• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Judiciary and constitutional bodies: who appoints, who removes

Compare the High Court, subordinate courts, the State Public Service Commission and the State Election Commission by appointment, removal and function.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Another favourite exam pattern asks 'who appoints' and 'who removes' for a set of bodies. The easy way is a table with columns for appointing authority and removing authority. This lesson fills the table for the courts and the main constitutional bodies of a state.

The table to learn

Appointment and removal
BodyAppointed byRemoved by / how
High Court judgePresident (Article 217)President, on an address from Parliament
District judgeGovernor, after consulting the High Court (Article 233)Under the High Court's control
Public Service Commission memberGovernor (Article 316)President, after inquiry by the Supreme Court (Article 317)
State Election CommissionerGovernor (Article 243K)Like a High Court judge
Advocate GeneralGovernor (Article 165)At the Governor's pleasure

High Court details

A High Court judge holds office until the age of 62 (Article 217). The High Court has the power of superintendence over all the courts below it in its area (Article 227), and its control over subordinate court officers is stated in Article 235. The High Court of Madhya Pradesh has its principal seat at Jabalpur.

Courts of the state

  • High Court
    • Principal seat at Jabalpur
    • Judges appointed by the President
  • District courts
    • Judges appointed by the Governor with the High Court
    • Controlled by the High Court
  • Lower courts
    • Subordinate to the district courts
A simple ladder

Public Service Commission

The state has a Public Service Commission, provided by Article 315. Its members hold office for six years or until age 62, whichever is earlier. They are appointed by the Governor but can be removed only by the President after an inquiry by the Supreme Court, which protects their independence.

Traps

  • Appointed by the Governor does not mean removed by the Governor. For Commission members the President removes.
  • District judges are appointed by the Governor, but High Court judges by the President.
  • The oath of the Governor is given by the High Court's Chief Justice; this does not make the Court a superior of the Governor.
  • The Election Commission of India (Article 324) is not the state body for local elections.

Worked example 1: who removes?

Question: who can remove a member of the State Public Service Commission? Working: the President, after an inquiry by the Supreme Court. The Governor appoints but does not remove.

Worked example 2: retirement age

Question: a High Court judge was born on 1 July 1960. In which year does the judge retire? Working: 1960 plus 62 equals 2022. Retirement is at 62, so the year is 2022.

Worked example 3: district judges

Question: who appoints district judges? Working: the Governor, after consulting the High Court (Article 233).

Worked example 4: appoints but does not remove

Question: for which office does the Governor appoint but not remove? Options: Advocate General, Public Service Commission member, Chief Minister, Council of Ministers. Working: the Advocate General holds office at the Governor's pleasure, so the Governor can end it. The Chief Minister and the ministers can be dismissed or must resign under the rules of responsibility to the assembly. A Commission member is appointed by the Governor but removable only by the President after a Supreme Court inquiry. So the answer is the Public Service Commission member, which shows how independence is protected. This kind of question tests understanding of roles, so think of what each office does.

When the options look alike, ask: who selects, who dismisses and how secure is the term? Independence of a body shows in the answers.

Judges: President. District judges: Governor with the High Court. Commission members: Governor appoints, President removes.

Key takeaways: build the table of appointing and removing authorities. High Court judges retire at 62. Commission members have a six-year term or age 62, and are protected by the Supreme Court inquiry.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A High Court judge is appointed by:

    1. The Governor alone
    2. The Chief Minister
    3. The Collector
    4. The President
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Article 217.

  2. 2. District judges are appointed by the Governor after consulting:

    1. The High Court
    2. The Speaker
    3. The Collector
    4. The Public Service Commission
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 233.

  3. 3. At what age does a High Court judge retire?

    1. 58
    2. 60
    3. 62
    4. 65
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Article 217 sets the age at 62.

  4. 4. Who can remove a Public Service Commission member?

    1. The Governor alone
    2. The President, after Supreme Court inquiry
    3. The Speaker
    4. The Chief Minister
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Article 317.

  5. 5. Control over the subordinate courts of the state is with the:

    1. Collector
    2. Speaker
    3. Public Service Commission
    4. High Court
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Articles 227 and 235.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery