- Advanced
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Counting properties: lines, regions and crossings
Find the odd figure when the difference hides in a count: straight lines, closed regions, crossing points, corners and odd or even totals.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
At the advanced level the odd figure rarely looks different. All five figures may be squares with lines drawn inside, and the difference is that one of them has four regions where the others have two, or seven lines where the others have six. You cannot see such differences; you have to count them. This lesson lists what to count, gives the one test every answer must pass, and works through examples where only counting finds the answer. All figures are described in words, as you should describe them to yourself.
The test every rule must pass
An odd-one-out rule is valid only if it puts four figures together and exactly one apart. A property that splits the figures three to two, or that gives every figure a different value, is not the rule, however striking it looks. So for each property you try, write its value under each figure and check the split. When one property gives a clean four-to-one split, that is almost always the intended answer.
What to count
| Property | How to count it | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| Straight lines | every separate straight segment, sides and inner lines | a circle has no straight lines |
| Closed regions | areas fully enclosed by lines | the outside is not a region |
| Crossing points | places where two lines cross | a corner where lines meet is not a crossing |
| Corners | points where two sides of a shape meet | add corners of separate shapes together |
| Elements | dots, small shapes, arrows | group by size or colour if needed |
After counting, look not only at the size of each number but also at its kind: odd or even, a multiple of 3, a perfect square. Four figures with 15, 21, 9 and 27 dots and one with 12 differ in parity, not in size.
Worked example 1: counting lines
Figures: (1) a square with both diagonals; (2) a pentagon with one diagonal; (3) a triangle with lines joining the midpoints of its three sides; (4) two separate triangles; (5) a square and a separate triangle. Count straight lines: (1) 4 + 2 = 6; (2) 5 + 1 = 6; (3) 3 + 3 = 6; (4) 3 + 3 = 6; (5) 4 + 3 = 7. The split is four to one, so the odd figure is (5). Notice that the number of separate shapes splits these figures three to two, so it is not the rule.
Worked example 2: counting regions
Figures: (1) a pentagon with one diagonal; (2) a square with both diagonals; (3) a triangle with one line from a corner to the opposite side; (4) a rectangle with one line parallel to a side; (5) a hexagon with one long diagonal. Lines: 6, 6, 4, 5 and 7, which gives no four-to-one split. Regions: (1) 2, (2) 4, (3) 2, (4) 2, (5) 2. The odd figure is (2). As a check, (2) is also the only figure with a crossing point, which agrees.
Worked example 3: odd and even
Figures, each made of two or three separate shapes: (1) a triangle and a square; (2) a pentagon and a square; (3) two triangles and a pentagon; (4) a heptagon on its own; (5) two pentagons. Count corners: (1) 3 + 4 = 7; (2) 5 + 4 = 9; (3) 3 + 3 + 5 = 11; (4) 7; (5) 5 + 5 = 10. The sizes vary, but four totals are odd and one is even: the odd figure is (5). The number of shapes is 2, 2, 3, 1 and 2, which is not a four-to-one split.
A valid rule puts four figures together and exactly one apart. Count lines, regions, corners and crossings, and test odd or even as well as size.
Key takeaways
When the figures look alike, count. Write each count under each figure and keep only a property that splits them four to one. Remember the traps: a circle has no straight sides, the outside is not a region, and a corner is not a crossing. If the numbers are all different, test their kind, especially odd or even.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which figure is the odd one out?
- A square with one diagonal
- A square with one line joining the midpoints of two opposite sides
- A square with both diagonals
- A square with one line from a corner to the midpoint of an opposite side
Show answer
Answer: C. Count closed regions: one inner line cuts a square into 2 regions, so the three figures with a single line have 2 each. Both diagonals cut the square into 4 regions. The square with both diagonals is also the only one with 6 lines and a crossing point, which agrees.
-
2. Which figure is the odd one out?
- Two squares side by side
- A triangle and a square
- A pentagon and a hexagon
- A triangle and a hexagon
Show answer
Answer: A. Count the sides in each figure: 4 + 4 = 8, 3 + 4 = 7, 5 + 6 = 11 and 3 + 6 = 9. Three totals are odd and one is even, so the two squares (8) are the odd one out.
-
3. Which statement about a valid odd-one-out rule is correct?
- It may put two figures apart from the rest
- It is the first difference you notice
- It must involve shading
- It puts exactly one figure apart from all the others
Show answer
Answer: D. A valid rule splits the figures four to one (or, with four figures, three to one): exactly one figure lacks the property the others share. A split of three to two is not a rule.
-
4. Which figure is the odd one out?
- A box with 15 dots
- A box with 21 dots
- A box with 9 dots
- A box with 12 dots
Show answer
Answer: D. All four numbers are multiples of 3, so that property does not separate them. Check odd or even: 15, 21 and 9 are odd, 12 is even. The box with 12 dots is the odd one out.
-
5. Which figure is the odd one out?
- A square with both diagonals
- A circle with one diameter
- A circle with two diameters crossing at the centre
- A triangle with lines joining the midpoints of its sides
Show answer
Answer: B. Count closed regions: a square with both diagonals has 4, a circle with two crossing diameters has 4, and a triangle cut by the lines joining the midpoints of its sides has 4 small triangles. A circle with one diameter has only 2 regions, so it is the odd one out.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.