• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Odd one out among shaded grids: counts and symmetry

Write each shaded grid as rows of X and dots, then compare the number of shaded squares, line symmetry and half-turn symmetry to find the odd grid.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Shaded grids are a favourite practice type, because the odd figure often differs in a property that you cannot see at a glance: how many squares are shaded, or whether the pattern is symmetrical. In this lesson every grid has three rows of three squares. We write a shaded square as X and an empty one as a dot, and give the rows from top to bottom, separated by a slash.

Three properties to test

  1. Count. How many squares are shaded? Count them for every grid.
  2. Line symmetry. A grid is symmetrical about a vertical line if every row reads the same backwards. It is symmetrical about a horizontal line if the top row is a copy of the bottom row.
  3. Half-turn symmetry. A grid looks the same after a half turn if reversing the order of the rows and also reversing each row gives the same grid.

A half turn swaps top with bottom and left with right at once. That is why we reverse both the order of the rows and each row. A grid with half-turn symmetry need not have any line of symmetry, and the reverse is also true, so test each property separately.

Worked examples

Example 1 (count). Grids: (1) XX. / .X. / ..X, (2) X.X / ... / X.X, (3) XXX / ... / .X., (4) .X. / XXX / ..., (5) XXX / X.X / .X. Working: the shaded counts are 4, 4, 4, 4 and 6. Answer: grid (5).

Example 2 (vertical line). Grids: (1) X.X / .X. / X.X, (2) .X. / XXX / .X., (3) X.X / XXX / ..., (4) .X. / .X. / XXX, (5) XX. / .X. / ... Working: in grids (1) to (4) every row reads the same backwards. In grid (5) the first row XX. does not. Answer: grid (5). The counts are 5, 5, 5, 5 and 3, so the count rule points at the same grid, which makes the answer safer.

Example 3 (half turn). Grids: (1) XX. / .X. / .XX, (2) X.. / .X. / ..X, (3) XXX / ... / XXX, (4) X.X / .X. / X.X, (5) XX. / ... / .X. Working: take grid (1). Reversing the rows gives .XX / .X. / XX., and reversing each row gives XX. / .X. / .XX, which is the same as grid (1). The same test works for grids (2), (3) and (4). For grid (5), reversing the rows gives .X. / ... / XX., and reversing each row gives .X. / ... / .XX, which is different. Answer: grid (5).

Example 4 (columns). Grids: (1) X.. / .X. / ..X, (2) .X. / X.. / ..X, (3) ..X / .X. / X.., (4) X.. / ..X / .X., (5) X.. / X.. / ..X. Working: count the shaded squares in each column, from left to right. Grid (1) gives 1, 1, 1. Grid (2) gives 1, 1, 1. Grid (3) gives 1, 1, 1. Grid (4) gives 1, 1, 1. Grid (5) gives 2, 0, 1. Every other grid has exactly one shaded square in each column. Answer: grid (5). Notice that all five grids have 3 shaded squares, so the total could not separate them: the difference was only in how the squares are spread.

Count the shaded squares. Test every row backwards for line symmetry. For a half turn, reverse the rows and also reverse each row.

Key takeaways

  • Write the grids as rows of X and dots and test mechanically.
  • Test the count first, then line symmetry, then half-turn symmetry.
  • If two different tests point to the same grid, you can be confident.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Grids: XX. / X.. / ... , ..X / .XX / ... , ... / .XX / ..X , XXX / ... / ... , X.. / XX. / X.. . Which grid is the odd one out by number of shaded squares?

    1. The fifth grid
    2. The first grid
    3. The second grid
    4. The fourth grid
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The counts are 3, 3, 3, 3 and 4. The fifth grid has 4 shaded squares.

  2. 2. Grids: X.X / ... / X.X , .X. / XXX / .X. , XXX / ... / XXX , X.X / .X. / .X. , XX. / ... / .XX . Which grid is not symmetrical about a vertical line?

    1. The third grid
    2. The first grid
    3. The fifth grid
    4. The fourth grid
    Show answer

    Answer: C. In the first four grids every row reads the same backwards. In the fifth grid the first row XX. reads .XX backwards, which is different.

  3. 3. Which grid does not look the same after a half turn? (1) X.. / ... / ..X, (2) XX. / ... / .XX, (3) .X. / .X. / .X., (4) XXX / .X. / ..., (5) XX. / .X. / .XX

    1. Grid (1)
    2. Grid (4)
    3. Grid (3)
    4. Grid (5)
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Reversing the rows of grid (4) gives ... / .X. / XXX, and reversing each row leaves that as it is, which is different from the original XXX / .X. / ... . The other four grids are unchanged by a half turn.

  4. 4. Which grid is not symmetrical about a horizontal line (top row equals bottom row)? (1) X.. / .X. / X.., (2) .XX / ... / .XX, (3) XXX / .X. / XXX, (4) X.X / XXX / X.X, (5) XX. / .X. / ...

    1. Grid (4)
    2. Grid (1)
    3. Grid (3)
    4. Grid (5)
    Show answer

    Answer: D. In grids (1) to (4) the top row is a copy of the bottom row. In grid (5) the top row is XX. and the bottom row is ..., which differ.

  5. 5. A student counts the shaded squares in five grids and gets 5, 3, 4, 5 and 6. What should they do next?

    1. Choose the grid with 6 squares
    2. Choose the grid with 3 squares
    3. Test symmetry instead
    4. Count again until four match
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The counts give no split of four to one, so counting is not the rule here. Symmetry is the next property to test.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery