- Advanced
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Any angle in any hour: the complete solution, and the second hand
Find every time in an hour when the hands make a given angle, see why some hours have one answer and others two, and handle the second hand.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Advanced questions pick angles and hours that break the simple formula: an angle that is reached only once in the hour, or a time that only appears after going round the dial. They also bring in the second hand. This lesson gives a complete method that cannot miss an answer, and a way to predict how many answers to expect.
The complete equation
The hands make an angle θ (0° to 180°) when 30H − 5.5M equals θ or −θ, give or take a full turn of 360°. So the candidates are M = (60H − 2θ)/11 and M = (60H + 2θ)/11, each of which may be moved by 720/11 = 65 5/11 (one full turn of relative motion). Keep every value from 0 up to 60. Because 65 5/11 is more than 60, each candidate gives at most one valid time, so an hour never has more than two answers.
M = (60H ± 2θ)/11, shifted by ±65 5/11 if needed into 0 ≤ M < 60. When both answers fall in the same hour without shifting, they are 4θ/11 minutes apart.
Predicting the number of answers
Track the smaller angle through the hour. At H o'clock it is 30H (or 360 − 30H if H > 6). It then changes at 5.5° per minute, turning around when the hands are opposite (180°) or together (0°). Over the hour the relative angle sweeps 5.5 × 60 = 330°. Any angle that the smaller angle passes through twice in that sweep gives two answers; an angle it passes once gives one answer.
Worked example 1: 125° between 9 and 10
Basic candidates: (540 − 250)/11 = 290/11 = 26 4/11, valid; (540 + 250)/11 = 790/11, too big, and subtracting 720/11 gives 70/11 = 6 4/11, valid. So the hands are 125° apart at 9:06 4/11 and 9:26 4/11. Check the first: 30 × 9 − 5.5 × 70/11 = 270 − 35 = 235°, and 360 − 235 = 125°. The simple formula alone would have missed it.
Worked example 2: 25° between 11 and 12
At 11:00 the smaller angle is 30°. It grows as the minute hand moves away, up to 180° at about 11:27, and then shrinks to 0° at 12:00. So 25° is reached only on the way down: M = (660 − 50)/11 = 610/11 = 55 5/11. The other candidate, (660 + 50)/11, is 64 6/11; after subtracting 65 5/11 it becomes negative, so there is no second answer.
The second hand
The second hand turns 360° a minute, which is 6° per second. In one second the minute hand turns 0.1° and the hour hand 1/120°. For angles involving the second hand, find each hand's position from 12 at that instant: second hand = 6 × seconds; minute hand = 6 × (minutes + seconds/60); hour hand = 30H + 0.5 × (minutes + seconds/60).
Worked example 3: minute and second hands at 3:20:15
Minute hand: 6 × 20.25 = 121.5°. Second hand: 6 × 15 = 90°. The angle between them is 121.5 − 90 = 31.5°. A common slip is to put the minute hand at exactly 120°, forgetting the extra quarter minute.
Key takeaways: list the two candidates, shift by 65 5/11 when they fall outside the hour, and keep what lies from 0 to 60. Predict the count by tracking the smaller angle from its o'clock value. For the second hand, place every hand from 12 at the same instant before subtracting.
Check your understanding
-
1. At what times between 4 and 5 are the hands 10° apart?
- 20 and 24 min past 4
- 21 9/11 and 23 7/11 min past 4
- 20 and 23 7/11 min past 4
- 20 min past 4 only
Show answer
Answer: C. M = (240 − 20)/11 = 220/11 = 20 and M = (240 + 20)/11 = 260/11 = 23 7/11. Both lie within the hour, so the answers are 20 and 23 7/11 min past 4. They are 4 × 10/11 = 40/11 = 3 7/11 minutes apart, as expected.
-
2. At what times between 10 and 11 are the hands 100° apart?
- 7 3/11 and 36 4/11 min past 10
- 36 4/11 min past 10 only
- 7 3/11 and 34 6/11 min past 10
- 18 2/11 and 36 4/11 min past 10
Show answer
Answer: A. M = (600 − 200)/11 = 400/11 = 36 4/11, valid. M = (600 + 200)/11 = 800/11 is too big; subtracting 720/11 gives 80/11 = 7 3/11, valid. Check: at 10:07 3/11 the hour hand is at 303 7/11° and the minute hand at 43 7/11°, a gap of 260°, so the smaller angle is 100°. Answers: 7 3/11 and 36 4/11 min past 10.
-
3. What is the angle between the minute hand and the second hand at 5:12:30?
- 108°
- 102°
- 75°
- 105°
Show answer
Answer: D. Minute hand: 6 × 12.5 = 75°. Second hand: 6 × 30 = 180°. The angle between them is 180 − 75 = 105°.
-
4. Between 4 and 5 the hands are 66° apart at two times. How many minutes apart are those two times?
- 12 min
- 24 min
- 33 min
- 22 min
Show answer
Answer: B. The times are (240 − 132)/11 = 108/11 = 9 9/11 and (240 + 132)/11 = 372/11 = 33 9/11 minutes past 4. The gap is 33 9/11 − 9 9/11 = 24 min, which is also 4 × 66/11 = 24.
-
5. At what times between 11 and 12 are the hands 55° apart?
- 4 6/11 and 50 min past 11
- 50 min past 11 only
- 5 min and 50 min past 11
- 4 6/11 min past 11 only
Show answer
Answer: A. At 11:00 the smaller angle is 30°; it grows to 55° first and later shrinks back through 55°. M = (660 − 110)/11 = 550/11 = 50, valid. M = (660 + 110)/11 = 70, too big; subtracting 720/11 gives 50/11 = 4 6/11, valid. Answers: 4 6/11 and 50 min past 11.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.