- Advanced
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Three resistances compared: what was common and what was different
Compare the Khasi, Jaintia and Garo resistances by cause, method, leader and ending, and explain why they ended differently.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
At this level, a question seldom asks for a single fact. It asks you to compare, to explain a difference, or to judge a statement that mixes true and false parts. For this you need the three resistances side by side. This lesson builds the comparison and then shows what it explains.
The comparison
| Feature | Khasi Hills | Jaintia Hills | Garo Hills |
|---|---|---|---|
| Leader | U Tirot Sing | U Kiang Nangbah | Pa Togan Nengminza Sangma |
| Time | War from 1829, capture 1833 | Early 1860s | 1872 |
| Trigger | A road across the hills and broken trust | Taxes and interference with religious life | British forces moving into the Garo Hills |
| Position before | Syiem of Nongkhlaw, a Hima | Jaintia kingdom annexed in 1835 | Land held by clans under nokmas |
| Ending | Captured; died in Dhaka in 1835 | Hanged at Jowai in 1862 | Killed in the fighting |
What was common
All three leaders fought a better-armed power in their own hills. The Khasi and Jaintia fighters used the knowledge of forest and hill to their advantage. In all three, the British gained control in the end, and within a few decades the three hill regions were part of the British province of Assam. In each case the leader gave his life or his freedom, and in each case the state remembers him with honour. These shared points answer the common question 'what did the three have in common?'
What was different
The starting point differed. The Khasi leader was a chief of a Hima, with a Dorbar to consult. The Jaintia leader rose after the old kingdom had already been annexed in 1835, so his rising was against rule that was already in place, not against a threat still to come. The Garo had no king, so their resistance came from clan leaders and fighters, not from a royal court. The trigger differed: a road, taxes and an advance of troops. The ending differed: captivity, the gallows and death in battle. Spotting the difference is the quickest way to answer 'which one of these does NOT fit?'
What each resistance shows
-
Khasi
- Chief against a frontier road
- A war over four years
- Ends in captivity
-
Jaintia
- People against taxes
- A rising after annexation
- Ends on the gallows
-
Garo
- Clans against an advance
- No king to lead
- Ends in battle
One more point helps in essay-type questions. The three heroes are remembered in different places and on different occasions, but a student should never rank them. Each stood for the same thing in his own hills, and a fair answer says so. Exams that ask for a short note on any one of them want the five points of the table: community, time, trigger, position and ending.
Worked examples
Example 1. Question: Which feature is shared by the Khasi and Jaintia heroes but not the Garo hero? Working: U Tirot Sing was captured and kept as a prisoner, and U Kiang Nangbah was captured and hanged. Pa Togan was killed in the fighting. Answer: being captured alive by the British.
Example 2. Question: Which of the three came after the annexation of the Jaintia kingdom in 1835? Working: the rising of U Kiang Nangbah in the early 1860s, and the Garo resistance of 1872 came after 1835. Answer: both of them.
Example 3. Question: How many years separate the beginning of the Khasi war from the Garo resistance? Working: 1872 minus 1829 is 43 years. Answer: 43 years.
Same hills, same courage, different triggers and different endings.
Key takeaways
- The three resistances share a cause in loss of control, but not a trigger.
- Compare by leader, time, trigger, position and ending.
- A question asking for the odd one out is answered by finding the difference.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which hero's rising came after the Jaintia kingdom was annexed?
- U Tirot Sing
- Both Tirot Sing and Kiang Nangbah
- U Kiang Nangbah
- None of them
Show answer
Answer: C. The annexation was in 1835 and the Jaintia rising in the early 1860s. The Khasi war began in 1829.
-
2. The odd one out in the ending of the three resistances is:
- Pa Togan, who was killed in the fighting
- Kiang Nangbah, who was hanged
- Tirot Sing, who was captured
- None, all ended the same way
Show answer
Answer: A. Tirot Sing was captured, Kiang Nangbah hanged, and Pa Togan died in the fighting.
-
3. The gap between 1829 and 1872 is:
- 33 years
- 53 years
- 47 years
- 43 years
Show answer
Answer: D. 1872 minus 1829 is 43.
-
4. Which community had no king or Syiem but land divided among clans?
- Khasi
- Garo
- Jaintia
- None of them
Show answer
Answer: B. The Garo had a'king land and the nokma, not a king.
-
5. The common result of the three resistances was that:
- The three hill regions came under British control
- The three became one state at once
- Shillong became a village
- Assam was divided
Show answer
Answer: A. By the end of the nineteenth century the hills were part of the province of Assam.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.