- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Darwin, Lamarck, speciation and human evolution
Explain Darwin's theory of natural selection and its objections, explain Lamarckism and why it was rejected, describe how new species form, and outline the main stages of human evolution.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- State Darwin's theory of natural selection and three objections raised against it.
- Explain Lamarck's use and disuse and inheritance of acquired characters, and why it was rejected.
- Explain speciation and outline the journey of human evolution.
Evidence tells us that evolution happened. Theories try to explain how. This lesson compares the two classic theories, then looks at how new species form and how human beings themselves evolved.
Darwin's theory of natural selection
Charles Darwin (1809-1882), an English biologist, collected and studied a huge number of plant and animal specimens. In his book On the Origin of Species he set out the theory of natural selection, often summed up as survival of the fittest.
Darwin's argument
- Over-production All organisms reproduce in large numbers.
- Struggle They compete fiercely for survival.
- Variation Individuals that have useful modifications win the competition.
- Natural selection Nature selects the fit; the rest perish.
- New species The selected organisms reproduce, and over generations new species arise.
The theory was accepted for a long time, but objections were raised: natural selection is not the only factor in evolution; Darwin did not explain how useful and useless modifications arise; and he did not explain slow versus sudden changes. Even so, his work remains a milestone. (Later, mutation and genetics filled some of these gaps.)
Lamarckism
Jean-Baptiste Lamarck (1744-1829), a French naturalist, proposed that the activity or inactivity of an organism changes its organs. This is the principle of use and disuse of organs. He further claimed that such changes, called acquired characters, are passed on to the next generation: the inheritance of acquired characters.
| Lamarck's example | His explanation |
|---|---|
| Long neck of the giraffe | Stretching the neck to browse tall trees over many generations |
| Strong shoulders of a blacksmith | Constant hammering |
| Weak wings of ostrich and emu | Wings not used |
| Webbed swimming feet of ducks and swans | Living in water |
| Legless snakes | Body modified for a burrowing habit |
That use develops an organ and disuse weakens it was widely accepted. But the claim that these changes are inherited was rejected, because repeated tests showed that changes acquired during life are not passed on. A blacksmith's child is not born with strong shoulders.
Worked example 1: Darwin or Lamarck?
Explain the giraffe's long neck both ways. Lamarck: each giraffe stretched its neck, the stretch was inherited, and necks grew longer generation after generation. Darwin: giraffes already varied in neck length; those with longer necks reached more food, survived and reproduced more, so long necks became common. Only the Darwinian explanation fits the evidence that acquired changes are not inherited.
Speciation
A species is a group of organisms that can produce fertile offspring by natural reproduction. Formation of new species, speciation, is the result of evolution. Genetic variation is the basic cause. Geographical isolation (a population split by a river, mountain or sea) and reproductive isolation (groups that no longer interbreed) allow differences to build up until a new species forms.
Worked example 2
One population of beetles is split by a new river. After a very long time, beetles from the two sides no longer produce fertile offspring together. What happened? Geographical isolation stopped interbreeding; different variations built up on each side; reproductive isolation followed. A new species has formed.
The journey of human evolution
Human evolution followed the same slow route. After the last dinosaurs disappeared, roughly 6.5 to 7 crore years ago, monkey-like animals arose from lemur-like ancestors. Ape-like forms evolved as the brain enlarged and the hands improved. As forests declined, some apes came to live on the ground; changes in the pelvic girdle let them stand erect and freed their hands. The textbook records Ramapithecus from North India and East Africa as an early human-like ape. Approximate stages after that are shown below.
Main stages of human evolution (approximate)
- Australopithecus Ape of southern Africa, about 40 lakh years ago.
- Skilled human (Homo habilis) Early member of the genus Homo, about 20 lakh years ago.
- Erect human (Homo erectus) Walked upright, about 15 lakh years ago; discovered fire.
- Neanderthal man About 1.5 lakh years ago; an early wise man.
- Cro-Magnon man About 50 thousand years ago; evolution became faster.
Around 10 thousand years ago humans began agriculture, kept cattle and built cities. Writing appeared about 5000 years ago, beginning recorded history; modern science emerged about 400 years ago and industrial society about 200 years ago.
Darwin: variation + struggle + natural selection → new species. Lamarck: use and disuse + inheritance of acquired characters (rejected).
Key takeaways
- Darwin's natural selection: the fit survive and reproduce; objections concern other factors and the origin of variations.
- Lamarck's inheritance of acquired characters was disproved.
- Genetic variation, with geographical and reproductive isolation, leads to speciation.
- Humans evolved gradually through stages such as Australopithecus, Homo habilis, Homo erectus, Neanderthal and Cro-Magnon man.
Check your understanding
-
1. 'Survival of the fittest' is the central idea of
- Lamarckism
- Darwin's theory of natural selection
- de Vries's mutation theory
- the central dogma
Show answer
Answer: B. Darwin proposed that nature selects organisms fit for their surroundings while the rest perish; this is summed up as survival of the fittest.
-
2. Which part of Lamarck's theory was rejected?
- That organisms vary
- That use strengthens an organ
- That acquired characters are inherited
- That evolution is gradual
Show answer
Answer: C. Tests showed that changes acquired during life are not passed to offspring, so the inheritance of acquired characters was rejected. Use developing an organ was accepted.
-
3. Which of these is NOT an objection raised against Darwin's theory?
- Natural selection is not the only factor in evolution
- It does not explain how useful and useless modifications arise
- It does not explain slow and sudden changes
- Organisms do not compete with one another
Show answer
Answer: D. Competition among organisms is part of Darwin's theory itself, not an objection to it. The other three are the objections listed in the chapter.
-
4. A group of organisms that can produce fertile offspring by natural reproduction is a
- species
- genus
- fossil
- connecting link
Show answer
Answer: A. That is the definition of a species. Speciation is the formation of new species.
-
5. Which order of human ancestors is correct, from oldest to most recent?
- Neanderthal, Australopithecus, Homo erectus, Cro-Magnon
- Australopithecus, Homo habilis, Homo erectus, Cro-Magnon
- Homo erectus, Homo habilis, Cro-Magnon, Neanderthal
- Cro-Magnon, Neanderthal, Homo habilis, Australopithecus
Show answer
Answer: B. Australopithecus (about 40 lakh years ago) came first, then Homo habilis (about 20 lakh), Homo erectus (about 15 lakh) and, much later, Cro-Magnon man (about 50 thousand years ago).
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.