- Foundation
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
Counting problems: how many sons, daughters or relatives?
Answer simple 'how many' questions about a family by counting boys and girls carefully and not counting anyone twice.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Some blood-relation questions do not ask for a relation at all. They give a description such as 'each son has two sisters' and ask how many children there are. These are friendly questions, but they hide a trap: it is easy to count the same person twice. The cure is to decide who is being counted before you multiply.
The method
Counting relatives
- List the groups Such as boys and girls.
- Work out each group's size
- Check from one person's view
- Add each group once
- List the groups of people, such as boys and girls.
- Work out each group's size from the statement.
- Check each statement against your answer by counting from the viewpoint of one person.
- Add the groups once; do not add the same person in two groups.
Worked examples
Example 1. A man has two sons, and each son has three sons. How many grandsons does the man have? Working: Each of the 2 sons has 3 sons, which are 3 grandsons of the man. In total, 2 x 3 = 6 grandsons.
Example 2. A family has some boys and girls. Each girl has 2 brothers and each boy has 3 sisters. How many children are there? Working: A girl's brothers are all the boys in the family, so there are 2 boys. A boy's sisters are all the girls in the family, so there are 3 girls. The total is 2 + 3 = 5 children. Check: a girl has the 2 boys as brothers, and each boy has the 3 girls as sisters.
Example 3. Ravi has 3 sisters, and each sister has 2 sons. How many nephews does Ravi have? Working: Each sister's sons are Ravi's nephews. 3 x 2 = 6 nephews. (We assume the sisters' sons are different people.)
Example 4. A family has a husband, a wife, their two married sons with their wives, and one child of each son. How many persons are there? Working: Count generations. The first generation has the husband and wife, which is 2 persons. The second has 2 sons and their 2 wives, which is 4 persons. The third has 2 grandchildren, one child of each son. The total is 2 + 4 + 2 = 8 persons.
Say who is being counted. A statement about each girl's brothers counts all the boys, not the boys of one girl.
Example 5. A school class photo shows a brother and sister, Arun and Bela, with their parents. Arun says, 'I have as many brothers as sisters.' Bela says, 'I have twice as many brothers as sisters.' How many children are in the family? Working: Let there be b boys and g girls. Arun, a boy, has b - 1 brothers and g sisters, so b - 1 = g. Bela, a girl, has b brothers and g - 1 sisters, so b = 2 (g - 1). Substituting g = b - 1 gives b = 2 (b - 2) = 2b - 4, so b = 4 and g = 3. Total = 7 children. Check: Arun has 3 brothers and 3 sisters; Bela has 4 brothers and 2 sisters, which is twice as many.
The 'each' trap
In Example 2 many students answer 2 x 3 = 6 or 2 x 2 = 4, because they multiply the numbers by the number of people. But the brothers of any one girl are the same boys as the brothers of another girl: they are not different people for each girl. This is why 'each girl has 2 brothers' means 2 boys in the whole family. In Example 1, the sons of the different sons are different people, because every son has his own children. Ask yourself: are the people being counted shared or different for each person?
The 'each' trap
-
Shared people
- Each girl has 2 brothers
- Every girl has the same brothers
- So there are 2 boys in the whole family
-
Different people
- A man has two sons, and each son has three sons
- Every son has his own children
- So 2 x 3 = 6 grandsons
Key takeaways
- Decide whether the people counted are shared (brothers of each girl) or separate (children of each son).
- Check each statement from one person's point of view.
- Count generations separately and add them once.
Check your understanding
-
1. A man has 2 sons, and each son has 3 sons. How many grandsons does the man have?
- 5
- 6
- 8
- 9
Show answer
Answer: B. Each of the 2 sons has 3 sons, so 2 x 3 = 6 grandsons.
-
2. A family has 4 brothers who have one sister. How many children are in the family?
- 5
- 4
- 3
- 8
Show answer
Answer: A. The four brothers share the same one sister, so the family has 4 + 1 = 5 children.
-
3. Each girl has 3 brothers and each boy has 2 sisters. How many children are there?
- 6
- 8
- 4
- 5
Show answer
Answer: D. There are 3 boys and 2 girls. The total is 3 + 2 = 5 children.
-
4. A couple, their 2 married sons with wives, and one child of each son. How many persons are there?
- 6
- 10
- 8
- 7
Show answer
Answer: C. 2 + (2 sons + 2 wives) + 2 grandchildren = 8 persons.
-
5. Ravi has 3 sisters, and each sister has 2 sons. How many nephews does Ravi have?
- 3
- 6
- 5
- 9
Show answer
Answer: B. Each of the 3 sisters has 2 sons, so 3 x 2 = 6 nephews.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.