• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Common traps: facing, 'second from', 'between' and 'not'

Learn the five slips that cost marks in seating questions, see each one go wrong and then right, and build habits that avoid them.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Most marks lost in seating arrangement are not lost because the puzzle is hard. They are lost to a small misreading: the wrong side for left, a miscount, a clue taken as stronger than it is. Knowing the traps in advance is the quickest way to improve your score.

The five traps

TrapWhat goes wrongSafe habit
Facing directionUsing the page's left for a row that faces south, or a circle that faces outsideWrite the facing and its rule at the top of the page
'Second from' and 'second to''Second from the left end' is seat 2, but 'second to the left of Y' is two seats away from YTurn every phrase into a seat number at once
'Between' in a circleA circle has two arcs, so there can be two answersCount along the arc the question names, or the shorter one
'Next to' as 'immediate right''Next to' allows both sides; only 'immediate right' fixes oneKeep both options until another clue decides
'Not' as a placing clue'A is not at an end' does not say where A isUse it only to reject cases

Worked example 1: facing south

Five persons L, M, N, O and P sit in a row facing south. L sits at the extreme left. M sits to the immediate right of L. N sits at the extreme right. O sits to the immediate left of N. Who sits second from the west end of the page? Number the seats 1 to 5 from the west. Facing south, left is east and right is west. L is at the extreme left, which is the east end, seat 5. M is to the immediate right of L, which is west of L, so M is in seat 4. N is at the extreme right, the west end, seat 1. O is immediately left of N, which is east of N, so O is in seat 2. P takes seat 3. West to east: N, O, P, M, L. The answer is O. Reading the row as if it faced north would have put L in seat 1 and made M second from the west, which is the wrong answer.

Worked example 2: 'second from' against 'second to'

In a row of eight persons facing north, X is second from the left end. Y is fifth from the left end. Z is second to the left of Y. Which seats do X and Z occupy? X is simply in seat 2. Z is two seats to the left of Y, so Z = 5 - 2 = seat 3. The two phrases look alike but give different seats: X is in seat 2 and Z is in seat 3, so X and Z are neighbours.

Worked example 3: using a 'not' clue to reject

Four persons A, B, C and D sit in a row facing north. C sits at the left end. A is not at either end. B does not sit next to A. C is in seat 1. A is in seat 2 or 3, because A is not at an end. Try A in seat 3: B cannot be in seat 2 or 4, which are the only seats left, so this case is dead. Try A in seat 2: B cannot be in seat 3, so B takes seat 4 and D takes seat 3. The row is C, A, D, B.

Convert each phrase to a seat number at once, keep both options for 'next to', and use 'not' clues to kill cases, never to place people.

Key takeaways

  • Write the facing rule at the top before placing anyone.
  • 'Second from the end' is a seat; 'second to the left of Y' is a distance from Y.
  • A 'not' clue removes options; it does not place anyone.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In a row that faces south, where is the 'extreme left' of the row on the page?

    1. At the west end of the page
    2. At the north edge of the page
    3. At the middle seat of the row
    4. At the east end of the page
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Facing south, a person's left hand points east. So the extreme left of the row is the east end of the page.

  2. 2. In a row of nine persons facing north, P is sixth from the left end. In which seat does the person second to the left of P sit?

    1. Seat 2
    2. Seat 4
    3. Seat 5
    4. Seat 8
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Second to the left of seat 6 is 6 - 2 = seat 4. Seat 2 would be 'second from the left end', which is a different phrase.

  3. 3. Four persons W, X, Y and Z sit in a row facing north. Z sits at the left end. W is not at either end. X is not next to W. Who sits at the right end?

    1. W
    2. Y
    3. X
    4. Z
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Z is in seat 1, so W is in seat 2 or 3. If W were in seat 3, X would have to be in seat 2 or 4, both next to W or impossible, so the case dies. So W is in seat 2, X cannot be in seat 3, and X takes seat 4. Y takes seat 3.

  4. 4. Why can the question 'Who sits between A and C?' have two answers when the people sit round a circular table?

    1. Two arcs join A and C, and each arc may hold people
    2. Left and right swap whenever people face the table's centre
    3. A circle has no seat numbers that can be counted
    4. People in a circle always sit in pairs of two
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Between two people on a circle there are two arcs. Each may hold one or more people, so the question must name an arc or a direction, or ask for the shorter side.

  5. 5. In a row of seven persons facing north, R sits second from the right end. In which seat does R sit?

    1. Seat 5
    2. Seat 6
    3. Seat 2
    4. Seat 7
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Second from the right end of seven seats is 7 - 2 + 1 = seat 6. Seat 7 is the right end itself.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery