readings of the same choices, and Indian policy contains elements of both. Kautilya's mandala and six-fold policy show that realist thinking about statecraft has deep Indian roots.