- Advanced
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Who am I? Clue chains, conflicts and odd-one-out
Solve multi-clue identification questions on the personalities of Madhya Pradesh by finding the strongest clue first, resolving conflicts between two similar people and spotting the odd one out.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Hard questions on personalities stop asking 'Where was X born?' and instead give you three or four clues and ask for the person. Some clues fit two people; some options are the right answer to a different question. This lesson shows a method for chains of clues, and it will carry you through the harder lessons that follow.
Clue sets for the main figures
| Clue set | Person |
|---|---|
| Born at Bhavra; took the name 'Azad'; died at Alfred Park in 1931 | Chandrashekhar Azad |
| Born in Maharashtra; companion of Nana Sahib; executed at Shivpuri | Tantia Tope |
| Born at Chondi; ruled from Maheshwar between 1767 and 1795 | Ahilyabai Holkar |
| Chandela princess; Gond kingdom; fought Asaf Khan in 1564 | Rani Durgavati |
| Born in Karnataka; settled at Dewas; classical singer | Kumar Gandharva |
| Born at Mhow; Chairman of the Drafting Committee; Bharat Ratna in 1990 | Dr B. R. Ambedkar |
| Born in 1929 at Indore; Bharat Ratna in 2001 | Lata Mangeshkar |
Find the strongest clue
Solving a clue chain
- List every clue
- Mark the clue that only one person can fit (a year, a rare place)
- Test the other clues against that person
- Reject options that fail even one clue
A year or a rare place is a strong clue. 'Died in 2022' fits Lata Mangeshkar and nobody else in this course. 'Executed at Shivpuri' fits Tantia Tope. A common clue such as 'born in 1929' is weak, because two singers were born in that year; it is useful only to remove the rest of the field.
Conflicts between similar people
Some pairs are deliberately made to look alike. Kishore Kumar and Lata Mangeshkar were both born in 1929, both sang in films and both belong to the state, but the birthplace (Khandwa or Indore), the date of death (1987 or 2022) and the honour (Bharat Ratna in 2001 for Lata Mangeshkar) separate them. Tansen and Allauddin Khan are both tied to places of music, but one is of Akbar's court and the other of Maihar. Rani Durgavati and Ahilyabai are both queens, but one is a Gond queen of 1564 and the other a Holkar ruler of the late eighteenth century.
Odd one out
An odd-one-out question hides a single rule that separates one name from the others. Find the common rule of three names first. For instance, Tantia Tope, Shankar Shah and Rani Avantibai all belong to the events of 1857-59. Chandrashekhar Azad belongs to the twentieth century. So Azad is the odd one out in that set. In another set Tansen, Allauddin Khan and Kumar Gandharva are classical musicians, while Kishore Kumar is a film singer.
Worked examples
Example 1. Clues: 'She was a Chandela princess. She ruled Garha-Mandla. She fought a Mughal general in 1564.' Working: the year 1564 and Garha-Mandla are the strong clues, and they fit only Rani Durgavati. The Chandela clue agrees. Answer: Rani Durgavati.
Example 2. Which is the odd one out: Shankar Shah, Tantia Tope, Rani Avantibai, Chandrashekhar Azad? Working: the first three belong to the 1857-59 period. Azad was born in 1906. Answer: Chandrashekhar Azad.
Example 3. Clues: 'Born in 1929, died in Mumbai, born in Madhya Pradesh, a playback singer.' Working: both Kishore Kumar and Lata Mangeshkar fit all four, so a fifth clue is needed. If the question adds 'died in 2022', only Lata Mangeshkar fits. Answer: Lata Mangeshkar.
When two clues seem to conflict, suspect that one belongs to a different person. If a question says 'born at Khandwa' and 'Bharat Ratna', the two clues cannot belong to the same person in this course, so one of the options is deliberately built from two different people. Such a mixed option is always wrong.
One strong clue, then test the rest. Reject any option that fails a clue.
Key takeaways. Pick the strongest clue first: a year, a rare place or a unique honour. Treat similar pairs with care. Odd-one-out questions depend on one rule that three names share.
Check your understanding
-
1. Born in Maharashtra, companion of Nana Sahib, executed at Shivpuri in 1859: who am I?
- Shankar Shah
- Tantia Tope
- Chhatrasal
- Chandrashekhar Azad
Show answer
Answer: B. Executed at Shivpuri in 1859 and a companion of Nana Sahib fits only Tantia Tope.
-
2. Which is the odd one out among Tantia Tope, Shankar Shah, Rani Avantibai and Chandrashekhar Azad?
- Tantia Tope
- Shankar Shah
- Rani Avantibai
- Chandrashekhar Azad
Show answer
Answer: D. The first three belong to 1857-59, while Azad belonged to the revolutionary movement of the twentieth century.
-
3. Born in 1929 at Indore, died in 2022: who am I?
- Lata Mangeshkar
- Kishore Kumar
- Kumar Gandharva
- Ustad Allauddin Khan
Show answer
Answer: A. Kishore Kumar was born at Khandwa and died in 1987. Lata Mangeshkar died in 2022.
-
4. Assertion (A): Ahilyabai Holkar is counted among the personalities of Madhya Pradesh. Reason (R): She ruled from Maheshwar on the Narmada.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: C. Ahilyabai was born in Maharashtra, but she ruled from Maheshwar, and that is the reason she belongs to the state's list.
-
5. Statement 1: Subhadra Kumari Chauhan was born at Jabalpur. Statement 2: Kumar Gandharva was born in Karnataka. Which is correct?
- Only statement 1
- Both statements
- Only statement 2
- Neither statement
Show answer
Answer: C. She was born at Nihalpur near Allahabad and lived at Jabalpur, so statement 1 is wrong. Kumar Gandharva was born in Karnataka, so statement 2 is correct.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.