• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Mixed traps and elimination for economy questions

Combine herders, silk, lakes, tourism, roads and the region's status in mixed questions, and learn how to use elimination, statement checking and assertion-reason logic.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Real papers mix everything. A single question may have an option about a herder, one about a lake and one about a river. This lesson gives a routine for mixed items and a drill of the last topics.

Quick recall table

Mixed recall
TopicFactTrap
BakarwalsSheep and goats; move to margs in summerDo not call them fishermen
TranshumanceSeasonal herd movementNot a farming method of fields
SericultureSilkworms on mulberryNot growing saffron
Dal LakeFloating vegetable gardens, shikaras, houseboatsJhelum does not flow through Dal
Wular LakeLarge freshwater lake; fish and water chestnutNot in Srinagar city
Vaishno DeviTrikuta hills, Jammu regionNot in the Valley
AmarnathCave shrine visited in summerNot a lake
Jawahar TunnelBanihal, through the Pir PanjalNot on the Zojila road
Union TerritorySince 31 October 2019Check the current legal position for later change

Routine for a mixed question

  1. Read the stem Is it asking for correct or incorrect?
  2. Underline clue words Place, season, plant part, river
  3. Cross out wrong regions Valley or Jammu?
  4. Cross out absolute words Only, never, always
  5. Choose and re-read Does your answer fit every word of the stem?
Five steps

Statement and assertion-reason logic

In a statement question, test each statement alone. Only then match with the options. In an assertion-reason question, ask three things: Is the assertion true? Is the reason true? Does the reason explain the assertion? A true reason that does not explain the assertion is the classic trap.

Worked example 1: incorrect statement

Question: 'Which is incorrect?' (a) Bakarwals herd sheep and goats. (b) Margs are summer pastures. (c) Sericulture needs mulberry leaves. (d) Transhumance means growing two crops a year. Working: (d) is wrong; transhumance is seasonal herd movement. Answer: (d).

Worked example 2: assertion-reason

Assertion: Many mountain roads of the region are closed in winter. Reason: Snow and landslides block them. Working: both true, and the reason explains the assertion. Answer: both true, reason explains.

Worked example 3: true reason, wrong explanation

Assertion: Salal is on the Chenab. Reason: The Chenab is a long river. Working: both are true, but length does not explain why Salal is on it. Answer: both true, but the reason does not explain the assertion.

Worked example 4: sector and place

Question: 'A pony-man at Pahalgam and a hydropower engineer at Uri are in...' Working: the pony-man provides a service (tertiary); producing power is secondary. Answer: tertiary and secondary respectively.

Worked example 5: pilgrimage

Question: 'The shrine in the Trikuta hills' is...' Working: Trikuta hills + goddess shrine = Vaishno Devi, which is in the Jammu region. Answer: Vaishno Devi.

Two more drills

Worked example 6: 'Which of these is a tertiary activity?' (a) shearing sheep, (b) running a guesthouse at Pahalgam, (c) weaving a carpet, (d) generating power. Working: (a) is primary, (c) and (d) are secondary, and (b) provides a service. Answer: (b).

Worked example 7: 'Choose the correct pair.' (a) Margs : floating gardens, (b) Wular : water chestnut, (c) Kandi : saffron, (d) Karewa : herds in winter. Working: (a) is wrong because margs are meadows; (c) is wrong because Kandi is dry foothills; (d) is wrong because karewas are terraces. Answer: (b).

  • Words that often signal a wrong option: only, never, always, all, none.
  • Words that often fit a correct option: mainly, generally, traditionally.
  • Check the region word (Jammu or Valley) before the detail.

Test each statement alone, cross out absolutes, and check the region before the answer.

Key takeaways: use the five-step routine. Test statements one by one. A reason can be true yet not explain the assertion. Keep the recall table in your head: herders, silk, lakes, shrines, tunnel.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which statement is incorrect?

    1. Margs are summer pastures
    2. Transhumance means growing two crops in one year
    3. Bakarwals rear sheep and goats
    4. Sericulture uses mulberry leaves
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Transhumance is the seasonal movement of herds, not double cropping.

  2. 2. Vaishno Devi shrine is in the:

    1. Trikuta hills of the Jammu region
    2. Gulmarg meadow
    3. Dal Lake
    4. Zojila pass
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The shrine is in the Trikuta hills.

  3. 3. The Jawahar Tunnel passes through which range?

    1. Great Himalaya at Gulmarg
    2. Zanskar
    3. Shiwalik at Kandi
    4. Pir Panjal
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The tunnel at Banihal crosses the Pir Panjal.

  4. 4. Assertion: Dal Lake supports floating vegetable gardens. Reason: Families grow vegetables on floating beds. Choose:

    1. Both true but unrelated
    2. Assertion true, reason false
    3. Both true, and the reason explains the assertion
    4. Assertion false, reason true
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The reason describes how the floating gardens work.

  5. 5. A guide at Sonamarg belongs to:

    1. Primary sector
    2. Secondary sector
    3. Mining sector
    4. Tertiary sector
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Guiding visitors is a service.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery