- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
The Governor, the Chief Minister and the Council of Ministers
Explain who heads the government of Manipur, how the Governor and the Chief Minister differ, and to whom the ministers are answerable.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Once Manipur became a State, it was governed like every other Indian state. The Union has a President, a Prime Minister and a Council of Ministers. A state has a Governor, a Chief Minister and a Council of Ministers. This lesson helps you answer 'who appoints', 'who is answerable to whom' and 'who is the real head' questions.
The Governor
- Article 153 says there shall be a Governor for each State.
- The Governor is appointed by the President and holds office during the President's pleasure; the normal term is five years.
- The Governor must be a citizen of India who has completed 35 years of age and must not be a member of Parliament or a state legislature.
- The Governor is the constitutional (nominal) head of the state and acts mostly on the advice of the Council of Ministers.
- The Governor appoints the Chief Minister, summons the Assembly, gives assent to bills and issues ordinances when the Assembly is not in session (Article 213).
The Chief Minister
Under Article 164 the Governor appoints the Chief Minister. In practice the Governor invites the leader of the party or group that commands a majority in the Manipur Legislative Assembly. The Chief Minister is the real executive head: he or she leads the Council of Ministers and tells the Governor of its decisions. The other ministers are appointed by the Governor on the Chief Minister's advice.
The Council of Ministers
The Council of Ministers aids and advises the Governor. It is collectively responsible to the Legislative Assembly (Article 164). If the Assembly passes a vote of no-confidence, the whole Council must resign together. A minister who heads a department is also answerable for that department.
| Question | Governor | Chief Minister |
|---|---|---|
| Position | Nominal head | Real head of the government |
| How chosen | Appointed by the President | Appointed by the Governor, usually the majority leader |
| Answerable to | The President | The Legislative Assembly |
| How long | About five years | As long as the majority supports |
State executive
- Governor Nominal head, appointed by the President
- Chief Minister Real head, leads the Council of Ministers
- Council of Ministers Collectively responsible to the Assembly
The permanent civil service
Ministers decide policy; officers carry it out. The Chief Secretary heads the permanent administration and works with the secretaries of departments in the Secretariat at Imphal. Ministers change with elections, but the officers continue, which is why the civil service is called the 'permanent executive'. The Manipur Public Service Commission, created under Article 315, recruits for state posts.
Worked example 1: who is answerable to the Assembly?
Question: the Governor, the Chief Minister or the Council of Ministers: which is collectively responsible to the Legislative Assembly? Working: Article 164 makes the Council of Ministers collectively responsible. The Governor is not elected and does not answer to the Assembly. The answer is the Council of Ministers.
Worked example 2: who appoints whom?
Question: who appoints the Governor, and who appoints the Chief Minister? Working: the President appoints the Governor. The Governor appoints the Chief Minister, choosing the person who commands a majority in the Assembly. The Chief Minister's advice then decides who the other ministers are.
Worked example 3: nominal or real?
Question: orders are issued in the Governor's name, but ministers decide what they say. Who is the real head? Working: the Constitution makes the Governor the head of the executive in form, but the Governor acts on the advice of the Council of Ministers headed by the Chief Minister. The Chief Minister is the real head.
Governor: appointed by the President, nominal head. Chief Minister: appointed by the Governor, real head. Council of Ministers: collectively responsible to the Assembly.
Key takeaways: the Governor is appointed by the President and is the nominal head. The Chief Minister leads the real government. The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Legislative Assembly. The Chief Secretary heads the permanent civil service.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who appoints the Governor of a state?
- The Chief Minister
- The Speaker
- The Chief Justice
- The President of India
Show answer
Answer: D. The Governor is appointed by the President and holds office during the President's pleasure.
-
2. The real executive head of the state government is the:
- Chief Minister
- Governor
- Speaker
- Chief Secretary
Show answer
Answer: A. The Governor is nominal. The Chief Minister with the Council of Ministers runs the government.
-
3. The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the:
- Governor
- High Court
- Legislative Assembly
- Lok Sabha
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 164 makes it collectively responsible to the Assembly.
-
4. The minimum age to be a Governor is:
- 25 years
- 30 years
- 40 years
- 35 years
Show answer
Answer: D. The Constitution requires a Governor to have completed 35 years.
-
5. Which officer heads the permanent civil service of the state?
- Advocate General
- Chief Secretary
- Speaker
- Chief Minister
Show answer
Answer: B. The Chief Secretary heads the permanent administration under the ministers.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.