• Advanced
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Premise, conclusion and assumption

Break any argument into premises, conclusion and the unstated assumption that links them, using signal words.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Every critical-reasoning question begins with an argument. To handle it you must separate what is claimed (the conclusion) from what is offered in support (the premises), and notice the gap between them. That gap is filled by an unstated assumption.

Signal words

  • Conclusion signals: therefore, thus, hence, so, it follows that, consequently.
  • Premise signals: because, since, as, given that, for.
  • The conclusion is the claim the author wants you to accept; the premises are the reasons.

Worked example 1

Because the monsoon was late, the dam levels are low. Therefore the city must start water rationing. The premises are that the monsoon was late and that dam levels are low. The conclusion is that the city must start water rationing. An assumption is that the low dam levels will not recover soon enough to avoid rationing.

Worked example 2

The new flyover has cut travel time, so the town's traffic congestion is solved. The premise is that travel time has fallen. The conclusion is that congestion is solved. The gap: a shorter travel time does not show that congestion is gone. The argument assumes that reduced travel time is the same as solved congestion.

Find the conclusion first. Everything that supports it is a premise. What links them without being said is the assumption.

— Method to remember

Key takeaways: locate the conclusion, list the premises, and name the gap between them.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. 'It follows that the factory must install smoke filters, given that its smoke exceeds the safe limit and nearby residents report breathing problems.' What is the conclusion?

    1. The factory must install smoke filters
    2. The factory's smoke exceeds the safe limit
    3. Nearby residents report breathing problems
    4. Smoke filters are cheap
    Show answer

    Answer: A. 'It follows that' marks the conclusion: the factory must install filters. 'Given that' introduces the two premises. Nothing is said about cost.

  2. 2. 'Because the monsoon was late, the dam levels are low. Therefore the city must start water rationing.' Which is an unstated assumption?

    1. The monsoon was late in arriving over the catchment of the dam
    2. The dam levels are low at present, at the start of the season
    3. The dam levels will not recover soon enough to avoid rationing
    4. Rationing is popular with residents and has the support of the city
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The late monsoon and the low dam levels are stated premises. The gap between low dam levels and the need to ration is that the levels will not recover in time - unstated, but needed.

  3. 3. 'The new flyover has cut travel time, so the town's traffic congestion is solved.' What does the argument assume?

    1. Travel time has fallen since the flyover was opened
    2. A shorter travel time means that congestion is solved
    3. The flyover was costly to build and took a long time
    4. The town has a small population compared with other towns
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The premise (travel time fell) is stated. The jump to "congestion is solved" needs the unstated idea that shorter travel time is the same as no congestion - which may not be true.

  4. 4. 'Meera won the state coding contest, so she will be a good leader of the software team.' What is a key assumption?

    1. Meera enjoys coding and takes part in contests every year
    2. The coding contest was difficult and had many entrants
    3. The software team is large and has many senior members
    4. Skill in coding contests shows the skills needed to lead a team
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The premise is about contest coding; the conclusion is about leading a team. The bridge is that contest skill indicates leadership skill.

  5. 5. 'Hence the shop should stay open till 10 p.m., as most of its customers return from work after 8 p.m.' Which is a premise?

    1. The shop should stay open till 10 p.m. on all days
    2. Most of its customers return from work after 8 p.m.
    3. The shop is profitable during the early evening hours
    4. Customers prefer late hours for their daily shopping
    Show answer

    Answer: B. 'As' introduces the premise: most customers return after 8 p.m. 'Hence' marks the conclusion, even though it begins the sentence.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Strengthening and weakening arguments

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery