- Advanced
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Article 371G in depth: statements, comparisons and limits
Analyse what Article 371G protects and does not, compare it with the Sixth Schedule and with the Nagaland provision, and judge statements about it.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
At the advanced level, examiners do not ask what Article 371G is. They give you three or four statements about it and ask which are correct. To handle these you need to know exactly what the article protects, what it leaves out and how it differs from neighbouring provisions. This lesson trains that precision.
Reading the article closely
Article 371G begins with the word notwithstanding, which tells us that it overrides other parts of the Constitution. It then says that no Act of Parliament in four listed matters shall apply to Mizoram unless the Legislative Assembly of Mizoram decides by a resolution that it shall. The four matters are the religious or social practices of the Mizos, Mizo customary law and procedure, the administration of civil and criminal justice involving decisions according to Mizo customary law, and the ownership and transfer of land. A second part says that the Assembly shall have not less than forty members.
What the article does not do
- It does not stop Parliament from making laws on other matters. Defence, currency and foreign affairs remain Union subjects and apply fully.
- It does not forbid a central Act on a protected matter. It only requires the Assembly's resolution before such an Act applies in Mizoram.
- It does not create the Autonomous District Councils. Those come from the Sixth Schedule.
- It does not exist because of an old British rule. It came from the 1986 Peace Accord and the Fifty-third Amendment.
Comparing three tools
| Feature | Article 371G | Sixth Schedule | Article 371A (Nagaland) |
|---|---|---|---|
| State covered | Mizoram | Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura, Mizoram | Nagaland |
| Main idea | Central Acts on four matters need an Assembly resolution | Self-governing district councils with their own powers | Central Acts on Naga custom and land need an Assembly resolution |
| Who decides | The state Assembly | The councils, within the schedule | The state Assembly |
| Linked history | 1986 Peace Accord | Constitution of 1950 | Settlement of the early 1960s |
371G versus the Sixth Schedule
-
Article 371G
- Covers the whole of Mizoram
- Works by an Assembly resolution
- Protects custom, justice and land
-
Sixth Schedule
- Covers named tribal areas only
- Creates councils with law-making powers
- In Mizoram: Lai, Mara, Chakma
Examiners also use a fourth style: a statement that is almost correct but changes one word. For example, 'Article 371G requires the President's resolution' changes Assembly to President, and 'Article 371G protects Mizo defence law' changes the matter. Read the nouns in a statement slowly: who decides, what is protected, which year, and which article.
Worked example 1: judging statements
Statements: (i) Article 371G was added in 1986. (ii) It makes Mizoram a Sixth Schedule state with councils for all districts. (iii) A central Act on land applies in Mizoram only after an Assembly resolution. Which are correct? Working: (i) is correct, since the Fifty-third Amendment Act of 1986 added it. (ii) is wrong: the Sixth Schedule is separate and its councils cover only three areas. (iii) is correct. So (i) and (iii) are correct.
Worked example 2: assertion and reason
Assertion: a new central Act on civil justice does not automatically apply to cases decided by Mizo customary law. Reason: Article 371G protects the administration of justice involving Mizo customary law. Working: both statements are true, and the reason explains the assertion. The answer is that both are true and the reason is the correct explanation.
Worked example 3: the defence law
Question: does Article 371G require an Assembly resolution before a central law on defence applies in Mizoram? Working: defence is not one of the four protected matters, so no resolution is needed. The law applies in Mizoram as in every other state.
371G: four matters, Assembly resolution, minimum forty seats, born of the 1986 Accord. It is not the Sixth Schedule and not a ban on Parliament.
Key takeaways: Article 371G needs an Assembly resolution only for the four listed matters. It is separate from the Sixth Schedule. It was a result of the Peace Accord and it fixes a minimum assembly size.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which statement about Article 371G is correct?
- A central Act on land applies only if the Assembly so resolves
- It bans Parliament from making any law for Mizoram
- It creates the Lai, Mara and Chakma councils
- It was added in 1950 with the Constitution
Show answer
Answer: A. The article requires the Assembly's resolution for central Acts on the four protected matters. It does not stop Parliament in general, and it was added in 1986.
-
2. Which matter is NOT among those protected by Article 371G?
- Foreign affairs
- Ownership and transfer of land
- Mizo customary law and procedure
- Religious or social practices of the Mizos
Show answer
Answer: A. Foreign affairs is a Union subject and is not protected.
-
3. The Autonomous District Councils of Mizoram are created by:
- The Sixth Schedule
- Article 371G
- The Mizoram Peace Accord alone
- The Inner Line rules
Show answer
Answer: B. The Sixth Schedule is the source of the councils. Article 371G is a different protection.
-
4. Assertion (A): Article 371G was the result of a negotiated settlement. Reason (R): It was added by the Fifty-third Amendment after the Peace Accord of 1986. Choose:
- Both true, but R does not explain A
- A true, R false
- Both true, and R explains A
- A false, R true
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 371G was added by the Fifty-third Amendment, following the Accord, so R explains A.
-
5. Which statement is incorrect?
- Article 371G fixes a minimum of forty seats in the assembly
- The Assembly can decide that a central Act on a protected matter applies
- Article 371G was added in 1986
- Article 371G applies equally to Assam and Tripura
Show answer
Answer: D. The article is a special provision for Mizoram and not for Assam or Tripura.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.