- Advanced
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
From Part C to Union Territory: how status is made by law
Trace how the Constitution's categories of units changed in 1956, why Lakshadweep has no legislature, and how Parliament can alter a territory's status or name by law.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The status of Lakshadweep is not a permanent fact of nature. It is a legal arrangement that Parliament made and can change. Advanced questions test whether you understand this: they ask not only what Lakshadweep is, but how it came to be so, and what that tells us about the Indian federal design. Read this lesson as the legal backbone of the whole course.
The Constitution's first categories
When the Constitution came into force in 1950 it grouped the units of the Union into four classes: Parts A, B, C and D of the First Schedule. Part C states were smaller units, often governed directly by the Centre. The islands that now form Lakshadweep were then still part of the districts of Malabar and South Canara in Madras State, so they were administered along with a Part A state.
The States Reorganisation Act, 1956, together with the Seventh Amendment of the same year, removed the old Part A, B, C and D scheme. India was divided into states and Union Territories. On 1 November 1956 the islands became a Union Territory, bringing them under one administration for the first time.
| Aspect | Before 1956 reorganisation | After 1956 |
|---|---|---|
| Classes of units | Parts A, B, C, D | States and Union Territories |
| Lakshadweep islands | Attached to Madras districts | One Union Territory |
| Name of the islands | Laccadive, Minicoy and Amindivi Islands (as a group) | Same official name until 1973 |
| Head of the administration | District officers of Madras | Administrator under Article 239 |
Why some Union Territories got legislatures
The Fourteenth Amendment of 1962 inserted Article 239A, and the Government of Union Territories Act, 1963 followed. Together they allowed Parliament to create legislatures for certain Union Territories. This was a matter of political choice. Lakshadweep, small and far from the mainland, was not given one, and the territory therefore remains in the group governed through an Administrator. Treat this as a legal fact about the territory's present form and add 'check the current legal position' in your revision notes.
How the status was made
- 1950 Constitution: Parts A, B, C and D
- 1956 States Reorganisation Act and the Seventh Amendment: states and Union Territories
- 1962-63 Article 239A and the Act of 1963: legislatures possible for some territories
- 1973 Parliament's law renames the territory Lakshadweep
Parliament and the change of status
A territory's status is set by law. The renaming in 1973 shows this: the islands did not change on the ground, but a law changed the name. In the same way, Parliament has in the past altered the status of other territories, so a student should never say 'Lakshadweep will always be a Union Territory without a legislature'. The correct careful statement is 'Lakshadweep is, under the law as we know it, a Union Territory without a legislature; check the current legal position'.
Worked example 1: sort the sequence
Question: 'Arrange: (1) Article 239A inserted, (2) Seventh Amendment and the 1956 reorganisation, (3) renaming as Lakshadweep.' Working: 1956 comes first, 1962 second, 1973 third, giving the order 2, 1, 3.
Worked example 2: why not a legislature?
Question: 'Lakshadweep has no legislature because it was never a state.' Working: this is only half the story. Even among Union Territories some have legislatures by law. The reason Lakshadweep has none is that Parliament has not provided one. The statement is incomplete and examiners may mark it as the weaker option.
Worked example 3: the old scheme
Question: 'Which scheme of classification was abolished by the Seventh Amendment?' Working: the Part A, B, C and D scheme of the First Schedule. The answer is the four-part classification.
1950 Parts A-D; 1956 states and Union Territories; 1962-63 legislatures possible for some; 1973 name Lakshadweep. Status is made by law and can be changed by law.
Key takeaways: the 1956 reorganisation made Lakshadweep a Union Territory. Article 239A and the 1963 Act allow legislatures for some territories but not for Lakshadweep. Status and name are fixed by law and may change.
Check your understanding
-
1. Consider: (1) The Seventh Amendment removed the Part A, B, C and D classification. (2) Lakshadweep was a Part A state before 1956. Which is correct?
- 1 only
- 2 only
- Both 1 and 2
- Neither 1 nor 2
Show answer
Answer: A. Statement 1 is correct. Lakshadweep was never a state; it was attached to districts of Madras.
-
2. Article 239A was inserted by which amendment?
- Seventh Amendment
- Forty-second Amendment
- Fourteenth Amendment
- Seventy-third Amendment
Show answer
Answer: C. The Fourteenth Amendment (1962) inserted it.
-
3. Assertion: Lakshadweep's name was changed in 1973 without any change on the ground. Reason: names of territories are fixed by law. Which is correct?
- Both true; the reason does not explain
- Both true; the reason explains the assertion
- Assertion true, reason false
- Assertion false, reason true
Show answer
Answer: B. A law changed the name, which explains the assertion.
-
4. Which is the best careful statement for revision notes?
- Lakshadweep will never have a legislature
- Lakshadweep is a state
- Lakshadweep has had an assembly since 1956
- Lakshadweep is a Union Territory without a legislature; check the current legal position
Show answer
Answer: D. Status is set by law, so say so.
-
5. Which law allowed legislatures for some Union Territories in 1963?
- Government of Union Territories Act, 1963
- States Reorganisation Act, 1956
- Constitution (Fortieth Amendment) Act
- Panchayat Act, 1992
Show answer
Answer: A. The 1963 Act did so for some territories.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.