• Advanced
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Statement questions: reading 'only', 'first' and 'both' with care

Solve multi-statement questions on the personalities of Jammu and Kashmir by testing each statement alone and watching the small words.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Advanced papers rarely ask for a name alone. They give three or four statements about several people and ask which are correct. Such questions are won by two habits: testing every statement on its own, and noticing the small words, such as only, first, both and always, which turn a true statement into a false one. This lesson trains both habits on the personalities of Jammu and Kashmir.

The statement method

Solving a statement question

  1. Split Treat every statement as its own true or false question
  2. Mark Write T or F beside each, using what you know firmly
  3. Watch the small words Only, first, both and all need extra proof
  4. Combine Choose the option that matches your marks, not your feeling
Four steps

Why small words matter

Testing statements
StatementVerdictReason
Kalhana wrote the RajataranginiTrue12th-century chronicle in Sanskrit verse
Kalhana wrote the Rajatarangini and the KathasaritsagaraFalseThe second is by Somadeva
Lal Ded and Nund Rishi both wrote shruksFalseLal Ded's verses are vakhs
Gulab Singh founded the Dogra stateTrue1846
Only Hari Singh was a Dogra ruler in this courseFalseGulab Singh, Ranbir Singh and Pratap Singh also ruled
Brigadier Rajinder Singh received the Maha Vir ChakraTrueHonoured after his death
Habba Khatoon was a SultanFalseShe was a poet-queen
Abhinavagupta wrote on both philosophy and aestheticsTrueTantraloka and Abhinavabharati

Look at the second row. Half the statement is true, because Kalhana did write the Rajatarangini. The false half spoils the whole. Examiners build such statements on purpose: they join a true fact with a false one using the word and. Always test each half. The fifth row works the other way: the word only turns a true statement into a false one, because it denies the other Dogra rulers.

Here is a longer practice with the same method. Suppose a question says: (i) Avantivarman was a Utpala king. (ii) Suyya was his engineer-minister. (iii) Anandavardhana lived in the 9th century. (iv) All three lived in the 12th century. Test each. Statement (i) is true. Statement (ii) is true. Statement (iii) is true. Statement (iv) is false: the word all and the century 12th make it wrong, since the 12th century is the age of Kalhana. So the correct set is (i), (ii) and (iii). Such four-statement questions are only three or four small questions in disguise, and a calm student who writes T or F beside each cannot be tricked by the long stem.

Worked examples

Example 1. Consider: (i) Lalitaditya is linked with the Martand Sun Temple. (ii) Avantivarman founded Avantipura. (iii) Didda was a Sultan. Which are correct? Statements (i) and (ii) are true. Statement (iii) is false because Didda was a queen of the 10th century. The answer is (i) and (ii) only.

Example 2. Consider: (i) Zorawar Singh led campaigns for Gulab Singh. (ii) He founded the Dogra state. (iii) He died in 1841. Statement (i) is true, (ii) is false because Gulab Singh founded it, and (iii) is true as taught in this course. So (i) and (iii).

Example 3. Consider: (i) Anandavardhana wrote the Dhvanyaloka. (ii) Mammata wrote the Dhvanyaloka. (iii) Mammata wrote the Kavyaprakasha. Statements (i) and (iii) are true, (ii) is false.

Example 4. Consider: (i) Maqbool Sherwani delayed raiders at Baramulla. (ii) Brigadier Rajinder Singh held back raiders at Uri. (iii) Both were honoured with the Maha Vir Chakra. Statements (i) and (ii) are true. Statement (iii) contains both and goes beyond the facts of this course, since only the Brigadier is named as receiving that honour here. Treat it as not supported, so choose (i) and (ii).

Test every half of every statement. One false half makes the whole false.

— Rule

Key takeaways

  • Split each statement and test it alone.
  • A true half joined by and to a false half is false.
  • Only, first and both need extra proof; if the course does not support them, do not accept them.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. (i) Lal Ded wrote vakhs. (ii) Nund Rishi wrote vakhs. Which is correct?

    1. (ii) only
    2. Both (i) and (ii)
    3. (i) only
    4. Neither (i) nor (ii)
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Nund Rishi's verses are shruks.

  2. 2. (i) Gulab Singh founded the Dogra state in 1846. (ii) Zorawar Singh was his general. Which is correct?

    1. Both (i) and (ii)
    2. (i) only
    3. (ii) only
    4. Neither (i) nor (ii)
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true.

  3. 3. 'Kalhana wrote the Rajatarangini and the Narmamala.' This statement is:

    1. True, both are chronicles
    2. True, both are 12th century
    3. False, because Kalhana wrote neither
    4. False, because the Narmamala is by Kshemendra
    Show answer

    Answer: D. One half is false.

  4. 4. 'Only Gulab Singh ruled in the Dogra line in this course.' This statement is:

    1. True, since he founded the line
    2. False, because Ranbir Singh and Hari Singh also ruled
    3. True, since he signed the Treaty
    4. False, because the Dogra line had no founder
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The word only is the trap.

  5. 5. Which statement is correct?

    1. Somadeva wrote the Rajatarangini
    2. Abhinavagupta wrote the Tantraloka
    3. Mammata wrote the Narmamala
    4. Bilhana wrote the Dhvanyaloka
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Only the first pair is right.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery