• Advanced
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Multi-element analogies: the change table

Break a figure analogy with several moving parts into one rule per element, apply every rule to the third figure and use the clearest rule to strike options first.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

At the advanced level a figure analogy rarely changes just one thing. The outer shape may gain a side while a small symbol moves round the corners and an arrow inside turns. Students who try to see the whole change at a glance lose time and pick an option that gets two of the three changes right. The cure is a habit: break the pair A : B into elements, write one rule per element, then build the answer element by element. Since no pictures are possible here, every figure in this course is described in words, exactly as you should describe it to yourself in the exam hall.

Step 1: list the elements

An element is any part that can be followed from A to B on its own: the outer frame, each small symbol, each arrow, each group of dots, the shading of a region. Write them down in a column. If A has a large square, a small black circle and an arrow, you have three rows. If B has a part that A does not have, that is an element too (something was added), and a part of A missing from B was removed.

Step 2: record the attributes that change

For each element ask the same five questions: did its position change, did its orientation change (turn or flip), did its size change, did its shading change, and did its count change (sides, dots, lines)? Most elements change in only one attribute. The result is a small change table, one row per element.

A change table
ElementIn AIn BRule
Outer framesquaresquareno change
Small black circletop-left cornertop-right cornermoves one corner clockwise
Arrow insidepoints uppoints rightturns 90 degrees clockwise

Step 3: apply every rule to C, clearest rule first

Now apply each row to the matching element of C. Start with the rule you are most sure of and use it to strike out options; only then check the survivors against the other rules. A rule about count can be ambiguous (from 2 to 4 might be +2 or doubling), while a rule about position or orientation is usually clearer. Leaving the ambiguous rule till last means the options often settle it for you.

Worked example 1: three elements at once

A: a large square with a small black circle in its top-left corner and an arrow in the centre pointing up. B: the same square with the black circle in the top-right corner and the arrow pointing right. C: a large square with a small white triangle in the bottom-left corner and an arrow pointing down-left. The change table above gives two rules: the corner symbol moves one corner clockwise, and the arrow turns 90 degrees clockwise. Apply them to C. Corners clockwise run top-left, top-right, bottom-right, bottom-left, then back to top-left, so the triangle goes from bottom-left to top-left. The arrow turns from down-left by 90 degrees clockwise to up-left. The answer is a square with a white triangle in the top-left corner and an arrow pointing up-left. Notice that the triangle stays white: shading did not change from A to B, so it does not change from C to the answer.

Worked example 2: let the clear rule decide an unclear one

A: a triangle containing 2 dots. B: a square containing 4 dots. C: a pentagon containing 3 dots. The outer shape gains one side, which is clear: the answer is a hexagon. The dots went from 2 to 4, which could be +2 (giving 5) or doubling (giving 6). The options are: a hexagon with 5 dots, a square with 6 dots, a heptagon with 6 dots, and a hexagon with 4 dots. The side rule leaves only the two hexagons. Of these, 5 dots fits +2 and 4 dots fits nothing. The answer is the hexagon with 5 dots. Had you started with the dots and preferred doubling, you would have chased the heptagon and wasted time.

Worked example 3: inner and outer swap

A: a small circle inside a large triangle. B: a small triangle inside a large circle, with the small triangle shaded black. Two rules: the inner and outer shapes swap places, and the new inner shape is shaded. C: a small white square inside a large hexagon. Swap: a small hexagon inside a large square. Shade the new inner shape: the answer is a small black hexagon inside a large white square.

One row per element, one rule per row. Apply every rule to C, use the clearest rule to strike options first, and accept only an option that obeys all the rules.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

List the elements, write what happens to each, and apply the rules one at a time. Attributes that do not change from A to B must not change from C to the answer either; this alone removes many options. When a rule could be read two ways, decide it last and let the options choose between the readings. A wrong option is usually right on all elements but one, so check every row before you mark an answer.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A: a square with a small black circle in the top-left corner and an arrow pointing up. B: the circle is in the top-right corner and the arrow points right. C: a square with the small black circle in the bottom-right corner and an arrow pointing left. Which figure completes C : ?

    1. Circle in the top-right corner, arrow pointing up
    2. Circle in the bottom-left corner, arrow pointing down
    3. Circle in the bottom-left corner, arrow pointing up
    4. Circle in the top-left corner, arrow pointing right
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Two rules: the circle moves one corner clockwise and the arrow turns 90 degrees clockwise. From bottom-right the next corner clockwise is bottom-left. An arrow pointing left (270) turned 90 degrees clockwise points up (360, the same as 0). So: circle bottom-left, arrow up.

  2. 2. A: a square containing 3 dots. B: a pentagon containing 6 dots. C: a hexagon containing 4 dots. The options are a heptagon with 7 dots, an octagon with 8 dots, a hexagon with 8 dots and a pentagon with 7 dots. Which is the answer?

    1. Heptagon with 7 dots
    2. Octagon with 8 dots
    3. Hexagon with 8 dots
    4. Pentagon with 7 dots
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Square (4 sides) to pentagon (5) is one side more, so C's hexagon becomes a heptagon. Only one heptagon is offered, with 7 dots, which fits the dot rule +3 (3 to 6, so 4 to 7). Doubling would give 8, but no heptagon with 8 dots is offered, so the clear side rule settles it.

  3. 3. A: a small circle inside a large triangle. B: a small triangle inside a large circle. C: a small square inside a large pentagon. Which figure completes the analogy?

    1. A small square inside a large pentagon
    2. A small pentagon inside a large square
    3. A small square inside a large square
    4. A small pentagon inside a large pentagon
    Show answer

    Answer: B. From A to B the inner and outer shapes swap places. Swapping in C puts the pentagon inside and the square outside: a small pentagon inside a large square.

  4. 4. In the change table method, what is the first thing you do?

    1. Look at the options and pick the one that looks most like C
    2. Find the rule for the count of dots
    3. Turn C by 90 degrees
    4. List every element of A and match it with its counterpart in B
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The method starts by listing the elements of A and pairing each with its counterpart in B. Only then do you write a rule for each element and apply the rules to C.

  5. 5. A: a square with a black triangle in the top-left corner and a white circle in the bottom-right corner. B: the black triangle is in the bottom-right corner and the white circle in the top-left corner. C: a square with a black star in the top-right corner and a white square in the bottom-left corner. Which figure completes C : ?

    1. Black star top-right, white square bottom-left
    2. Black star bottom-left, white square top-right
    3. Black star top-left, white square bottom-right
    4. White star bottom-left, black square top-right
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The two symbols swap corners (equally, each moves two corners round). In C the star goes from top-right to bottom-left and the square from bottom-left to top-right. Shading does not change from A to B, so the star stays black and the square stays white.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery