• Advanced
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Language in the Constitution: reasoning with statements

Separate a state's official language, the Eighth Schedule and the safeguards for linguistic minorities, and solve statement and assertion-reason questions about them.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Advanced questions on language rarely ask for one fact. They give two or three statements and ask which are true, or they join an assertion to a reason. To handle them you must hold the constitutional ideas apart and then test each statement on its own. This lesson builds that skill using Manipuri as the running example.

Four ideas that must stay separate

Four separate ideas
IdeaSourceWhat it does
Official language of a stateArticle 345 and the state's own lawNames the language of the state's government work
Eighth ScheduleArticles 344 and 351A national list of recognised languages; Manipuri entered in 1992 by the 71st Amendment
Mother-tongue instructionArticle 350AAsks states to try to give primary instruction in the mother tongue to linguistic minority children
Special OfficerArticle 350BAn officer to look into safeguards for linguistic minorities

Manipuri touches the first two directly. It is the official language of Manipur, and it is on the Eighth Schedule. The other two ideas apply to any language community that is a minority in a state, so they are relevant to the many mother tongues of Manipur's communities without saying anything more specific about any of them.

Do not mix these

  • State level Decided by the state
    • Official language of Manipur: Manipuri
    • Rooted in Article 345
    • Used for the state's own work
  • National level Decided by the Union
    • Eighth Schedule list
    • Manipuri added in 1992
    • Linked with Articles 344 and 351

A method for statement questions

  1. Break the question into single claims.
  2. Label each claim state-level or national-level.
  3. Check the year and the number if one is given.
  4. Look for absolute words such as always, only and never.
  5. Only then match your findings to the options.

Worked example 1: two statements

Statement I: Manipuri became the state's official language because it was added to the Eighth Schedule in 1992. Statement II: Manipuri was added to the Eighth Schedule in 1992 by the 71st Amendment. Working: Statement II is true. Statement I joins two separate facts with a false 'because', since a state's official language rests on Article 345 and the state's law, not on the Schedule. Answer: only Statement II is true.

Worked example 2: assertion and reason

Assertion: the hill languages of Manipur are not named individually on the Eighth Schedule. Reason: the Schedule lists every language spoken in each state. Working: the assertion is true. The reason is false, because the Schedule is a selected national list, not a count of every speech. Answer: the assertion is true, the reason is false.

Worked example 3: the count

Statement: after the 71st Amendment the Schedule had eighteen languages, and after the amendment of 2003 it had twenty-two. Working: fifteen plus three is eighteen, then four more in 2003 gives twenty-two. Answer: the statement is true.

Worked example 4: a three-statement problem

Statements: (1) The Eighth Schedule lists languages. (2) Article 345 lets a state adopt its official language. (3) The 71st Amendment of 1992 added four languages. Working: (1) true; (2) true; (3) false, since three languages were added: Konkani, Manipuri and Nepali. Answer: only 1 and 2.

Notice how the false statement here changed only a number. The commonest way to make a hard option is to alter one detail in an otherwise true sentence: a year, a number, an amendment, or a word such as every or solely. Read each claim twice, slowly, and compare each detail with the timeline and the table of ideas above.

Test each claim alone. Official language = state level (Article 345). Eighth Schedule = national list (Manipuri, 1992, 71st Amendment).

Key takeaways: separate the state level from the national level, test each claim alone, distrust a false 'because', and check numbers against the timeline 14, 15, 18, 22. In every case, say only what the law and the facts support.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Assertion: Manipuri is the official language of Manipur. Reason: it was added to the Eighth Schedule in 1992. Which is correct?

    1. Both true and the reason explains the assertion
    2. Assertion true, reason true, but the reason does not explain the assertion
    3. Assertion true, reason false
    4. Assertion false, reason true
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Both are true, but a state's official language rests on Article 345 and the state's law, not on the Schedule. So the reason does not explain it.

  2. 2. Which Article is about a Special Officer for linguistic minorities?

    1. Article 345
    2. Article 350A
    3. Article 351
    4. Article 350B
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Article 350B provides for a Special Officer. Article 350A is on mother-tongue instruction.

  3. 3. Statement I: the Schedule lists every language of India. Statement II: Manipuri entered it in 1992. Which holds?

    1. Only Statement II
    2. Both
    3. Only Statement I
    4. Neither
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The Schedule is a selected list, so Statement I is false; Statement II is true.

  4. 4. Fifteen languages plus those added in 1992 and 2003 give:

    1. 18
    2. 20
    3. 22
    4. 24
    Show answer

    Answer: C. 15 + 3 = 18 in 1992, then + 4 = 22 in 2003.

  5. 5. The Eighth Schedule is linked to which pair of Articles?

    1. 345 and 350A
    2. 350A and 350B
    3. 29 and 30
    4. 344 and 351
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The Schedule is referred to in Articles 344 and 351.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery