• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Cause-and-effect questions: why things are where they are

Use a four-step method to answer why questions about industries, mining problems and farming risks, and rehearse typical exam reasoning.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Many questions on Jharkhand's economy are not about names but about reasons: why did industry come up here, why does farming suffer there, why is mining a problem. The marks go to the answer that follows the real cause. This lesson gives you a method and then practises it.

A four-step method

Answer a why question

  1. Name the place or activity Say exactly what the question is about
  2. Name the natural base Rock, rain, river, forest or mineral
  3. Name the link How that base helps or harms the activity
  4. State the result In one clear sentence
Base, link, result

Three common reasons to learn

Typical reasons
QuestionNatural baseResult
Why are there steel and power industries?Iron ore and coal lie close togetherIndustries grew near the mines
Why is farming risky?Rain only in a few months; thin soil lets water run offDry spells hit crops
Why is mining a challenge?Mines lie under forests and farmsLoss of land, displacement, pollution

Traps in why questions

  • Wrong cause. 'Jharkhand grows paddy because it has a long coast.' The state has no coast; the cause is the monsoon.
  • Right fact, wrong reason. 'Jamshedpur grew because it is the capital.' The capital is Ranchi; Jamshedpur grew from steel inputs.
  • Too general. 'Because it is rich.' Give the specific base.
  • Reversed effect. Mining does not cause rain-fed farming; it competes for land.

Worked example 1: farming risk

Question: why do Jharkhand farmers face dry spells even in a year of good total rain? Working: rain falls in a few months and the plateau soil does not hold water, so much of it runs off. A gap of a few weeks between showers can leave crops without water. Answer: because rain is concentrated and runs off the plateau.

Worked example 2: why the power stations?

Question: why are coal-based power stations such as Patratu and Chandrapura placed in the coal belt? Working: coal is heavy and costly to carry. Burning it near the mine saves transport, and power can then be sent along wires. Answer: to save the cost of moving coal.

Worked example 3: effect of cutting sarna groves

Question: what harm may come if village groves and nearby forests are cleared for a mine? Working: trees that protect soil are lost; produce such as lac, tasar, mahua and sal leaves, which give income, disappears; and a place of worship may be lost. Answer: loss of income, soil protection and cultural places.

Worked example 4: choose the best reason

Question: which is the best reason for the Tata steel works at Jamshedpur? (a) It is on the coast. (b) Iron ore, coal, water and rail were close. (c) It is near the capital. Working: only (b) names the inputs a steel works needs. Answer: (b).

Worked example 5: fix a weak answer

Weak answer: 'Dhanbad is important because of mines.' Improved answer: 'Dhanbad lies in the Jharia coalfield in the Damodar valley, where Gondwana rocks hold coking coal; the coal feeds steel plants and power stations, so mining and coal companies grew there.' The second answer names the place, the base, the link and the result, and would earn more marks.

A good 'why' answer names the base, the link and the result.

— Revision line

Key takeaways

  • Follow base, link, result.
  • Industries sit near heavy raw materials.
  • Rain-fed farming is risky because rain is short and soil lets water run off.
  • Mining must be balanced against land, forest and health.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Why are coal-based power stations placed in the coal belt?

    1. Coal is lighter than power
    2. Coal is heavy, so burning it near the mine saves transport
    3. Rivers do not flow there
    4. The capital is nearby
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Moving coal is costly, so power stations are placed close to the fields.

  2. 2. Which is the best reason for the Jamshedpur steel works?

    1. Ore, coal, water and rail were all near
    2. It is the state capital
    3. It lies on the coast
    4. It has no rivers
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A steel works is placed near its heavy inputs.

  3. 3. Why do dry spells hurt crops even when yearly rain is good?

    1. The soil is always flooded
    2. Farmers grow only coconut
    3. Rain is concentrated in a few months and runs off the plateau
    4. There is no sunshine
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Short bursts of rain and fast run-off leave gaps without water.

  4. 4. Which is NOT a cost of heavy mining?

    1. Loss of farmland
    2. More forest cover
    3. Air pollution
    4. Displacement of villages
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Mining reduces forest cover; it does not add to it.

  5. 5. In a why question, what comes after naming the activity?

    1. The date
    2. The name of an official
    3. The population
    4. The natural base
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Name the base first (rock, rain, river or mineral), then link and result.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery