• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Atmospheric refraction: twinkling stars, mirages and early sunrise

Explain how the changing refractive index of air causes stars to twinkle, planets not to twinkle, mirages, shimmering above a fire, and the Sun being visible before sunrise and after sunset.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain how the refractive index of air changes with height and temperature.
  • Explain why stars twinkle but planets do not.
  • Explain mirages, shimmering objects above a fire, and the advanced sunrise and delayed sunset.

The earth's atmosphere is not uniform. Its density, and so its refractive index, changes with height and temperature. Light passing through it bends gradually, and this atmospheric refraction produces several beautiful and puzzling effects.

How air changes

  • Air is denser near the ground, so its refractive index increases as we go down towards the earth's surface.
  • Hot air is rarer than cold air, so it has a smaller refractive index.
  • Moving air (wind, rising hot air) keeps changing the density and temperature, so the refractive index keeps changing from moment to moment.

Twinkling of stars

Stars are so far away that they appear as point sources of light. Starlight entering the atmosphere passes from rarer to denser air and keeps bending towards the normal. So a star appears higher in the sky than its actual position. Because the air is always moving and its density and temperature keep changing, the refractive index keeps changing, so the apparent position and brightness of the star keep changing slightly. The star appears to twinkle.

Why planets do not twinkle

Planets are much closer to us, so they do not look like points; each looks like a tiny disc, a collection of many point sources. The light from each point flickers, but the changes cancel out on average, so the average position and total brightness stay steady. Planets therefore do not twinkle.

Star versus planet

  • Star
    • Very far away
    • Seen as a point source
    • Changes in air shift its whole light
    • Position and brightness flicker: it twinkles
  • Planet
    • Much closer
    • Seen as a tiny disc of many point sources
    • Flickers of different points average out
    • Steady light: it does not twinkle

Mirage and shimmering above a fire

On a hot day, the air just above a road or desert sand is very hot and rarer than the cooler air above it. Light coming down from a distant object or the sky passes into layers of smaller and smaller refractive index and keeps bending away from the normal, until it curves upwards towards the eye. The eye traces the ray back, so the object appears to come from an image below the ground, like a reflection in water. This illusion is a mirage.

Objects seen through the hot air rising above a bonfire, such as a Holi fire, seem to shake. The rising hot air keeps changing the refractive index, so the direction of light from the objects keeps changing.

Advanced sunrise and delayed sunset

Sunrise means the Sun appearing above the horizon. But even when the Sun is slightly below the horizon, its light reaches us along a curved path because of refraction in the atmosphere. So we see the Sun a little before it actually rises. In the same way, after sunset we keep seeing the Sun for a short while even after it has gone below the horizon. Atmospheric refraction thus makes the day slightly longer.

Worked example: explain the observation

  1. Observation: on a hot afternoon a highway far ahead looks wet. Reason: a mirage; light from the sky bends upwards in the hot, rarer air near the road, so we see an image of the sky that looks like water.
  2. Observation: a bright 'star' low in the evening sky shines steadily. Reason: it is probably a planet; being close, it acts as many point sources whose flickers average out.
  3. Observation: astronauts above the atmosphere see stars shining steadily. Reason: there is no atmosphere to change the refractive index, so there is no twinkling.

Key takeaways: the refractive index of air increases closer to the ground and decreases where air is hot; moving air keeps changing it. This makes stars appear higher and twinkle, while planets shine steadily. Hot air near the ground causes mirages; refraction lets us see the Sun before sunrise and after sunset.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Why do stars appear to twinkle?

    1. The stars switch on and off
    2. Clouds keep passing in front of them
    3. They move quickly across the sky
    4. The refractive index of the air keeps changing because the air is moving
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Moving air keeps changing in density and temperature, so its refractive index keeps changing. The apparent position and brightness of the point-like star flicker, and it twinkles.

  2. 2. The Sun can still be seen for a short while after it has actually gone below the horizon. Which process makes this possible?

    1. Reflection of light by clouds
    2. Atmospheric refraction
    3. Dispersion of light
    4. Persistence of vision
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Refraction in the atmosphere bends sunlight along a curved path, so it reaches us even when the Sun is slightly below the horizon.

  3. 3. Why do planets not twinkle?

    1. They are closer and act as a collection of point sources whose changes average out
    2. They are farther than stars
    3. They produce their own light
    4. There is no atmosphere between us and them
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Being close, a planet appears as a tiny disc made of many point sources. The flickering of different points averages out, so the total brightness and position stay steady.

  4. 4. The air just above a hot road is:

    1. Denser, with a higher refractive index
    2. Exactly like the air above it
    3. Rarer, with a lower refractive index
    4. A solid layer
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Hot air is rarer than cool air, so its refractive index is lower. Light passing down into it bends away from the normal and curves upwards, producing a mirage.

  5. 5. Because of atmospheric refraction, a star appears:

    1. Lower than its actual position
    2. At its actual position
    3. Higher than its actual position
    4. Below the horizon
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Starlight bends towards the normal as it enters denser lower air. Tracing the ray back, the eye sees the star higher than it actually is.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery