- Advanced
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
River basins, upstream and downstream, and the law of shared rivers
Use the ideas of upper and lower riparian states to place Maharashtra on its shared rivers, and learn how India's Constitution and law handle river disputes.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
At the advanced level the question changes from 'where is the river?' to 'who shares it, and who decides?'. Almost every large river of Maharashtra crosses a state boundary, so water is a matter of law and negotiation as well as geography. This lesson gives you the vocabulary and the constitutional frame for such questions.
Upper and lower riparian
A state through which a river flows is a riparian state. A state nearer the source is upper riparian (upstream) and a state nearer the mouth is lower riparian (downstream). A state in between has both roles at once. Look at where Maharashtra stands on each river.
| River | Where it rises | Maharashtra is | Downstream states or end |
|---|---|---|---|
| Godavari | Inside Maharashtra (Nashik) | Upper riparian | Telangana, then Andhra Pradesh |
| Krishna | Inside Maharashtra (Mahabaleshwar) | Upper riparian | Karnataka, then Telangana and Andhra Pradesh |
| Bhima | Inside Maharashtra (Bhimashankar) | Upper riparian | Joins the Krishna in Karnataka |
| Tapi | Outside, in Madhya Pradesh | Middle riparian | Gujarat, then the sea |
| Wainganga | Outside, in Madhya Pradesh | Middle riparian | Joins the Wardha to form the Pranhita |
Upstream and downstream state interests
-
An upper riparian state
- Controls where dams are built
- Wants to store and use water at home
- Is often accused of holding back flows
-
A lower riparian state
- Depends on what is released
- Fears that its farms will dry
- Asks for a fixed share in law
What the Constitution says
- Water, including water supplies, irrigation and canals, is on the State List.
- The regulation and development of inter-State rivers, to the extent Parliament declares, is on the Union List.
- Article 262 lets Parliament make a law to settle disputes about the water of an inter-State river, and to keep such disputes away from the courts.
- Parliament used this power in the Inter-State River Water Disputes Act, 1956, under which a tribunal can be set up.
How an inter-State water dispute is settled
- A State complains It asks the Centre to refer the dispute
- The Centre tries talks Negotiation between the States
- Talks fail The Centre sets up a tribunal
- The tribunal decides It gives an award on sharing
- The award is binding As if it were a decree of the Supreme Court
Tribunals have been set up for the Krishna and the Godavari, both of which are shared by Maharashtra with other states. The basin approach is the key idea: the tribunal looks at the whole river, not at one state's portion.
Worked example 1: classify
Question: 'Is Maharashtra upper or lower riparian on the Krishna?' Working: the Krishna rises at Mahabaleshwar inside Maharashtra and then flows to Karnataka. Maharashtra is nearer the source, so it is upper riparian.
Worked example 2: a state in the middle
Question: 'Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra and Gujarat share the Tapi. Which is the lower riparian?' Working: the Tapi rises in Madhya Pradesh, crosses Maharashtra and reaches the sea through Gujarat. The state nearest the mouth is Gujarat.
Worked example 3: which law?
Question: 'Which Article lets Parliament provide for settling inter-State river disputes?' Working: the provision on inter-State river water disputes is Article 262.
Source state = upstream. Mouth state = downstream. Water is a State subject, but inter-State rivers can be regulated by the Union. Article 262, 1956 Act, tribunal.
Key takeaways: Maharashtra is upper riparian on the Godavari, Krishna and Bhima and a middle state on the Tapi. Article 262 and the 1956 Act provide a tribunal route for inter-State disputes. Think basin, not boundary.
Check your understanding
-
1. Maharashtra is the upper riparian state on the:
- Tapi
- Narmada
- Wainganga
- Krishna
Show answer
Answer: D. The Krishna rises inside Maharashtra and flows down to other states, so Maharashtra is upstream.
-
2. Which state is lower riparian on the Tapi?
- Madhya Pradesh
- Gujarat
- Telangana
- Goa
Show answer
Answer: B. The Tapi reaches the sea through Gujarat, so Gujarat is downstream of Maharashtra.
-
3. Article 262 deals with:
- the formation of new districts
- the use of forests
- disputes about inter-State river water
- the rights of fishermen
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 262 allows a law for settling inter-State river water disputes.
-
4. Statement 1: Water is a State subject in the Constitution. Statement 2: Parliament can nevertheless regulate inter-State rivers as declared by law. Which is correct?
- 1 only
- 2 only
- Both 1 and 2
- Neither 1 nor 2
Show answer
Answer: C. Both are right. Water is on the State List, while the regulation of inter-State rivers is on the Union List to the extent Parliament declares.
-
5. Assertion (A): A lower riparian state may ask for a fixed share of a river. Reason (R): It depends on the water that flows past the upper state.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true but R is false
- A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both true, and R explains A: dependence on released water is why the lower state seeks a legal share.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.