- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
The Governor, Chief Minister and Council of Ministers
Explain who heads the state executive, how the Governor and Chief Minister are chosen, and why real power lies with the elected ministry.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Every state in India has a head and a government. In Karnataka, the head of the state is the Governor, but the government is run by the Chief Minister and the Council of Ministers. This lesson explains the three offices and how they relate.
The Governor: the formal head
The Governor is appointed by the President of India and holds office during the President's pleasure, normally for a term of five years. To be a Governor a person must be an Indian citizen and at least 35 years of age. The Governor is the constitutional head of the state, similar to the way the President is the head of the country. All executive action in the state is taken in the Governor's name. The Governor lives and works at the Raj Bhavan in Bengaluru.
The Chief Minister and the Council of Ministers
After an election, the Governor invites the leader of the party or group that has the support of a majority in the Vidhan Sabha (the Legislative Assembly) to become Chief Minister. The Governor then appoints the other ministers on the Chief Minister's advice. Together they form the Council of Ministers. The Chief Minister is the real head of government.
| Office | Chosen how | Role |
|---|---|---|
| Governor | Appointed by the President | Formal head; acts in the name of the state |
| Chief Minister | Appointed by the Governor; leads the majority in the Assembly | Real head of government |
| Council of Ministers | Appointed by the Governor on the Chief Minister's advice | Runs the departments and advises the Governor |
State executive of Karnataka
- Governor Formal head, appointed by the President
- Chief Minister Real head of government
- Council of Ministers Ministers heading departments
Collective responsibility
The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Vidhan Sabha. This means that if the Assembly loses confidence in the ministry, the whole ministry must go. It is not enough for one minister to resign alone when the whole ministry has lost the House's support. Individual ministers hold office during the Governor's pleasure, but in practice the Governor acts on the Chief Minister's advice.
Who can be a minister
A minister must be a member of the state legislature, or become a member within six months of taking office. A person who is not a member when appointed has this six-month window. The Constitution also limits the size of a state's Council of Ministers to 15 percent of the total members of the Assembly, with a minimum of twelve ministers.
Other posts in the executive
The Governor also appoints the Advocate General, the state's chief law officer, who advises the government on legal matters. The Chief Secretary heads the permanent civil service of the state, serving under whichever ministry is in office.
Worked example 1: who is the real head?
Question: a bill is to be introduced and a department is to be reorganised. Who takes the main decision? Working: the Council of Ministers under the Chief Minister decides. The Governor acts on their advice. So the decision belongs to the elected ministry; the Governor signs it as formal head.
Worked example 2: the six-month rule
Question: a person who is not an MLA or MLC is made a minister on 10 March. By when must the person become a member of the legislature? Working: the limit is six months, so by 10 September of the same year. If the person is not a member by then, the person must cease to be a minister.
Worked example 3: size of the ministry
Question: suppose an Assembly had 200 members. What is the largest Council of Ministers allowed? Working: 15 percent of 200 = 30. So at most 30 ministers, including the Chief Minister. The lower limit of twelve applies in any state.
The Governor is the formal head, the Chief Minister the real head, and the Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Vidhan Sabha.
Key takeaways: the President appoints the Governor; the Governor appoints the Chief Minister, who has the Assembly's majority; the Chief Minister's advice decides the other ministers. The Council is collectively responsible to the Assembly, is capped at 15 percent of its strength, and a minister who is not a member must join the legislature within six months.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who appoints the Governor of Karnataka?
- The Chief Minister
- The Chief Justice of India
- The Speaker of the Vidhan Sabha
- The President of India
Show answer
Answer: D. The Governor is appointed by the President and holds office during the President's pleasure.
-
2. The real head of the government in the state is the:
- Chief Minister
- Governor
- Speaker
- Chief Secretary
Show answer
Answer: A. The Chief Minister leads the Council of Ministers and runs the government. The Governor is the formal head.
-
3. To whom is the Council of Ministers collectively responsible?
- The Governor alone
- The High Court
- The Vidhan Sabha
- The Vidhan Parishad alone
Show answer
Answer: C. Under the Constitution the Council is collectively responsible to the Legislative Assembly.
-
4. The minimum age to be Governor is:
- 25 years
- 30 years
- 40 years
- 35 years
Show answer
Answer: D. A Governor must be an Indian citizen who has completed 35 years of age.
-
5. A non-member appointed minister must become a member of the legislature within:
- Six months
- One month
- One year
- Three months
Show answer
Answer: A. The Constitution allows six months. If the person is still not a member, the person must stop being a minister.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.