- Advanced
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Reading statement questions: when one wrong word makes a statement false
Test multi-statement questions on the people of Manipur by checking each part against the facts, and learn how a single wrong word, date or group makes a statement false.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
In advanced papers, a personality question is rarely a plain 'who was this?'. It is a set of statements, and you must decide which are true. The facts are the same ones you know, but each statement mixes them. A statement is true only if every part is true, so your job is to find the one wrong word.
Five kinds of wrong word
How a statement becomes false
-
Wrong person
- Gaidinliu hanged in 1931
- Khamba Thoibi Sheireng by Irabot
-
Wrong date
- Treaty of Yandabo in 1891
- Merger Agreement in 1972
-
Wrong group
- Mirabai Chanu as a boxer
- Paona Brajabashi as a poet
-
Wrong event
- Patriots' Day for the battle
- Khongjom Day for the hanging
-
Wrong word of degree
- Only, always, first, never
The method
- Split the statement into small parts: person, act, date or place.
- Test each part alone against what you know.
- If one part fails, the whole statement is false.
- Only after that, count how many statements are true.
Notice that you do not need to be sure of every fact. If you can show one part is false, you are done. This is why a clear grid of the key facts helps even in hard questions.
Words of degree
Words such as only, first, always and never make a statement strong, and strong statements are often false. For example, 'Bhagyachandra is the only Manipuri king connected with the Company' goes beyond the facts, because Gambhir Singh also worked with British support. A moderate statement such as 'Bhagyachandra made a treaty with the Company in 1762' is safe and true.
A table of true and false versions
| True statement | False twin |
|---|---|
| Tikendrajit was hanged on 13 August 1891 | Tikendrajit fell at Khongjom on 23 April 1891 |
| Rani Gaidinliu followed Jadonang | Rani Gaidinliu started the Heraka movement |
| Mary Kom won Olympic bronze in 2012 | Mary Kom won Olympic silver at Tokyo |
| Hijam Irabot supported the Second Nupi Lan | Hijam Irabot led the First Nupi Lan in 1904 |
| Bodhachandra Singh signed the Merger Agreement at Shillong | Bodhachandra Singh signed it at Imphal on 21 January 1972 |
Why examiners like this format
A statement question lets an examiner test five or six facts in one question. A student who knows only half the facts can still be trapped, because the false twin looks so much like the true statement. That is why this course keeps repeating the pairs: Tikendrajit and Paona Brajabashi, Jadonang and Gaidinliu, Mary Kom and Mirabai Chanu. When you meet a statement, ask first which pair it belongs to, and then ask which member of the pair the statement is really about.
Worked example 1: two statements
Statements: (1) Paona Brajabashi fell at Khongjom. (2) Khongjom Day is observed on 13 August. Working: statement 1 is true. Khongjom Day is 23 April, so statement 2 is false. Answer: only statement 1 is correct.
Worked example 2: a word of degree
Statement: 'Hijam Irabot was the only leader linked with the Second Nupi Lan.' Working: Irabot supported the movement, but the movement was led by women of the markets. The word only makes the statement false. Answer: false.
Worked example 3: counting true statements
Statements: (1) Jadonang was hanged in 1931. (2) Gaidinliu was arrested in 1932. (3) Gaidinliu received the Padma Bhushan in 1982. Working: all three agree with the facts. Answer: all three are correct.
One wrong part makes the whole statement false.
Key takeaways: split each statement, test each part, watch for words of degree, and remember the true and false twins. Counting comes last.
Check your understanding
-
1. Statements: (1) Tikendrajit was hanged on 13 August 1891. (2) Paona Brajabashi was hanged on 13 August 1891. Which is correct?
- 2 only
- 1 only
- Both 1 and 2
- Neither 1 nor 2
Show answer
Answer: B. Tikendrajit was hanged on 13 August 1891, whereas Paona Brajabashi fell at Khongjom in April.
-
2. Statements: (1) Jadonang was hanged in 1931. (2) Gaidinliu started the Heraka movement. Which is correct?
- 2 only
- Both
- Neither
- 1 only
Show answer
Answer: D. Jadonang started the movement, so statement 2 is false.
-
3. A statement says 'Mirabai Chanu won Olympic gold at Tokyo'. The error lies in:
- the colour of the medal
- the sport
- the state
- the person's name
Show answer
Answer: A. She won silver in weightlifting at Tokyo.
-
4. Statements: (1) Khongjom Day is on 23 April. (2) Patriots' Day is on 13 August. (3) Nupi Lan Day is on 12 December. How many are correct?
- Only two
- Only one
- All three
- None
Show answer
Answer: C. All three dates are correct.
-
5. Which word makes 'Garib Niwaz was the only king who supported Vaishnavism' false?
- king
- Vaishnavism
- only
- supported
Show answer
Answer: C. Bhagyachandra also supported Vaishnavism, so only makes it false.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.