• Advanced
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

The four possible relationships

Decide whether one of two statements is the cause of the other, whether both share a cause, or whether they are unrelated.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Each question gives two statements, I and II, and asks how they are connected. In this course the answer options are always the same four, and we label them A to D.

Answer options used in this course
OptionMeaning
AI is the cause and II is its effect
BII is the cause and I is its effect
CBoth are effects of the same (common) cause
DBoth are independent: neither causes the other and they share no cause

Test

  1. Which event happened first or sets the conditions? A cause comes before its effect.
  2. Could I produce II? Could II produce I?
  3. If neither produces the other, could one outside event produce both? If so choose C.
  4. If there is no link at all, choose D.

Worked example 1

I. Several road accidents occurred on the highway last week. II. The highway was covered in dense fog throughout the week. Dense fog reduces visibility and causes accidents. II is the cause and I is its effect. The answer is B.

Worked example 2

I. The price of onions has doubled in a month. II. Heavy rains damaged onion crops in the main producing regions. Damaged crops reduce supply and push up prices. II is the cause and I is its effect. The answer is B.

A cause comes first and produces the effect. If neither produces the other, look for a common cause, and then for no link at all.

— Method to remember

Key takeaways: a cause comes first and produces the effect; look for a common cause before declaring two events unrelated.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In this course, what does the option 'both are effects of a common cause' mean?

    1. I produces II
    2. One outside event produces both I and II, and neither produces the other
    3. II produces I
    4. The two events have no link of any kind
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A common cause is a third event that produces both statements. Neither statement causes the other, so it is not A or B, and there is a link, so it is not D.

  2. 2. I. A dam on the river broke. II. Low-lying villages downstream were flooded. How are the two statements related?

    1. I is the cause and II is its effect
    2. II is the cause and I is its effect
    3. Both are effects of a common cause
    4. Both are independent and unrelated
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The dam breaking comes first and releases the water that floods the villages. I is the cause and II is its effect.

  3. 3. I. The school was closed for a week. II. Heavy snowfall blocked every road into the town. How are the two statements related?

    1. I is the cause and II is its effect
    2. II is the cause and I is its effect
    3. Both are effects of a common cause
    4. Both are independent and unrelated
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Blocked roads make it impossible for pupils and teachers to reach school, so the school closes. II is the cause and I is its effect.

  4. 4. I. Fishing boats were told to stay in harbour. II. Schools along the coast were closed for the day. How are the two statements related?

    1. I is the cause and II is its effect
    2. II is the cause and I is its effect
    3. Both are effects of a common cause
    4. Both are independent and unrelated
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Keeping boats in harbour does not close schools, and closing schools does not keep boats in. One outside event, such as a cyclone warning, explains both, so they are effects of a common cause.

  5. 5. I. A singer released a new album. II. A bridge in another city was painted blue. How are the two statements related?

    1. I is the cause and II is its effect
    2. II is the cause and I is its effect
    3. Both are effects of a common cause
    4. Both are independent and unrelated
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Neither event can produce the other, and no single outside event explains both. They are independent.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Time order and the principal cause

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery