- Advanced
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Special provisions compared: Article 371A, other articles and the Sixth Schedule
Compare Nagaland's Article 371A with the special provisions for other states and with the Sixth Schedule, and answer assertion-reason questions on them.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
At the advanced level an examiner will rarely ask only 'what is Article 371A'. A harder question sets it beside other special provisions and asks what is common and what differs. To answer well you need a clear picture of the whole family of special arrangements in the Constitution, and a way of testing statements about them.
The family of special provisions
Part XXI of the Constitution contains a set of articles numbered 369 to 392 which deal with temporary, transitional and special provisions. Among them are the articles numbered 371 and the letters after it, which give particular states particular arrangements. The ones that matter most for the north-east are in the table. Do not try to memorise every letter; learn these and the principle that each is written for one state's history.
| Article | State | One feature to remember |
|---|---|---|
| 371A | Nagaland | Parliament's Acts on Naga religious or social practices, customary law, justice by custom and land need the Assembly's resolution |
| 371B | Assam | A committee of the Assembly for tribal areas |
| 371C | Manipur | A committee of members from the hill areas |
| 371F | Sikkim | Special provisions after Sikkim became a state |
| 371G | Mizoram | Protection of Mizo customs, justice by custom and land, like 371A in spirit |
| 371H | Arunachal Pradesh | Governor's special responsibility for law and order |
The Sixth Schedule is a different tool
The Sixth Schedule deals with the administration of tribal areas in Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura and Mizoram through autonomous district and regional councils. Nagaland is not under the Sixth Schedule. Its protection comes instead from Article 371A. So one tool works through councils within a state; the other works by protecting subjects from Parliament's laws unless the Assembly agrees.
Two ways of protecting tribal self-rule
-
Sixth Schedule
- Autonomous councils with law-making powers on listed matters
- Applies to tribal areas of Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura and Mizoram
- Not applied to Nagaland
-
Article 371A
- Protects four subjects from Parliament's Acts without a resolution
- Applies to the whole state of Nagaland
- Assembly of the state is the gatekeeper
Testing an assertion and reason
In an assertion-reason question you have two sentences. First decide if each is true. Then, if both are true, ask whether the reason explains the assertion. Do the two steps separately; many marks are lost by mixing them.
Worked example 1: assertion and reason
Assertion: A Parliament Act on land ownership does not automatically apply in Nagaland. Reason: Article 371A protects ownership and transfer of land and its resources. Working: the assertion is true, because the Assembly's resolution is needed. The reason is true, and it explains the assertion. So both are true and the reason is the correct explanation.
Worked example 2: a false reason
Assertion: Nagaland is under the Sixth Schedule. Reason: Article 371A creates autonomous district councils. Working: the assertion is false, since Nagaland is not under the Sixth Schedule. The reason is also false, since Article 371A protects subjects and does not create such councils. Both are false.
Worked example 3: true but not explaining
Assertion: Nagaland became a state in 1963. Reason: Article 371A gives the Governor a responsibility for law and order. Working: both statements are true, but the reason does not explain why the state was formed in 1963. So both are true, but the reason is not the explanation.
Council model: Sixth Schedule. Resolution model: Article 371A. Check each sentence first, then the link.
Key takeaways: each special article is written for one state. Nagaland is not under the Sixth Schedule. In assertion-reason questions judge the statements separately and then judge the link.
Check your understanding
-
1. Nagaland's protection of customary law and land comes from:
- Article 371A
- The Sixth Schedule
- Article 371C
- Article 371H
Show answer
Answer: A. Nagaland is not under the Sixth Schedule. Its protection is in Article 371A.
-
2. Which state's special provision is similar in spirit to 371A, protecting custom and land?
- Assam (371B)
- Manipur (371C)
- Arunachal Pradesh (371H)
- Mizoram (371G)
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 371G protects Mizo customary law and land, much as 371A does for Nagaland.
-
3. Which of these states is NOT covered by the Sixth Schedule?
- Assam
- Nagaland
- Meghalaya
- Tripura
Show answer
Answer: B. The Sixth Schedule covers tribal areas of Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura and Mizoram.
-
4. Assertion: Article 371A gives Nagaland no special protection. Reason: The Constitution applies to Nagaland. Which is correct?
- Both true and the reason explains
- Assertion true, reason false
- Assertion is false; reason is true but does not support the assertion
- Both false
Show answer
Answer: C. The assertion is false since the article protects four subjects. The reason is true but explains nothing here.
-
5. Article 371H gives which special responsibility?
- Protection of Mizo land
- A committee for Manipur's hills
- Sikkim's merger terms
- Governor's responsibility for law and order in Arunachal Pradesh
Show answer
Answer: D. 371H concerns the Governor's special responsibility in Arunachal Pradesh.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.