- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Executive traps: Governor and Lieutenant Governor, Chief Minister and Chief Secretary
Tell apart offices that sound alike: Governor, Lieutenant Governor, Chief Minister, Chief Secretary and Speaker, with their appointing authority.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Many mistakes in this topic come from offices with similar names. The questions often ask 'who appoints', 'who is the head' or 'who is responsible to whom'. This lesson trains you to answer with a simple table, and shows the traps that catch careless students.
Who is who
| Office | Appointed or chosen by | Role |
|---|---|---|
| Lieutenant Governor | The President | Head of the Union Territory; President's representative |
| Governor (old state) | The President | Head of the former state; no longer applies since 2019 |
| Chief Minister | The Lieutenant Governor | Leads the elected government |
| Chief Secretary | The government | Head of the permanent civil service |
| Speaker | Elected by members of the Assembly | Presides over the Assembly |
| Divisional Commissioner | The government | Heads a division of districts |
The main traps
- Governor or Lieutenant Governor? Since 2019 the head of the Union Territory is the Lieutenant Governor. Choose 'Governor' only for the period before 31 October 2019.
- Chief Minister or Chief Secretary? The Chief Minister is a political leader appointed after an election. The Chief Secretary is a civil servant. Their titles look alike, but the jobs are different.
- Who appoints the Chief Minister? The Lieutenant Governor, not the President and not the Speaker.
- To whom is the Council of Ministers responsible? To the Legislative Assembly, not to the Lieutenant Governor.
- Who may dissolve the Assembly? The Lieutenant Governor acts under the Act; the Speaker cannot.
Chain of appointment
- President Appoints the Lieutenant Governor
- Lieutenant Governor Appoints the Chief Minister
- Chief Minister Advises on the other ministers
- Council of Ministers Answers to the Assembly
The Darbar Move trap
Questions sometimes ask where the government sits. Srinagar is the summer capital and Jammu is the winter capital. Do not write 'Jammu is the summer capital'. The bi-annual shifting of the Civil Secretariat is called the Darbar Move, and how it is arranged today is decided by the government, so check current practice if you need it.
What the Lieutenant Governor can and cannot do
The Lieutenant Governor represents the President in the Union Territory. In the matters assigned to the elected government, the Lieutenant Governor acts on the advice of the Council of Ministers. Some subjects, such as police and public order, are kept outside the Assembly's lawmaking power by the Act, so the elected government does not control them in the same way. Always check the current legal position, because Acts can be amended.
Worked example 1: appointing authority
Question: who appoints the Chief Minister of Jammu and Kashmir? Working: the Chief Minister is appointed by the Lieutenant Governor, who invites the leader with majority support in the Assembly. The President appoints the Lieutenant Governor, not the Chief Minister. So the answer is the Lieutenant Governor.
Worked example 2: choosing between similar titles
Question: the head of the permanent administration is the (a) Chief Minister (b) Chief Secretary (c) Speaker (d) Lieutenant Governor. Working: the permanent civil servants are headed by the Chief Secretary. The Chief Minister is a political head, the Speaker presides over the Assembly and the Lieutenant Governor is the head of the Union Territory. So the answer is (b).
Worked example 3: before or after 2019
Question: 'The Governor of the state appointed the Chief Minister in 2018.' Is this a correct description of the system at that time? Working: in 2018 Jammu and Kashmir was still a state, with a Governor and Chief Minister. So the statement fits the time. After 31 October 2019 it would be a Lieutenant Governor instead.
President appoints the Lieutenant Governor. Lieutenant Governor appoints the Chief Minister. The Council of Ministers answers to the Assembly.
Key takeaways: use a chain of appointment. Governor belongs to the old state; Lieutenant Governor to the Union Territory. Chief Minister is political; Chief Secretary is a civil servant. Srinagar is the summer capital and Jammu the winter capital.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who appoints the Chief Minister of the Union Territory?
- The Lieutenant Governor
- The President
- The Speaker
- The Chief Secretary
Show answer
Answer: A. The Lieutenant Governor appoints the Chief Minister.
-
2. The head of the permanent civil service is the:
- Chief Minister
- Speaker
- Lieutenant Governor
- Chief Secretary
Show answer
Answer: D. The Chief Secretary is a civil servant.
-
3. The summer capital of Jammu and Kashmir is:
- Jammu
- Srinagar
- Kargil
- Leh
Show answer
Answer: B. Srinagar is the summer capital; Jammu is the winter capital.
-
4. The Council of Ministers answers to the:
- Chief Secretary
- Legislative Assembly
- Divisional Commissioner
- Public Service Commission
Show answer
Answer: B. It is collectively responsible to the Assembly.
-
5. In 2018 the head of Jammu and Kashmir was called the:
- Lieutenant Governor
- Sadr-i-Riyasat
- Mayor
- Governor
Show answer
Answer: D. In 2018 the state still had a Governor. The Lieutenant Governor came with the Union Territory in 2019.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.