- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Panchayati Raj, Fifth Schedule and PESA: articles and comparisons
Revise Part IX of the Constitution, the Fifth Schedule's key provisions, and how they differ from the Sixth Schedule.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Questions on local government and tribal administration are well suited to Jharkhand because the state combines a large rural population with a large Scheduled Area. You need three things: the articles of Part IX, the Fifth Schedule's main provisions and the comparison with the Sixth Schedule.
Part IX: the Panchayats
| Provision | Rule |
|---|---|
| Part IX | Articles 243 to 243O, added by the 73rd Amendment (in force 1993) |
| Article 243A | The Gram Sabha |
| Three tiers | Gram Panchayat, Panchayat Samiti (intermediate level), Zila Parishad |
| Article 243D | Reservation of seats for SC and ST, and at least one-third of seats for women |
| Article 243E | Term of five years; fresh election within six months of dissolution |
| Article 243I | State Finance Commission |
| Article 243K | State Election Commission conducts the elections |
| Eleventh Schedule | 29 subjects that may be given to panchayats |
For towns, the 74th Amendment added Part IX-A, with the Twelfth Schedule listing 18 subjects. A trap is to mix the two: panchayats are rural and go with the Eleventh Schedule; municipalities are urban and go with the Twelfth Schedule.
Why PESA was needed
Article 243M says that Part IX does not apply to the Scheduled Areas unless Parliament extends it by law. Parliament did so in 1996 through PESA, based on the recommendations of the Bhuria Committee. PESA lets Scheduled Areas have panchayats but with special features: the Gram Sabha has strong powers, and the chairpersons of panchayats at all levels in the Scheduled Areas are to be Scheduled Tribe members. It also strengthens the community's say in matters such as minor forest produce and land.
The Fifth Schedule in brief
| Part of the Fifth Schedule | What it provides |
|---|---|
| Governor's report | The Governor reports every year to the President on the administration of the Scheduled Areas |
| Tribes Advisory Council | Up to twenty members, three-fourths from Scheduled Tribe members of the Assembly; advises on tribal welfare |
| Governor's law-making power | The Governor may direct that a law of Parliament or the state does not apply to a Scheduled Area, or applies with changes |
| Governor's regulations | After consulting the Council, the Governor may make rules on transfer of tribal land and on money-lending |
| Declaration of Scheduled Areas | The President may declare or change Scheduled Areas after consulting the Governor |
Fifth Schedule and Sixth Schedule
-
Fifth Schedule
Scheduled Areas
- Applies to states such as Jharkhand
- Governor holds the special powers
- Tribes Advisory Council advises
-
Sixth Schedule
Tribal areas of some north-eastern states
- Autonomous district councils
- Council has law-making powers on listed matters
- Not used for Jharkhand
Worked example 1: which schedule?
Question: a Governor-centred system with a Tribes Advisory Council belongs to which Schedule? Working: the Fifth. The Sixth Schedule works through autonomous district councils instead.
Worked example 2: the Article 243M link
Question: why was a separate law needed for panchayats in Scheduled Areas? Working: Article 243M keeps Part IX out of those areas unless Parliament extends it. PESA of 1996 is that extension.
Worked example 3: count the Council
Question: if the Tribes Advisory Council has the maximum twenty members, how many members should be Scheduled Tribe MLAs under the three-fourths rule? Working: three-fourths of 20 is 15. So about 15 of the 20 members should be Scheduled Tribe MLAs, and the remaining 5 may be others.
Part IX 243-243O, 73rd Amendment 1993, Eleventh Schedule 29 subjects; Article 243M keeps Scheduled Areas out; PESA 1996 brings them in.
Key takeaways: Part IX deals with panchayats, the Eleventh Schedule lists 29 subjects, Article 243M excludes Scheduled Areas until Parliament extends the Part, which PESA did in 1996. The Fifth Schedule works through the Governor and the Tribes Advisory Council.
Check your understanding
-
1. Panchayats are dealt with in which part of the Constitution?
- Part III
- Part V
- Part XIV
- Part IX
Show answer
Answer: D. Part IX, Articles 243 to 243O, deals with panchayats.
-
2. The Eleventh Schedule lists how many subjects for panchayats?
- 18
- 29
- 24
- 36
Show answer
Answer: B. The Eleventh Schedule has 29 subjects; the Twelfth has 18 for municipalities.
-
3. Which article provides that Part IX does not apply to Scheduled Areas unless Parliament extends it?
- Article 243A
- Article 243K
- Article 243M
- Article 243E
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 243M is the exception clause. PESA 1996 is the extension.
-
4. Who is responsible for the annual report on the administration of Scheduled Areas?
- The Governor
- The Chief Justice
- The Speaker
- The Block Development Officer
Show answer
Answer: A. The Governor reports to the President each year.
-
5. The Sixth Schedule differs from the Fifth in that it provides for:
- A Tribes Advisory Council for Jharkhand
- Autonomous district councils in some north-eastern areas
- A single national tribal council
- Gram Sabha chairpersons
Show answer
Answer: B. The Sixth Schedule uses autonomous councils; the Fifth, which applies to Jharkhand, works through the Governor and the Tribes Advisory Council.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.