- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
The Constitution, Article 51 and who runs India's foreign policy
Know what Article 51 asks of the State, why foreign affairs belong to the Union, what Article 253 allows, and the roles of the Ministry of External Affairs and the Indian Foreign Service.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Foreign policy is not made in a vacuum. India's Constitution gives it a direction and decides which government handles it, and a set of institutions turns decisions into action. This lesson explains the constitutional basis and the machinery in simple terms.
Article 51: the Constitution's guidance on world affairs
Article 51 is in Part IV of the Constitution, the Directive Principles of State Policy. It is titled 'Promotion of international peace and security' and says that the State shall endeavour to do four things:
| Clause | What the State shall endeavour to do |
|---|---|
| (a) | Promote international peace and security |
| (b) | Maintain just and honourable relations between nations |
| (c) | Foster respect for international law and treaty obligations in the dealings of organised peoples with one another |
| (d) | Encourage settlement of international disputes by arbitration |
Like all Directive Principles, Article 51 cannot be enforced in a court. Article 37 says these principles are nevertheless fundamental in the governance of the country and that the State has a duty to apply them in making laws. So Article 51 is a guiding value, not a legal right.
Why foreign affairs belong to the Union
The Seventh Schedule divides subjects between the Union and the states. Foreign affairs, diplomatic and consular representation, participation in international bodies such as the United Nations, treaties with foreign countries, and war and peace are all in the Union List. That is why foreign policy is run by the Union (central) government; states do not have foreign policies of their own.
Article 253 adds that Parliament can make a law for the whole or any part of India to implement any treaty, agreement or convention with other countries, or any decision taken at an international conference or body - even if the subject would otherwise be in the State List.
Who does the work
- The Prime Minister and the Union Cabinet take the major decisions; the Prime Minister's Office plays a large part.
- The Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) is the ministry in charge of foreign relations. It is headed by the Minister of External Affairs.
- The Foreign Secretary is the senior-most career diplomat and the administrative head of the MEA.
- The Indian Foreign Service (IFS), created in 1946, is the career service of diplomats. Its members work at the MEA in New Delhi and in India's missions abroad.
- The National Security Council, set up in 1998, and the National Security Adviser advise on strategic matters.
- Other ministries - Defence, Commerce, Finance and others - handle the parts of foreign relations that touch their work.
- Parliament debates foreign policy, questions ministers, examines it through a standing committee on external affairs and votes the money the MEA spends.
India's missions abroad have different names. In most countries India has an embassy headed by an ambassador. In other Commonwealth countries the mission is a High Commission headed by a High Commissioner. Consulates in other cities help with passports and visas and assist Indian citizens.
Worked example 1: can Article 51 be taken to court?
Question: a citizen files a case asking a court to order the government to settle a dispute with another country by arbitration, relying on Article 51(d). Working: Article 51 is in Part IV, the Directive Principles. Article 37 says these are not enforceable by any court. So the court cannot enforce Article 51 as a right, though the principle guides policy.
Worked example 2: ambassador or High Commissioner?
Question: what is the head of India's mission called in (a) the United Kingdom and (b) Japan? Working: the United Kingdom is a member of the Commonwealth, so India's representative there is a High Commissioner. Japan is not a Commonwealth member, so India's representative there is an ambassador.
Article 51 (Part IV, Directive Principle): peace and security, honourable relations, respect for international law and treaties, arbitration. Foreign affairs = Union List. Article 253 = Parliament makes laws to implement treaties.
Key takeaways: Article 51 sets four non-justiciable aims for India's conduct in the world. Foreign affairs are a Union subject, and Article 253 lets Parliament legislate to carry out treaties. The MEA, led by the Minister of External Affairs and run by the Foreign Secretary and the Indian Foreign Service, does the daily work, with the Prime Minister, the Cabinet, other ministries and Parliament all playing a part.
Check your understanding
-
1. Article 51 of the Constitution of India is part of which section?
- Fundamental Rights
- Fundamental Duties
- Emergency Provisions
- Directive Principles of State Policy
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 51 is in Part IV, the Directive Principles of State Policy. Fundamental Duties are in Article 51A, a separate article in Part IVA.
-
2. Which of the following is NOT one of the aims listed in Article 51?
- Encourage settlement of international disputes by arbitration
- Maintain just and honourable relations between nations
- Keep Indian troops stationed in every neighbouring country
- Foster respect for international law and treaty obligations
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 51 speaks of peace and security, honourable relations, respect for international law and treaties, and arbitration. Stationing troops abroad is not among its aims.
-
3. Who is the administrative head of the Ministry of External Affairs?
- The Foreign Secretary
- The Chief Justice of India
- The Speaker of the Lok Sabha
- The Comptroller and Auditor General
Show answer
Answer: A. The Foreign Secretary is the senior-most career diplomat and the administrative head of the Ministry of External Affairs. The ministry's political head is the Minister of External Affairs.
-
4. India's diplomatic mission in another Commonwealth country is usually headed by:
- A consul
- A High Commissioner
- A governor
- A resident commissioner
Show answer
Answer: B. Between Commonwealth countries, missions are called High Commissions and their heads High Commissioners. In other countries the head is an ambassador.
-
5. What does Article 253 of the Constitution allow?
- States to sign treaties with foreign countries
- The President to declare war without the Cabinet
- Courts to enforce the Directive Principles
- Parliament to make laws to implement treaties, even on State List subjects
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 253 lets Parliament make laws for the whole or any part of India to give effect to treaties, agreements and international decisions, even on subjects otherwise in the State List.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.