- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Who appoints whom: exam traps on the executive and legislature
Practise questions on appointments and answerability in Nagaland and avoid the usual confusions between the Governor, Chief Minister, Speaker and Chief Secretary.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Examination questions on the government of Nagaland are rarely hard. They become hard only when two similar-sounding offices are mixed up. This lesson sets out the chain of appointment as a method you can reconstruct under time pressure, then lists the traps that cost marks.
The chain, reconstructed in ten seconds
Remember the sentence President, Governor, Chief Minister, ministers. Each appoints the next one: the President appoints the Governor; the Governor appoints the Chief Minister (the leader with a majority in the Assembly); the Governor appoints the other ministers on the Chief Minister's advice. Then reverse it for answerability: ministers answer to the Assembly, and the Assembly answers to the voters.
Appointment runs down, answerability runs up
- President Appoints the Governor
- Governor Appoints the Chief Minister and, on advice, other ministers
- Chief Minister Leads the Council of Ministers
- Council of Ministers Collectively responsible to the Legislative Assembly
- Legislative Assembly Elected by the voters
Offices that sound alike
| Office | Elected? | Belongs to | Common wrong guess |
|---|---|---|---|
| Governor | No, appointed by the President | Executive (formal head) | Elected by the Assembly |
| Chief Minister | Chosen from elected members, appointed by the Governor | Executive (real head) | Appointed by the President |
| Speaker | Elected by the members from among themselves | Legislature | Head of government |
| Chief Secretary | A civil servant, not elected | Permanent administration | A minister |
| Deputy Commissioner | A civil servant | District administration | Elected head of the district |
| Member of the Legislative Assembly | Elected by voters | Legislature | Appointed by the Governor |
Trap 1: confusing the Speaker and the Chief Minister
The Speaker presides over the Assembly and keeps order. The Chief Minister leads the government. A question that says 'head of the government' points to the Chief Minister; 'presides over the House' points to the Speaker.
Trap 2: the number 60
Nagaland's Assembly has 60 members. Do not mix this with the numbers of seats of other states. A majority of 60 is 31 or more, because 30 is exactly half. If a party has 30 seats and another 30, neither has a majority.
Trap 3: 'directly elected'
Directly elected by voters means chosen in a vote by the public. Only the members of the Assembly (and the Lok Sabha member) are directly elected. The Rajya Sabha member from Nagaland is elected by the MLAs. The Governor and the Chief Minister are not directly elected.
Worked example 1: decide the office
Question: The person who is the leader of the party with a majority and runs the government day by day is the: (a) Governor (b) Speaker (c) Chief Minister (d) Chief Secretary. Working: the one who leads the elected government is the Chief Minister, answer (c). The Governor is formal head; the Speaker presides; the Chief Secretary is a civil servant.
Worked example 2: a majority question
Question: After a vote, a party has 28 members in the 60-member Assembly, and supporters add 4 more. Does the group have a majority? Working: 28 + 4 = 32, which is more than 30, so it has a majority. If the supporters were 2, the total 30 would be only half, not a majority.
Worked example 3: statement check
Statement: 'The Council of Ministers is responsible to the Governor alone.' Working: wrong. It is collectively responsible to the Legislative Assembly. The Governor appoints ministers, but the ministers must keep the confidence of the Assembly.
Appointed: Governor, Chief Secretary, DC. Elected: MLA. Chosen by MLAs: Speaker, Rajya Sabha member.
Key takeaways: use the line President, Governor, Chief Minister, ministers. Do not mix the Speaker with the Chief Minister. A majority in a 60-member house is 31. Only MLAs and the Lok Sabha member are directly elected.
Check your understanding
-
1. In a 60-member Assembly, what is the smallest number that makes a clear majority?
- 30
- 29
- 31
- 35
Show answer
Answer: C. Half of 60 is 30. More than half is at least 31.
-
2. Who presides over the Nagaland Legislative Assembly?
- The Speaker
- The Chief Minister
- The Governor
- The Chief Secretary
Show answer
Answer: A. The Speaker presides; the Chief Minister leads the government.
-
3. Which of these is directly elected by voters?
- The Governor
- The Chief Secretary
- The Deputy Commissioner
- A Member of the Legislative Assembly
Show answer
Answer: D. Only the MLA is directly elected. The others are appointed.
-
4. The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to:
- The Governor alone
- The Legislative Assembly
- The Speaker alone
- The Chief Secretary
Show answer
Answer: B. Collective responsibility is to the elected Assembly.
-
5. The Rajya Sabha member from Nagaland is chosen by:
- All voters of the state
- The Governor
- Members of the Legislative Assembly
- The Election Commission
Show answer
Answer: C. Rajya Sabha members are elected by the state's MLAs.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.