- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Diagram-choosing drill: ten word sets and the traps in them
Practise choosing the right diagram for typical exam word sets, and learn to avoid traps such as wrong nesting, hidden overlaps and words that sound alike.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
This lesson is a drill. Each word set below is reduced to a pattern by testing the three pairs: always, sometimes or never. After the drill we look at the traps that cost marks.
The drill
| Words | Pair results | Pattern |
|---|---|---|
| Doctors, Engineers, Humans | Both inside Humans; doctors and engineers overlap | Two overlapping circles inside a large circle |
| Sparrow, Bird, Animal | Sparrow inside Bird inside Animal | Three nested circles |
| Lions, Tigers, Mammals | Both inside Mammals; lions and tigers apart | Two separate circles inside a large circle |
| Pen, Pencil, Eraser | None is another | Three separate circles |
| Women, Mothers, Doctors | Mothers inside Women; doctors cross both | Nested pair, with a third circle crossing both |
| Boys, Girls, Children | Both inside Children; boys and girls apart | Two separate circles inside a large circle |
| Wheat, Cereals, Plants | Wheat inside Cereals inside Plants | Three nested circles |
| Cat, Dog, Pet | Cats and dogs apart; some of each are pets, some not | Two separate circles, each crossing the third |
| Mango, Yellow things, Fruit | Mango inside Fruit; yellow things cross both | Nested pair, with a third circle crossing both |
| Square, Rectangle, Rhombus | Squares are both | Small circle in the overlap of two circles |
Traps
- The wrong container. In Cat, Dog, Pet, not every cat is a pet, so Pet is not a container. Ask 'is every cat a pet?' before nesting.
- The wrong direction. In Women, Mothers, Doctors, every mother is a woman, but not every woman is a mother. The mother circle goes inside.
- The hidden overlap. In Doctors, Engineers, Humans, it is easy to draw the doctors and engineers apart, but a person can be both.
- The sound-alike. Fruit and Yellow things sound unrelated, but some fruits are yellow, so they overlap.
Worked examples
Example 1. Boys, Girls, Children. Working: boys are children and girls are children; no boy is a girl. Answer: two separate circles inside a large circle.
Example 2. Pen, Pencil, Eraser. Working: a pen is never a pencil, a pen is never an eraser, and a pencil is never an eraser. Answer: three separate circles. (If a question gave 'Stationery' as the third word, the pattern would change.)
Example 3. Women, Mothers, Doctors. Working: every mother is a woman, so Mothers is inside Women. Some doctors are mothers and some are women who are not mothers, and some doctors are men. Answer: the Doctors circle crosses both. Every part of the drawing is consistent with these facts.
Example 4. Cat, Dog, Pet. Working: no cat is a dog. Some cats are pets and some are not, and the same for dogs. Answer: two separate circles, each overlapping a third.
Example 5. Mango, Yellow things, Fruit. Working: every mango is a fruit, so Mango is inside Fruit. Some mangoes are yellow when ripe and some are green or red, so Yellow things cross Mango. Some yellow things are not fruit, such as a yellow pencil, so Yellow things also stick out of Fruit. Answer: a Mango circle inside a Fruit circle, with a third circle crossing both.
Example 6. Square, Rectangle, Rhombus. Working: every square has four right angles, so it is a rectangle, and four equal sides, so it is a rhombus. Not every rectangle is a rhombus and not every rhombus is a rectangle, so those two circles overlap. The overlap holds exactly the squares. Answer: a small circle in the overlap of two circles.
Test every pair. Then look for the group that contains the others; if there is none, the pattern is overlaps or separate circles.
Key takeaways
- Ask 'always, sometimes or never' for each pair.
- Ask whether a word is truly a container before nesting.
- Direction matters: the smaller group goes inside.
- Check the final drawing against all three pairs.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which diagram fits Boys, Girls, Children?
- Three nested circles
- Two overlapping circles inside a large circle
- Two separate circles inside a large circle
- Three separate circles
Show answer
Answer: C. Boys and girls are both children, and no boy is a girl, so they are apart inside the Children circle.
-
2. Which diagram fits Pen, Pencil, Eraser?
- Two separate circles inside a large circle
- Three nested circles
- Three overlapping circles
- Three separate circles
Show answer
Answer: D. None of the three is a kind of another and none can be another, so the circles are separate.
-
3. Which diagram fits Women, Mothers, Doctors?
- Three separate circles
- A small circle (Mothers) inside Women, with Doctors crossing both
- Three nested circles
- Doctors inside Women, with Mothers crossing both
Show answer
Answer: B. All mothers are women. Some doctors are mothers and some are women who are not, so Doctors crosses both.
-
4. Which diagram fits Cat, Dog, Pet?
- Two separate circles, each crossing a third circle
- Two separate circles inside a large circle
- Three nested circles
- Three crossing circles
Show answer
Answer: A. Cats and dogs are apart, and some of each are pets and some are not, so each crosses the Pet circle.
-
5. Which diagram fits Wheat, Cereals, Plants?
- Two separate circles inside a large circle
- Three separate circles
- Three circles, each inside the next
- Three crossing circles
Show answer
Answer: C. Wheat is a cereal and every cereal is a plant.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.