• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Truth-teller and liar puzzles

Decide who tells the truth from their statements by testing each assumption and checking for contradictions.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

In these puzzles each person either always tells the truth or always lies. Assume one person is truthful, follow the consequences, and check for a contradiction. A statement made by a liar is false; one made by a truthful person is true.

Method

  1. Pick one person and assume they tell the truth.
  2. Work out what their statement implies for the others.
  3. If you reach a contradiction, that person is a liar; try the opposite assumption.
  4. When a consistent assignment is found, check every statement.

Worked example 1

A says 'B is a liar'. B says 'C is a liar'. C says 'A and B are both liars'. Suppose C is truthful: then A and B are liars, so A's statement 'B is a liar' would be true, a contradiction. So C lies. Suppose A is truthful: B is a liar, so B's statement 'C is a liar' is false, meaning C is truthful, contradicting C lying. So A is a liar, hence B is not a liar and B is truthful, and C is a liar as B says. A and C lie; B tells the truth.

Worked example 2

Of two persons, one always tells the truth and one always lies. P says 'We are both liars'. If P were truthful, the statement would be true, making P a liar: a contradiction. So P is a liar, the statement is false, and so Q is truthful.

Assume, follow the consequences, and discard any assumption that contradicts itself.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: assume and test, discard contradictions, and remember that a statement can leave the answer undetermined.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Of X and Y, one always tells the truth and the other always lies. X says: 'I am the truthful one.' Who is truthful?

    1. X
    2. Y
    3. Both
    4. It cannot be determined
    Show answer

    Answer: D. If X is truthful, the statement is true; if X is the liar, the statement is false, which a liar would also say. Both cases fit, so the statement decides nothing.

  2. 2. Of P and Q, one always tells the truth and the other always lies. P says: 'We are of different kinds.' Who is truthful?

    1. Q
    2. Both
    3. It cannot be determined
    4. P
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The puzzle itself guarantees they are of different kinds, so P's statement is true. A liar cannot say something true, so P is truthful and Q is the liar.

  3. 3. A says: 'B is truthful.' B says: 'C is a liar.' C says: 'A is a liar.' Each always tells the truth or always lies. Which must be true?

    1. A is truthful
    2. A and B are of the same kind
    3. C is a liar
    4. All three are liars
    Show answer

    Answer: B. If A is truthful: B is truthful, C lies, and C's 'A is a liar' is false - consistent. If A lies: B lies, so C is truthful, and C's 'A is a liar' is true - also consistent. Two assignments fit; in both, A and B are the same kind.

  4. 4. A says: 'C is a liar.' B says: 'A and C are both liars.' C says: 'B is truthful.' Each always tells the truth or always lies. Who tells the truth?

    1. Only A
    2. Only B
    3. Only C
    4. B and C
    Show answer

    Answer: A. If C were truthful, B would be truthful, so A and C would both be liars - but C is truthful: a contradiction. So C lies, and B is not truthful: B lies. B's statement is then false, and as C is a liar, A must be truthful. A's 'C is a liar' is indeed true.

  5. 5. You assume A is truthful and reach a contradiction. What is the next step?

    1. Declare the puzzle unsolvable
    2. Assume A is truthful again with another person
    3. Take A as a liar and follow the consequences
    4. Ignore A's statement
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A contradiction rules out that case, so A must be a liar. Continue with that and check every statement at the end.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Arrangement and arithmetic puzzles

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery