• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Courts and constitutional bodies: who appoints, who removes

Compare the High Court, the Public Service Commission, the State Election Commissioner, the State Finance Commission and the Advocate General by Article, appointer and term.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Bodies outside the elected government check its work. Examiners ask about the Article, who appoints, who can remove and how long the term is. A single table, learned with a rule, answers most of these questions.

One table for the bodies

Bodies compared
BodyArticleAppointed byKey rule
High Court (Manipur, Imphal)214, 217President, after consulting the Chief Justice of India, the Governor and the Chief Justice of the High CourtJudge retires at 62
Public Service Commission315, 316Governor appoints chair and membersSix years or age 62, whichever comes first
State Election Commissioner243KGovernorRemoved like a High Court judge
State Finance Commission243IGovernorSet up every five years
Advocate General165GovernorHolds office during the Governor's pleasure

Memory rule

State bodies: the Governor appoints. High Court judges are the exception: the President appoints. The President removes a Public Service Commission member, after the Supreme Court inquires.

High Court

The Manipur High Court was established in 2013 at Imphal. It has power to issue writs under Article 226, for fundamental rights and also for other purposes, so its writ power is wider than the Supreme Court's under Article 32, which is for fundamental rights. A High Court judge can be removed only in the manner provided for a Supreme Court judge, by Parliament. The High Court also supervises the subordinate courts (Articles 227 and 235).

Public Service Commission

The Manipur Public Service Commission recruits for state services. Its members are appointed by the Governor but, to protect their independence, can be removed only by the President on the report of the Supreme Court (Article 317). The Commission sends its annual report to the Governor, who places it before the Assembly (Article 323).

Appointer and remover

  • Appointed by the Governor
    • Public Service Commission members
    • State Election Commissioner
    • State Finance Commission
    • Advocate General
  • Appointed or removed by the President
    • High Court judges are appointed by the President
    • PSC members are removed by the President after a Supreme Court inquiry
    • Governor is appointed by the President
Who appoints and who removes

Worked example 1: the independence trap

Question: who appoints a member of the Public Service Commission, and who removes? Working: the Governor appoints. The President removes, after the Supreme Court has inquired and reported. Be careful: the same person does not do both.

Worked example 2: term arithmetic

Question: a Public Service Commission member is appointed at the age of 57. For how long does the term run? Working: the term is six years or until age 62, whichever is earlier. Five years take the member to 62, which is earlier than six years. So the term lasts five years.

Worked example 3: writ powers

Question: which court can issue writs for purposes other than fundamental rights? Working: Article 226 gives the High Court writ power for fundamental rights and for any other purpose. Article 32 gives the Supreme Court writ power for fundamental rights. So the answer is the High Court.

Quick revision drill

  • Cover the table and name the Article for each body: 214, 315, 243K, 243I, 165.
  • Say aloud: Governor appoints, President removes the PSC member.
  • Say aloud: High Court 62, PSC 62 or six years, whichever is earlier.
  • Note that the Manipur High Court dates from 2013 and sits at Imphal.

Key takeaways: the Governor appoints the Public Service Commission, State Election Commissioner, State Finance Commission and Advocate General. The President appoints High Court judges and removes PSC members. Learn the Articles 214, 217, 226, 315, 316, 317, 243K, 243I and 165.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The Governor appoints the:

    1. Chairperson of the State Public Service Commission
    2. Judges of the High Court
    3. The Chief Justice of India
    4. The Comptroller and Auditor General
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 316 gives the Governor the power to appoint the PSC chair and members. High Court judges are appointed by the President.

  2. 2. A Public Service Commission member can be removed by the:

    1. Governor
    2. President
    3. Chief Minister
    4. Speaker
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Article 317: removal by the President on a Supreme Court inquiry.

  3. 3. The retirement age of a High Court judge is:

    1. 58 years
    2. 60 years
    3. 65 years
    4. 62 years
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Article 217 sets 62.

  4. 4. Which Article gives the High Court its writ power?

    1. Article 32
    2. Article 214
    3. Article 226
    4. Article 165
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Article 226 covers writs from the High Court.

  5. 5. The State Finance Commission is set up every:

    1. Five years
    2. Two years
    3. Three years
    4. Ten years
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 243I provides for a Finance Commission every five years.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery