• Practice
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Postulates, theorems and proofs: direct and indirect proof

Know what a postulate and a theorem are, recall some of Euclid's postulates, and follow both a direct proof and an indirect proof (proof by contradiction).

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Distinguish a postulate from a theorem.
  • Recall some of Euclid's postulates.
  • Write a direct proof that vertically opposite angles are equal.
  • Explain the steps of an indirect proof and use one to prove a simple statement.

Until now you have checked many properties of angles and triangles by measuring. Measurement can only show that something seems true for the figures you drew. A proof shows that it must be true for every figure. This way of building geometry goes back to the Greek mathematician Euclid, who lived in the third century before the Christian Era and organised the geometry known in his time.

Postulates and theorems

Euclid took some simple statements as true without proof, because everyone accepts them. These are postulates. Properties that are then proved logically from postulates and earlier results are theorems, and the logical argument is the proof. Some of Euclid's postulates are:

  1. Infinitely many lines pass through a point.
  2. One and only one line passes through two distinct points.
  3. A circle of any given radius can be drawn with any point as its centre.
  4. All right angles are congruent to each other.
  5. If the two interior angles on one side of a transversal of two lines add up to less than two right angles, then the lines, produced on that side, meet. (This fifth postulate is used in the next chapter.)

How geometry is built

  • Undefined terms
    • Point, line, plane
  • Postulates
    • Accepted without proof
    • Example: one line through two points
  • Theorems
    • Proved from postulates and earlier theorems
    • Each has Given, To prove, Proof

A direct proof

In a direct proof we start from the given facts and move step by step, giving a reason for every step, until we reach the statement to be proved.

Theorem: Vertically opposite angles are congruent. Given: line PQ and line RS intersect at O, with P - O - Q and R - O - S. To prove: ∠POR = ∠QOS.

  1. ∠POR + ∠ROQ = 180°, because they form a linear pair (ray OP and ray OQ are opposite rays).
  2. ∠ROQ + ∠QOS = 180°, because they also form a linear pair (ray OR and ray OS are opposite rays).
  3. So ∠POR + ∠ROQ = ∠ROQ + ∠QOS, from steps 1 and 2.
  4. Subtracting ∠ROQ from both sides gives ∠POR = ∠QOS. In the same way ∠ROQ = ∠POS.

An indirect proof

In an indirect proof we begin by assuming that the statement to be proved is false. Using that assumption and accepted facts, we reason until we reach a contradiction with the given part or with a known property. The contradiction shows the assumption was wrong, so the statement must be true. This is also called proof by contradiction.

Steps of an indirect proof

  1. Assume the opposite Suppose the consequent is false.
  2. Reason step by step Use the assumption with known facts.
  3. Reach a contradiction Something clashes with the given part or a known property.
  4. Reject the assumption So the consequent must be true.

Worked example: an indirect proof

Statement: If the square of a whole number n is odd, then n is odd. Given: n² is odd. To prove: n is odd. Proof: Suppose n is not odd. Then n is even, so n = 2k for some whole number k. Then n² = 4k² = 2(2k²), which is even. But we are given that n² is odd. This is a contradiction, so the assumption that n is even is false. Therefore n is odd.

Postulate: accepted without proof. Theorem: proved logically. Direct proof: given → reasons → result. Indirect proof: assume the result is false → reach a contradiction → the result is true.

Key takeaways: geometry is built from undefined terms, postulates and theorems. Every proof starts from the Given part of a conditional statement and ends at the To prove part, with a reason for each step. A direct proof argues straight forward; an indirect proof assumes the opposite and reaches a contradiction.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A statement accepted as true without proof is called a

    1. theorem
    2. postulate
    3. converse
    4. corollary
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Statements accepted without proof, such as 'one and only one line passes through two distinct points', are postulates. Theorems are proved.

  2. 2. According to one of Euclid's postulates, how many lines pass through two distinct points?

    1. Exactly one
    2. Two
    3. Infinitely many
    4. None
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Euclid's postulate says one and only one line passes through two distinct points. Infinitely many lines pass through a single point.

  3. 3. Two lines intersect and one of the angles formed is 68°. What is the angle vertically opposite to it?

    1. 112°
    2. 22°
    3. 68°
    4. 136°
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Vertically opposite angles are congruent, so the opposite angle is also 68°. The angles next to it are 180° − 68° = 112°.

  4. 4. What is the first step of an indirect proof?

    1. Measure the angles in a figure
    2. Write the converse
    3. Draw a construction line
    4. Assume that the statement to be proved is false
    Show answer

    Answer: D. An indirect proof begins by assuming the consequent is false and then reasons to a contradiction.

  5. 5. In the proof that vertically opposite angles are congruent, which fact is used in the first two steps?

    1. Angles in a linear pair add up to 180°
    2. Angles of a triangle add up to 180°
    3. Alternate angles are equal
    4. All right angles are congruent
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Each angle is paired with a common neighbouring angle in a linear pair, and angles in a linear pair add up to 180°. Comparing the two equations gives the result.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery