- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Traps in data sufficiency
Avoid the usual traps: using one statement while judging the other, accepting two possible answers as sufficient, and bringing in outside facts.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Most mistakes in data sufficiency are not about maths. They come from a few habits. Learn them and you will avoid them.
The traps
The traps
- Mixing statements Testing II alone, forget I.
- Accepting two answers x = 5 or −5 is not sufficient.
- Using outside knowledge Use only what is given, apart from maths facts.
- Calculating too long Once a single answer exists, stop.
- Ignoring 'definite no' A definite no is sufficient too.
- Mixing statements: when you test statement II alone, forget everything in statement I.
- Accepting two answers: if a statement allows two different answers (for instance x = 5 or -5), it is not sufficient.
- Using outside knowledge: use only what is given (apart from universally true maths facts).
- Calculating too long: once you know that a single answer exists, stop. You do not need its value.
- Ignoring 'definite no': for a yes-or-no question, a definite no is sufficient, just as a definite yes is.
Worked examples
Example 1 (definite no). Question: Is x greater than 10? I: x is less than 5. II: x is a multiple of 3. I: x < 5 means x is definitely not greater than 10, a definite no, so I is sufficient. II: x could be 6 (no) or 12 (yes), so it is not sufficient. Answer: A.
Is x greater than 10?
-
I: x is less than 5
- Definitely not greater than 10
- A definite no
- Sufficient
-
II: x is a multiple of 3
- x could be 6 (no) or 12 (yes)
- Not sufficient
Example 2 (two answers). Question: What is the value of n? I: n squared = 49. II: n is positive. I alone: n = 7 or -7. II alone: no value. Together: n = 7. Answer: C.
Example 3 (stop early). Question: Is Ravi older than Sita? I: Ravi is older than Tara. II: Tara is older than Sita. Neither alone links Ravi and Sita. Together: Ravi > Tara > Sita, so yes. Answer: C, and no calculation is needed.
Example 4 (different information). Question: What is the price of a notebook? I: A notebook costs Rs 5 more than a pen. II: A pen costs Rs 10. Together, a notebook costs Rs 15. Neither alone works. Answer: C.
If a statement leaves two possible answers, it is not sufficient. A definite no is as good as a definite yes.
Key takeaways
- Test each statement alone, with no help from the other.
- Two possible answers means not sufficient.
- A definite no is sufficient.
Check your understanding
-
1. Question: Is x less than 8? Statement I: x is greater than 12. Statement II: x is an odd number. Which is true?
- Statement I alone is sufficient, but II alone is not
- Statement II alone is sufficient, but I alone is not
- Both statements together are needed; neither alone is sufficient
- Even both statements together are not sufficient
Show answer
Answer: A. I: x > 12 means x is definitely not less than 8 - a definite no, which is sufficient. II: x could be 5 (yes) or 11 (no), so it does not decide.
-
2. Question: What is the value of n? Statement I: n squared = 81. Statement II: n is negative. Which is true?
- Statement I alone is sufficient, but II alone is not
- Statement II alone is sufficient, but I alone is not
- Both statements together are needed; neither alone is sufficient
- Each statement alone is sufficient
Show answer
Answer: C. I alone gives n = 9 or n = -9, two answers. II alone gives no value. Together, n = -9. Both together are needed.
-
3. You are testing statement II alone. What should you do with statement I?
- Use it to fill in any missing facts
- Combine it only if II gives two answers
- Forget it completely while you judge II
- Assume that it is false
Show answer
Answer: C. When a statement is tested alone, the other one must be ignored completely. Mixing in facts from statement I is one of the commonest traps.
-
4. Question: Is y negative? Statement I: y squared = 16. Statement II: y - 2 = 2. Which is true?
- Statement I alone is sufficient, but II alone is not
- Statement II alone is sufficient, but I alone is not
- Each statement alone is sufficient
- Even both statements together are not sufficient
Show answer
Answer: B. I gives y = 4 or y = -4, so the sign is not settled. II gives y = 4, so y is definitely not negative - a definite no is sufficient. II alone is sufficient.
-
5. Question: What is the value of p? Statement I: p is greater than 2. Statement II: p is less than 9. Which is true?
- Statement II alone is sufficient, but I alone is not
- Both statements together are needed; neither alone is sufficient
- Each statement alone is sufficient
- Even both statements together are not sufficient
Show answer
Answer: D. Together p lies between 2 and 9, which still allows many values (3, 5, 8 and more). A range is not a single value, so even both together are not sufficient.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.