- Advanced
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
What each status meant: Part C, Union Territory and State
Compare what Manipur's Part C state, Union Territory and State status meant for law-making and government, and link them to the Articles that decide them.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The earlier courses gave you the dates. This lesson asks what each status meant in practice: who made the laws, who headed the administration and what Parliament could do. Advanced questions test that understanding with statements and reasons, not with dates alone.
The legal base of each status
- Article 3 lets Parliament, by ordinary law, form new States, alter areas, boundaries and names. The creation of the State of Manipur in 1972 rests on this kind of law, the North-Eastern Areas (Reorganisation) Act, 1971.
- Article 239 says Union Territories are administered by the President through an administrator.
- Article 246(4) gives Parliament power to make laws on any subject for any part of India not included in a State, so Parliament's power over a Union Territory is complete.
- The Seventh Amendment (1956) with the States Reorganisation Act abolished the classes of Part A, B and C states and created States and Union Territories.
| Status | Head of administration | Who makes laws | Elected government? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Part C state (1950) | Chief Commissioner for the President | Parliament, with local bodies only as the Centre allowed | Limited, as the Centre allowed |
| Union Territory (1956) | Administrator appointed by the President | Parliament, plus any territorial body it allows | Not at first |
| Union Territory with assembly (1963) | Administrator | Parliament plus a territorial Legislative Assembly under the 1963 Act, with limited powers | Yes, within the Act |
| State (1972) | Governor | State Legislature on the State List and Concurrent List | Yes, full |
Union Territory versus State
-
Union Territory with assembly (1963-1972)
- Administrator appointed by the President
- Assembly powers set by Parliament's Act
- Parliament may legislate on any subject (Article 246(4))
-
State (from 1972)
- Governor is the constitutional head
- Legislature has its own constitutional list of subjects
- Council of Ministers responsible to the Assembly
The key idea: source of power
In a State, legislative power flows from the Constitution: the Seventh Schedule gives the State Legislature the State List. In a Union Territory with an assembly, it flows from an Act of Parliament that Parliament may change. That is why statehood in 1972 was a real change, not just a new name.
Worked example 1: assertion and reason
A: Manipur's change to statehood in 1972 gave it a Governor and a legislature with constitutional powers. R: States have their powers from the Constitution while Union Territories have powers from a Parliament's Act. Working: both statements are true and R explains A. In 1972 the Governor, not an administrator, headed the new State, and the Assembly drew its powers from the Seventh Schedule.
Worked example 2: who can legislate?
Question: before 1972, could Parliament make a law on a subject in the State List for Manipur? Working: yes. As a Union Territory, Manipur was outside the States, so Article 246(4) allowed Parliament to legislate on any subject for it. After 1972 Parliament cannot do this in normal times.
Worked example 3: reading the sequence
Question: why did the 1956 change not give Manipur an elected assembly? Working: the 1956 law made it a Union Territory run by an administrator. An elected assembly only came with the Government of Union Territories Act, 1963. The two steps are seven years apart.
Link with the history course
The earlier history lessons show that a popular, elected assembly was not new to Manipur: the Manipur State Constitution Act of 1947 had set one up before the merger. The 1963 assembly therefore restored an elected body that Manipur had known, though under different powers.
State: powers from the Constitution (Seventh Schedule). Union Territory: powers from Parliament; Article 246(4) allows Parliament to legislate on every subject. Article 3: Parliament forms States by ordinary law.
Key takeaways: Article 3 is the route to a new State. Union Territories are under Article 239 and Article 246(4). A State has its power from the Constitution, a Union Territory from an Act. The territorial assembly of 1963 had limited powers.
Check your understanding
-
1. Parliament forms a new State by law under:
- Article 3
- Article 239
- Article 164
- Article 246(4)
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 3 allows the formation of new States by ordinary law of Parliament.
-
2. Union Territories are administered by the President through:
- The Chief Minister
- The Speaker
- An administrator
- The Governor of a neighbouring state
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 239 provides for an administrator.
-
3. Parliament may legislate on any subject for a Union Territory because of:
- Article 3
- Article 164
- Article 213
- Article 246(4)
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 246(4) covers areas not included in a State.
-
4. Assertion (A): Statehood in 1972 changed the source of Manipur's legislative power. Reason (R): State Legislatures have powers under the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution. Choose the correct option.
- Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A
- A is true but R is false
- A is false but R is true
- Both A and R are true, and R explains A
Show answer
Answer: D. Both true; R explains A, since after 1972 the Assembly's powers came from the Constitution rather than from an Act of Parliament.
-
5. Consider the statements. Which is or are correct? 1. Manipur had an elected assembly under the 1963 Act while still a Union Territory. 2. The 1963 Act made Manipur a full State.
- 1 only
- 2 only
- Both 1 and 2
- Neither 1 nor 2
Show answer
Answer: A. Only statement 1 is true. Statehood came in 1972, under the 1971 Act.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.