- Advanced
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Thinking tools: national interest, realism, idealism and Kautilya's mandala
Use the ideas of national interest, realism, idealism and hard, soft and smart power, together with Kautilya's mandala and six-fold policy, to analyse India's foreign policy choices.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Advanced questions on India's foreign policy rarely ask only 'when' or 'where'. They ask why a choice was made and how it can be judged. For that you need a small set of thinking tools: the idea of national interest, the main schools of international relations thought, the forms of power, and India's own classical tradition of statecraft.
National interest
National interest is the set of goals a state treats as vital: survival and territorial security, economic well-being, autonomy of decision and the protection of its values and citizens. Different governments may rank these goals differently, but the core - security, prosperity and autonomy - stays remarkably stable. That stability is one reason analysts speak of continuity in India's foreign policy across governments.
Two classic lenses: realism and idealism
| Question | Realism | Idealism (liberal internationalism) |
|---|---|---|
| What is the world like? | Anarchic - there is no world government above states | Capable of order through law, institutions and cooperation |
| What drives states? | Power and security | Shared interests, rules and values as well as power |
| Best tools | Military strength, balance of power, alliances | International law, the UN, treaties, disarmament |
| View of morality | Secondary to survival | An important guide to policy |
Other lenses add detail. Liberal thinkers stress that trade and interdependence make conflict costly. Constructivists argue that ideas and identity - for example, India's identity as a former colony - shape what a state sees as its interest. In practice India's policy mixes these: Nehru's emphasis on the UN, disarmament and peaceful co-existence is usually read as idealist, while the pursuit of autonomy and, later, of nuclear deterrence is usually read as realist.
Forms of power
- Hard power - getting others to act through force or payment: military strength, sanctions, economic inducements.
- Soft power - getting others to want what you want through attraction: culture, values, policies seen as legitimate. The term was popularised by Joseph Nye.
- Smart power - combining hard and soft power so that each supports the other.
Kautilya: India's classical realism
Kautilya's Arthashastra describes a mandala, or circle of states, around a ruler seeking to expand his power (the vijigishu). The immediate neighbour is treated as a likely enemy (ari), and the neighbour's neighbour as a likely friend (mitra), with further rings beyond. The text also sets out a six-fold policy (shadgunya):
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Sandhi | Making peace by treaty |
| Vigraha | Hostility or war |
| Asana | Staying quiet - waiting without action |
| Yana | Marching or preparing for attack |
| Samshraya | Seeking shelter or alliance with a stronger power |
| Dvaidhibhava | Double policy - peace with one state, hostility with another |
Worked example 1: which lens?
Statement: 'India supported the UN, international law and disarmament because a world governed by rules protects weaker states.' Working: the argument relies on institutions and rules creating order - an idealist or liberal reading. Statement: 'India built a nuclear deterrent because no outside power could guarantee its security.' Working: the argument rests on self-help in an anarchic system - a realist reading. One country, two readings: exam answers that show both lenses score better than one-sided ones.
Worked example 2: applying the mandala
Suppose state X has a neighbour Y, and Y has another neighbour Z on its far side. By the mandala logic, X treats Y as a likely rival and Z as a natural partner, because Z also has reason to watch Y. Working: the mandala is a model of geography shaping alignments. Note that it is a general model of statecraft, not a description of any modern relationship.
Realism: anarchy, power, security. Idealism: law, institutions, cooperation. Hard, soft and smart power. Kautilya: mandala (neighbour = likely enemy, neighbour's neighbour = likely friend) and six-fold policy.
Key takeaways: national interest - security, prosperity, autonomy - explains continuity. Realism and idealism give opposite readings of the same choices, and Indian policy contains elements of both. Kautilya's mandala and six-fold policy show that realist thinking about statecraft has deep Indian roots.
Check your understanding
-
1. Consider the following statements: 1. Realism holds that there is no world government above states. 2. Idealism holds that international institutions and law can help create order. Which is/are correct?
- 1 only
- 2 only
- Both 1 and 2
- Neither 1 nor 2
Show answer
Answer: C. Both statements are correct. Realists stress anarchy (no authority above states); idealists stress the ordering role of law and institutions.
-
2. In Kautilya's six-fold policy, 'samshraya' means:
- Seeking shelter or alliance with a stronger power
- Making peace by treaty
- Marching to attack
- Staying quiet and waiting
Show answer
Answer: A. Samshraya is seeking shelter with a stronger power. Sandhi is peace by treaty, yana is marching and asana is waiting.
-
3. According to Kautilya's mandala, the neighbour of one's immediate neighbour is regarded as:
- A likely enemy
- A neutral to be ignored
- A vassal state
- A likely friend
Show answer
Answer: D. In the mandala the immediate neighbour (ari) is a likely enemy and the neighbour's neighbour (mitra) a likely friend, since both share an interest in watching the state between them.
-
4. Which of the following is the best example of soft power?
- A ban on exports to a rival state
- Foreign students choosing to study a country's classical arts because they admire them
- A large military parade
- A threat to cut off aid
Show answer
Answer: B. Soft power works through attraction. Students drawn to a country's arts are attracted, not forced or paid. Bans, parades and threats are forms of hard power.
-
5. 'Dvaidhibhava' in the Arthashastra refers to:
- Peace with one state and hostility with another at the same time
- Complete neutrality towards all
- Declaring war on all neighbours
- Giving up sovereignty to a stronger state
Show answer
Answer: A. Dvaidhibhava is the double policy: making peace with one state while being hostile to another.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.