• Advanced
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

From Bombay State to Maharashtra: constitutional status and Article 371(2)

Understand the constitutional route by which Maharashtra was formed, what Articles 3 and 4 allow, the status of the earlier units, and the Governor's special duty for regional development.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

At this level, examiners ask not only when Maharashtra was formed but how the Constitution allowed it, what the earlier units were in law, and what special arrangement was made to protect the less developed regions. This lesson goes through each of these.

The status of the earlier units

Under the Constitution of 1950 the states were grouped into Parts A, B and C. The three units that gave Maharashtra its territory were of different kinds.

Three earlier units
Earlier unitConstitutional status in 1950Gave
Bombay StatePart A state, formerly a British provinceWestern Maharashtra, Konkan and Khandesh
Hyderabad StatePart B state, formerly a princely stateMarathwada
Madhya PradeshPart A state, formerly Central Provinces and BerarVidarbha

The States Reorganisation Act, 1956, together with the Seventh Amendment, ended the Part A, B and C classes. After 1 November 1956 India had only states and Union Territories. Bombay State was enlarged, while Hyderabad and Madhya Pradesh lost territory.

Articles 3 and 4: how a state can be formed

  • Article 3 lets Parliament, by law, form a new state, change the boundaries of a state, or change its name.
  • The bill may be introduced only on the recommendation of the President.
  • The President must refer the bill to the legislature of the affected state for its views, but those views are not binding.
  • Under Article 4, such a law is not a constitutional amendment under Article 368, so it needs only a simple majority.

The Bombay Reorganisation Act, 1960, was made in this manner. This is why the creation of Maharashtra did not need the special majority required to amend the Constitution.

Route to a new state under Article 3

  1. President's recommendation Needed before the bill is introduced
  2. Reference to state legislature Views are asked for, not binding
  3. Parliament passes the law Simple majority
  4. State comes into being On the date named in the Act
How Maharashtra was made legally

Article 371(2): development boards

When Maharashtra and Gujarat were formed, there was a fear that the less developed regions, Vidarbha and Marathwada, would be neglected. Article 371(2) therefore gave the President power to provide that the Governor of Maharashtra has a special responsibility for establishing separate development boards for Vidarbha, Marathwada and the rest of Maharashtra, and for the equitable allocation of funds for development spending across them. This is one of the few matters in which the Governor acts in a special role, rather than only on ministerial advice.

Worked example 1: simple or special majority?

Question: to divide Bombay State, did Parliament need the majority required to amend the Constitution? Working: Article 3 gave Parliament the power to form states by ordinary law, and Article 4 says that such a law is not an amendment under Article 368. So a simple majority was enough. The answer is no.

Worked example 2: binding or not?

Question: if the legislature of an affected state opposes a reorganisation bill, must Parliament drop it? Working: the President must refer the bill to the state legislature, but Article 3 does not make its view binding. Parliament may proceed. So the answer is no; the view only has to be obtained.

Worked example 3: classify the older unit

Question: which of the three older units was a former princely state, and which region did it give? Working: Hyderabad was the princely state, and it was a Part B state in 1950. It gave Marathwada. So the answer is Hyderabad and Marathwada.

Article 3 forms the state by ordinary law (Article 4); Article 371(2) protects Vidarbha and Marathwada with development boards.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways. Bombay and Madhya Pradesh were Part A states and Hyderabad was Part B. States are formed under Article 3 by simple majority, and the state legislature's view is not binding. Article 371(2) sets the Governor's special responsibility for regional boards.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which article empowers Parliament to form a new state by law?

    1. Article 1
    2. Article 368
    3. Article 3
    4. Article 371(2)
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Article 3 lets Parliament form states and alter boundaries; Article 368 is for amending the Constitution.

  2. 2. Consider the following about the formation of Maharashtra. Statement 1: The state legislature's view on a reorganisation bill is binding on Parliament. Statement 2: A law under Article 3 is not treated as a constitutional amendment under Article 368.

    1. 1 only
    2. 2 only
    3. Both 1 and 2
    4. Neither 1 nor 2
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The view must be sought but does not bind Parliament (statement 1 is false). Article 4 says such a law is not an amendment under Article 368 (statement 2 is true).

  3. 3. In 1950, Hyderabad State was classified as a

    1. Part B state
    2. Part A state
    3. Part C state
    4. Union Territory
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Hyderabad was a former princely state ranked as a Part B state.

  4. 4. Under Article 371(2), the Governor of Maharashtra can have a special responsibility for

    1. Appointing the Chief Minister without advice
    2. Dissolving the Vidhan Parishad
    3. Appointing High Court judges
    4. Development boards for Vidarbha, Marathwada and the rest of Maharashtra
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The Article 371(2) arrangement concerns regional development boards and equitable allocation of funds.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Maharashtra could be created by an ordinary law of Parliament. Reason (R): Article 4 provides that a law made under Article 3 is not an amendment under Article 368.

    1. Both are true, but the reason does not explain the assertion
    2. The assertion is true, but the reason is false
    3. The assertion is false, but the reason is true
    4. Both the assertion and the reason are true, and the reason explains the assertion
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Both are true, and the reason explains why a simple majority sufficed.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery