• Advanced
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

How groupings are designed: treaties, secretariats, presidencies and decision rules

Compare how groupings are built - formal treaty or informal forum, secretariat or rotating presidency, consensus or weighted voting - and explain what each design can and cannot do.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

At the advanced level, questions move from 'where is it based?' to 'why does it behave this way?' Much of the answer lies in design. A grouping founded on a binding treaty, with a permanent secretariat and voting rules, behaves very differently from an informal forum that meets once a year under a rotating chair. Learning to read design lets you judge statements about any grouping, even one you know little about.

Four design questions

  1. Legal basis: is there a founding treaty or charter, or only a declaration or an understanding?
  2. Permanent body: is there a secretariat, or does the work rotate with a presidency?
  3. Decision rule: consensus or unanimity, majority voting, or voting weighted by money contributed?
  4. Binding force: do members have to obey decisions, or are decisions political commitments only?
Design compared
GroupingLegal basisPermanent bodyHow it decides
SAARCCharterSecretariat, KathmanduUnanimity; bilateral and contentious issues excluded
ASEANBangkok Declaration, later a formal charterSecretariat, JakartaConsultation and consensus
European UnionTreaties, including MaastrichtCommon institutionsSome laws binding on members; majority voting in some areas
NATONorth Atlantic TreatyHeadquarters, BrusselsConsensus; Article 5 mutual defence
IMF and World BankArticles of AgreementHeadquarters, Washington, D.C.Votes weighted by each member's financial share
WTOFounding agreementSecretariat, GenevaConsensus in practice; binding dispute settlement
SCOCharterSecretariat, Beijing; anti-terrorism structure, TashkentConsensus
G20No charterNone; rotating presidencyConsensus statements, not binding
BRICSNo charterNone; rotating chairConsensus; but owns the treaty-based New Development Bank
QuadNo treatyNoneJoint statements among four partners

Formal versus informal: the trade-off

A formal design gives permanence and the power to bind: the WTO can rule that a member has broken trade rules, and the EU can make laws its members must follow. The price is slow decision-making and a loss of freedom for members. An informal design such as the G20, BRICS or the Quad is flexible: leaders can take up a new problem at the next summit without amending any treaty. The price is that statements are political commitments, not obligations, and continuity depends on whoever holds the chair.

The G20 manages continuity without a secretariat through the troika: the previous, current and next presidencies work together. In 2023 the troika was Indonesia (2022 president), India (2023) and Brazil (2024).

Worked example 1: why SAARC cannot settle disputes

Statement: 'SAARC is a suitable forum for settling the India-Pakistan dispute.' Working: the SAARC Charter keeps bilateral and contentious issues out of its deliberations, and decisions need unanimity. A dispute between two members is therefore outside its agenda, and either side could block any decision. The statement is false, and the same design explains why tensions between two members can stall the whole grouping.

Worked example 2: weighted voting

Suppose (illustrative figures) a fund has three members whose votes follow their financial shares: A has 45 per cent, B 35 per cent and C 20 per cent, and a major decision needs 85 per cent of votes. Working: without A the others hold 35 + 20 = 55 per cent; without B, 45 + 20 = 65; without C, 45 + 35 = 80. Every total is below 85, so each member alone can block a major decision. In the Bretton Woods institutions votes follow financial shares, which is why developing countries press for the shares to be revised as their economies grow.

Treaty + secretariat + binding rules = durable but slow. No charter + rotating chair = flexible but non-binding. Read the design and the behaviour follows.

Key takeaways: ask four questions of any grouping - legal basis, permanent body, decision rule, binding force. SAARC's unanimity and exclusion of bilateral issues explain its stalls; the G20's informality explains both its speed and its non-binding outcomes; weighted voting explains the reform debate at the IMF and World Bank.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Consider: (1) The G20 has a permanent secretariat. (2) The G20 maintains continuity through a troika of past, present and next presidencies. Which is/are correct?

    1. 1 only
    2. 2 only
    3. Both 1 and 2
    4. Neither 1 nor 2
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Statement 1 is wrong: the G20 has no permanent secretariat. Statement 2 is right: the previous, current and next presidencies work together as the troika.

  2. 2. Which feature of the SAARC Charter keeps disputes between two members off its agenda?

    1. The exclusion of bilateral and contentious issues
    2. Weighted voting by financial share
    3. A rotating troika of presidencies
    4. Majority voting on trade matters
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The SAARC Charter excludes bilateral and contentious issues from its deliberations, and its decisions need unanimity.

  3. 3. In which institution do members' votes depend on their financial share?

    1. The Quad
    2. SAARC
    3. BRICS
    4. The IMF
    Show answer

    Answer: D. IMF votes are weighted by each member's financial share (quota). The Quad and BRICS have no voting system of this kind, and SAARC works by unanimity.

  4. 4. Suppose (illustrative) votes are A 50 per cent, B 30 per cent, C 20 per cent and a decision needs 75 per cent. Which member(s) can block a decision alone?

    1. Only A
    2. A and B
    3. Only C
    4. None of them
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Without A the rest have 50 per cent; without B, 70 per cent; without C, 80 per cent. Only the first two totals fall short of 75, so A and B can each block; C cannot.

  5. 5. Which grouping has no founding treaty but owns a treaty-based development bank?

    1. SAARC
    2. ASEAN
    3. BRICS
    4. NATO
    Show answer

    Answer: C. BRICS has no charter or secretariat, but its members set up the New Development Bank, headquartered in Shanghai, by a formal agreement.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery