- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Drawing statements: All, No, Some and Some-not
Turn the four basic statements about two groups into Venn diagrams, and see what a pair of statements tells you about three groups.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Venn diagrams are not only for choosing a picture for three words. They also show what a statement says. 'All doctors are graduates' is a claim about how two groups sit together, and a diagram makes the claim easy to check. In this lesson we learn the four basic statements and what picture each one gives.
The four statements
| Statement | Picture | What it does not say |
|---|---|---|
| All A are B | Circle A inside circle B | It does not say that all B are A |
| No A is B | Two circles that are apart | Nothing about other groups |
| Some A are B | Two circles that overlap | It does not say which members; some A may not be B |
| Some A are not B | Circle A with a part outside circle B | It does not say that no A is B |
Two warnings. First, 'All A are B' is not the same as 'All B are A'. All mangoes are fruits, but not all fruits are mangoes, so the mango circle is inside the fruit circle and not the other way round. Second, in logic 'some' means 'at least one, and possibly all'. A diagram drawn to show the statement 'Some A are B' uses an overlap, because this is the safe picture that always works.
Two statements together
When two statements share a group, draw the diagram so that both are true, and then ask what must follow. A conclusion is safe only if it is true in the diagram however the circles are drawn within the rules of the statements.
Worked examples
Example 1. 'All pens are stationery.' Working: pens form a group inside stationery. Diagram: a small circle (pens) inside a larger circle (stationery).
Example 2. 'No cat is a bird.' Working: the two groups have no member in common. Diagram: two separate circles.
Example 3. 'Some students are athletes.' Working: at least one person is in both groups. Diagram: two circles that overlap, with a common part.
Example 4. 'All dogs are animals' and 'All animals are living things.' Working: dogs inside animals, animals inside living things. Diagram: three circles, one inside the next. A safe conclusion is 'All dogs are living things', because the dog circle lies inside the living-things circle in every such diagram.
Example 5. 'All A are B' and 'No B is C.' Working: circle A is inside circle B, and circle C is apart from circle B. Since A is inside B, C is apart from A too. A safe conclusion is 'No A is C'. The statement 'Some A are C' would be false, as there is no common part.
All A are B: A inside B. No A is B: apart. Some A are B: overlap. A conclusion is safe only if it holds in every diagram that fits the statements.
Key takeaways
- Learn the picture for each of the four statements.
- 'All A are B' does not mean 'All B are A'.
- Draw both statements in one diagram before looking for a conclusion.
- If something could be drawn two ways, a conclusion that needs one of them is not safe.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which diagram shows 'All pens are stationery'?
- A circle for stationery inside a circle for pens
- A circle for pens inside a circle for stationery
- Two separate circles
- Two overlapping circles
Show answer
Answer: B. Every pen is stationery, so the pen circle lies entirely inside the stationery circle.
-
2. Which diagram shows 'No fish is a bird'?
- Two circles that coincide
- Two overlapping circles
- One circle inside the other
- Two separate circles
Show answer
Answer: D. No member is shared, so the circles are apart.
-
3. Which diagram shows 'Some teachers are poets'?
- Two overlapping circles
- Two separate circles
- Teachers inside poets only
- Poets inside teachers only
Show answer
Answer: A. At least one person is in both groups, so the circles overlap with a common part.
-
4. 'All A are B' and 'All B are C.' Which conclusion is certain?
- Some C are not B
- All C are A
- All A are C
- No A is C
Show answer
Answer: C. A is inside B and B is inside C, so A is inside C. The others are not certain, or are false.
-
5. 'All A are B' and 'No B is C.' Which conclusion is certain?
- Some A are C
- No A is C
- All C are A
- All B are C
Show answer
Answer: B. A is inside B, and C is apart from B, so C is apart from A as well.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.