• Advanced
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Chronology puzzles: gaps, overlaps and impossible meetings

Use the timeline of Ladakh's famous people to work out gaps between events, to test whether two people could have met, and to reject options with an impossible order.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Advanced questions do not ask you to recall a name; they ask you to reason with dates. Could two people have met? How many years lie between two events? Which event came first? To solve these, you need the timeline of Ladakh's personalities firmly in mind and a little arithmetic. This lesson shows the method and then applies it to hard cases.

The master timeline

Fourteen entries from the tenth century to 1948
DateEventPerson
Tenth centuryMaryul passes to a son of Nyima-gonNyima-gon
Tenth to eleventh centuryBuddhist revival; translations and temples credited by traditionRinchen Zangpo
Fifteenth centuryNamgyal line traced to its founderBhagan
Sixteenth centuryNamgyal Tsemo builtTashi Namgyal
Early seventeenth centuryLeh Palace built; Hemis founded with a lama's guidanceSengge Namgyal, Stagtsang Raspa
1684Treaty of TingmosgangLadakh and Tibet
1820Reaches LehWilliam Moorcroft
1820sStudies Tibetan in ZanskarCsoma de Kőrös
1834Campaigns begin; dictionary and grammar publishedZorawar Singh; Csoma de Kőrös
1841Killed in western TibetZorawar Singh
1842Treaty of ChushulDogra-Sikh side and Tibet
1846Treaty of AmritsarGulab Singh
1907A History of Western Tibet publishedA. H. Francke
May and November 1948Landing at Leh; tanks at Zoji LaMehar Singh; Thimayya

Gaps and overlaps

A gap is the number of years between two events: subtract the earlier year from the later. From 1834 to 1841 is 7 years; from 1841 to 1846 is 5 years; from 1834 to 1846 is 12 years. An overlap asks whether two lives or activities could have coincided. Moorcroft's arrival in 1820 and Csoma's years in Zanskar in the 1820s overlap in the same decade, so a question that asks whether they were roughly contemporary has the answer yes. Zorawar Singh and Sengge Namgyal do not overlap at all: more than two centuries lie between the early seventeenth century and 1834.

How to solve a date-reasoning question

  1. Locate each person Century or year from the timeline
  2. Compute the gap Later minus earlier
  3. Test the claim Could the claim fit inside that gap?
  4. Reject the impossible Cross out options with a wrong order
Four steps, in order

Typical impossible-order options

  • A person is placed at an event after his death, as in 'Zorawar Singh at the Treaty of Chushul'.
  • A book is said to describe events after its publication, as in 'Francke on the landing at Leh in 1948'.
  • A king is placed in the wrong century, as in 'Tashi Namgyal in the seventeenth century'.
  • Two people from different centuries are said to have met, as in 'Sengge Namgyal and Zorawar Singh'.

Each of these can be rejected in a few seconds, without recalling anything else about the people. This is why date reasoning is the fastest tool for hard questions: it needs only the skeleton of the timeline, and it works even when the names in the options are unfamiliar to you.

Worked example 1

Question: How many years passed between the start of Zorawar Singh's campaigns and the Treaty of Amritsar? Working: Campaigns began in 1834 and the treaty is of 1846. The difference is 1846 minus 1834. Answer: 12 years.

Worked example 2

Question: Could Zorawar Singh have been present when the Treaty of Chushul was signed? Working: The treaty was signed in 1842 after his death in 1841, so he could not have been present. Answer: No.

Worked example 3

Question: Statements: (1) Moorcroft reached Leh before the Treaty of Amritsar. (2) Francke's book was published before the landing at Leh in 1948. Which are correct? Working: Moorcroft arrived in 1820 and the treaty is of 1846, so 1 is correct. Francke's book is of 1907 and the landing was in 1948, so 2 is also correct. Answer: Both 1 and 2.

Locate, subtract, test, reject. A claim that cannot fit inside the gap is false, whatever the names.

Key takeaways: reason from dates rather than from memory of stories. Compute gaps by subtraction, check overlaps by decade, and reject any option that puts a person at an event after his death.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. How many years separate the Treaty of Chushul (1842) from the Treaty of Amritsar (1846)?

    1. 3 years
    2. 4 years
    3. 5 years
    4. 12 years
    Show answer

    Answer: B. 1846 minus 1842 is 4. The 12-year gap is between 1834 and 1846.

  2. 2. Statements: 1. Zorawar Singh and Sengge Namgyal were contemporaries. 2. Zorawar Singh died before the Treaty of Amritsar. Which is correct?

    1. 1 only
    2. 2 only
    3. Both 1 and 2
    4. Neither 1 nor 2
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Sengge Namgyal belongs to the early seventeenth century and Zorawar Singh to the nineteenth, so 1 is false. He died in 1841, before the treaty of 1846, so 2 is true.

  3. 3. Which of these two events was earlier?

    1. The publication of A History of Western Tibet
    2. The landing at Leh in 1948
    3. Moorcroft reaching Leh
    4. The Treaty of Amritsar
    Show answer

    Answer: C. 1820 is earlier than 1846, 1907 and 1948.

  4. 4. Which statement is impossible?

    1. Gulab Singh signed the Treaty of Chushul as ruler of Ladakh in 1684
    2. Gulab Singh was recognised as Maharaja in 1846
    3. Csoma de Kőrös published his dictionary in 1834
    4. Francke wrote after Moorcroft
    Show answer

    Answer: A. 1684 is the year of Tingmosgang, long before Gulab Singh, and Chushul is of 1842, so the first statement is impossible.

  5. 5. A student writes that Tashi Namgyal and Sengge Namgyal built their works in the same century. What is the best correction?

    1. They built in the tenth century
    2. They both built in 1834
    3. Neither built anything
    4. Tashi built in the sixteenth century and Sengge in the early seventeenth
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The two Namgyal kings belong to different centuries, with Tashi earlier.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery