- Advanced
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
One crop, one sea: why an island economy is fragile
Analyse the risks of depending on coconut and fishing, and apply the ideas to statement questions.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A strong exam answer on Lakshadweep goes beyond lists. It explains why the island economy has the shape it has and where its weak points lie. This lesson builds that skill. We use the facts you already know: coconut as the main crop, tuna as the main catch, no rivers or minerals, scarce fresh water, and a sea link to the mainland.
Four sources of fragility
| Source | Why it is a risk | Natural response |
|---|---|---|
| One main crop | A disease, storm or fall in demand hurts many households at once | Use every part of the palm; add small crops and fishing |
| Dependence on the sea link | Rice, fuel and goods come by ship, so rough weather or a break in service hurts | Store foods that keep, such as mas; keep stocks |
| Scarce fresh water | The thin fresh layer can be harmed by over-pumping or salt water | Protect wells, harvest rain, use desalination |
| Fragile reef | Fishing and tourism both depend on it | Limit pressure and protect coral |
Diversifying income
-
Coconut
Main crop
- Copra
- Coir
- Oil
- Leaf crafts
-
Sea
Second great resource
- Tuna
- Reef fish
- Mas
-
Services
Growing sector
- Tourism
- Transport
- Government services
Reading a statement question
Statement questions test two things: whether each statement is true, and whether it is too strong. For example, 'the islands grow only coconut' is false because other plants are grown in small amounts, and 'the islands have no connection with the mainland economy' is plainly false because of rice and coir trade. Test each statement separately, and mark it T or F before you look at the options.
Assertion-reason questions add a second test: if both are true, does the reason actually explain the assertion? A reason may be true yet not explain. For instance, 'there are no rivers' is true, but it does not explain 'coconut is the main crop', which is explained by the coral sand and salty air that suit the palm.
Low islands and the weather
The islands are low and flat, so they are exposed to storms and to the sea. Strong winds can strip coconuts from palms, and rough seas can stop boats and ships. Because the land lies only a little above the sea, scientists also watch how a rise in the sea level might affect such islands in the long run; for the latest understanding, consult up-to-date sources. For exam purposes, remember the idea that the economy rests on a small, low, exposed base.
This exposure explains several habits of island life: storing mas and other long-keeping food, keeping coconut products at home, building with materials that withstand wind and sea air, and relying on a shared sea link to the mainland. When you meet a question that begins 'why do islanders...', first look for the risk behind the habit.
Worked examples
Example 1. Why is diversification wise? If one source fails, the others still give income. A family with coconut, fishing and a small service income is safer than one with a single source.
Example 2. Why does a break in the ship service matter more here than in a mainland town? There is no road or rail link, and the islands must bring rice and many goods by sea, so a gap is serious.
Example 3 (illustrative numbers only). Suppose a household earns Rs 6,000 from coconuts and Rs 4,000 from fishing in a month in an imaginary case. If coconut income falls by half, it becomes Rs 3,000 and total income falls from Rs 10,000 to Rs 7,000, a fall of 30 per cent. A household earning Rs 10,000 from coconuts alone would have lost 50 per cent.
Single source means single point of failure. Diversify.
Key takeaways. The island economy is fragile because it relies on a few things. Protect it by diversifying, storing food and guarding the reef and the water.
Check your understanding
-
1. Consider: (1) Lakshadweep grows only coconut and no other plant. (2) Island households often draw income from more than one source. Which is correct?
- Only statement 2 is correct
- Only statement 1 is correct
- Both statements are correct
- Neither statement is correct
Show answer
Answer: A. Statement 1 is too strong: breadfruit, some fruits and vegetables are also grown. Statement 2 is correct.
-
2. Assertion (A): Rough weather can badly hurt supplies to the islands. Reason (R): Rice and many goods arrive by ship. Which is correct?
- Both A and R are true but R does not explain A
- Both A and R are true and R explains A
- A is true but R is false
- A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: B. Both are true, and because supplies come by ship, rough weather matters. R explains A.
-
3. Which step best reduces the risk of depending on one crop?
- Planting only more coconuts
- Closing the ports
- Earning from coconut, fishing and services
- Ignoring the weather
Show answer
Answer: C. Spreading income across sources reduces the harm if one fails. More of the same crop increases the risk.
-
4. Consider: (1) Mas is useful because it keeps for a long time. (2) Mas is a coconut product. Which is correct?
- Only statement 2 is correct
- Both statements are correct
- Neither statement is correct
- Only statement 1 is correct
Show answer
Answer: D. Statement 1 is correct. Statement 2 is wrong, because mas is dried tuna.
-
5. In an imaginary household, coconut brings Rs 8,000 and fishing Rs 2,000. If coconut income halves, total income falls by:
- 40 per cent
- 50 per cent
- 20 per cent
- 25 per cent
Show answer
Answer: A. Coconut falls by Rs 4,000. Total was Rs 10,000, so the fall is 4,000/10,000 = 40 per cent. These figures are imaginary.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.