Design compared
GroupingLegal basisPermanent bodyHow it decides
SAARCCharterSecretariat, KathmanduUnanimity; bilateral and contentious issues excluded
ASEANBangkok Declaration, later a formal charterSecretariat, JakartaConsultation and consensus
European UnionTreaties, including MaastrichtCommon institutionsSome laws binding on members; majority voting in some areas
NATONorth Atlantic TreatyHeadquarters, BrusselsConsensus; Article 5 mutual defence
IMF and World BankArticles of AgreementHeadquarters, Washington, D.C.Votes weighted by each member's financial share
WTOFounding agreementSecretariat, GenevaConsensus in practice; binding dispute settlement
SCOCharterSecretariat, Beijing; anti-terrorism structure, TashkentConsensus
G20No charterNone; rotating presidencyConsensus statements, not binding
BRICSNo charterNone; rotating chairConsensus; but owns the treaty-based New Development Bank
QuadNo treatyNoneJoint statements among four partners

Treaty + secretariat + binding rules = durable but slow. No charter + rotating chair = flexible but non-binding. Read the design and the behaviour follows.

Key takeaways: ask four questions of any grouping - legal basis, permanent body, decision rule, binding force. SAARC's unanimity and exclusion of bilateral issues explain its stalls; the G20's informality explains both its speed and its non-binding outcomes; weighted voting explains the reform debate at the IMF and World Bank.